Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Submitted by Thomas A. Harper


Were it not for this alternative, the impotence or cowardice of the local news media would have left us without an avenue through which to express legitimate concerns regarding the administration of certain sectors of the people’s affairs.

While we are aware that democracy is only a process through which we get to elect our dictators, we must exercise what freedom we still have to express our views, even as the press cowers behind its self-imposed iron curtain.

Be that as it may, in view of certain recent disturbing trends emerging within our judiciary that are excusably perceived to be bringing comfort to none other than the lawless, the following questions must be asked.

Is it now impossible to commit murder in Barbados?

Has the right to say no to sex on demand at anytime or under any conditions or circumstances been revoked?

Is saying no to sex on demand at any time and under any conditions or circumstances now reclassified as provocation?

Is it now the legal position that brutally killing a person for saying no to sex on demand at any time and under any conditions or circumstances be considered a provocation?

Is it now the legal position that saying no to sex on demand at any time and under any conditions or circumstances considered a provocation the magnitude of which evokes more sympathy for the killer than it does for the victim?

Why has it becoming increasingly and alarmingly difficult to distinguish the role of the prosecutor from that of the defense attorney?

Why do pleas accepted and sentences handed down for taking a life cease to reflect punishment that fits the crime, or come even remotely close to justice appearing to have been done?

Is plea-bargaining (which very closely resembles legalized perjury) that facilitates the perpetrators desire for a slap on the wrist not a slap in the face of their victims?

Is the ever increasing easy access to the plea bargain designed to eliminate the work required to prove the commission of the actual crime committed, thereby   facilitating the desire for shorter work days and getting everyone home early?

With the ever reducing options of self-defense open to victims of criminal assault, what message do these disturbing trends sent to callous killers, and perpetrators of heinous crime, or is the message intended for us their future victims?

I am fully aware that posing queries of this nature is like tiptoeing through the an over active minefield, and that they are very likely to arouse more rancor for the person posing them than for the perpetrator of senseless brutal killings. However, someone must seek to raise awareness of a problem that left unaddressed will inevitably bring us very close to the Jamaica experience. Unlike the press, being neither impotent or cowardly, I have chosen to be that someone who dares raise awareness of these troubling emerging trends, and call for recognizable justice to be restored, and bear any consequences of so doing.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


  1. @Anthony
    The appointment by the PM is not as bad as it seems. THe judicial system is the long arm of the government and the CJ appointment like any other branch of government should be appointed by the PM.Lawyers and judges are a clique and should remain neutral on such matters


  2. if the law has to be changed to accomodate the chief justice designate; then it is clear to me that the offer was made without due diligence undertaken and the govt should come out and admit their errorr and say sorry to the public of barbados and apologise to mr gibson for the gaffe; and not try to gain political mileage by fooling the public that the change in the law is to the benefit of the public. the decent thing to do is to admit their mistake. and the govt seems to be making some mistakes in the area of constutional law as it relates to good governance. first, it was mr ezra alleyne who questioned the procedures used in appointing mr brathwaite on the occasion of the illness of the prime minister; then there is a deafening silence concerning the holding of the position of minister of drainage. has mr lowe returned to work and if so, is mr kellman still paid as acting minister and if so, is there someone holding the consett bay post of ambassador to caricom with special responsibilties to solve the fish crisis?


  3. Looks like Friday will be an interesting day to listen to house debate.

     

    CJ law debate on Friday

    Attorney General and Minister of Home Affairs Adriel Brathwaite. (FP)
    By Chris Gollop | Sat, March 12, 2011 – 11:05 PM

    ANY QUALIFIED BARBADIAN who is willing to serve the country in a professional capacity should not be denied that opportunity because of antiquated laws, says Attorney General and Minister of Home Affairs Adriel Brathwaite.

    Brathwaite is expected to lead off debate on Friday as Government moves to amend the Supreme Court of Judicature Act.

    The proposed changes to the legislation have come in for strong criticism from the Opposition Barbados Labour Party (BLP), with former Attorney General Dale Marshall charging that Government was only amending the legislation to allow for United States-based Barbadian jurist Marston Gibson to become the island’s next Chief Justice.

    Under the current leglisation, Gibson would not be eligible for that post because he has not practised law in Barbados or in another part of the Commonwealth for a period, or periods amounting in aggregate to 15 years or more.

    The new legislation however would allow for the candidate for the office to be practising in a Commonwealth or “common law” jurisdiction – that would include the United States.

    Brathwaite told the Sunday Sun that the law was not being amended for any single individual; but rather for “a qualified Barbadian – whether he or she is a dentist, doctor or architect – who is willing to serve the country, and has all the right credentials [who] should not be denied the opportunity to do so because of antiquated laws”.

    Gibson, a Rhodes Scholar, who currently sits on the bench in New York, has already indicated his interest in taking up the job that has remained vacant since the end of 2009 when Sir David Simmon’s term of office expired.


  4. Far as i understand kellman is still minister of environment. Yes friday will be interesting. They really pushing hard. Does it have enough time to pass thru senate and get gazetted for april 1. It looking like they might still miss the date still.


  5. Is Mr. Gibson actually currently sitting on the bench in the US (Which I take it means that he is a full judge in the US) or is he a Judicial referee, a Judge’s assistant? If he is a judicial referee and not a judge is that section of Mr. Chris Gollop’s article somewhat misleading?


  6. he is court attorney/referee and is still listed in their directory
    http://www.courts.state.ny.us/courts/10jd/nassau/supreme_directory.shtml#Referees


  7. the headline in the nation of tuesday, march the eigth boldly proclaimed “LAWYERS BACK MOVE TO CHANGE SUPREME COURT OF JUDICATURE ACT” two things came to mind. one was the spineless fourth estate.(lord. how i miss Mr Gladstone Holder) could i not have been treated to a more realistic apportionment of the facts judging from the pronouncements of the president of the bar association about a week ago. was the decision a unanimous one as the headline sought to display? was this a case of partisan politics rearing its ugly head? how difficult would it have been for the reporter to investigate the composition of the vote and post a headline which would have effectively capture the mood of the meeting which gave support to the iniquitous amendment. the second thing which comes to mind is the spineless capitulation of the bar association to an amendment on hindsight despite its supposed merits which in my view was brought for the wrong reasons at the wrong time. i think a caption titled “ABOUT TURN BY THE BAR ASSOCIATION ” would have been more apt given the president and Mr Ralph Thorne’s previous comments on the matter.


  8. You quite right ruth, I think this was majority opinion of the council and no one else. Barbados today reported the dep. opposition leader as saying no one ever called to ask his or his firm opinion in matter nor other lawyer he contacted.


  9. Bar brew
     

    President of the Barbados Bar Association, Andrew Pilgrim. (FP)
    By Tim Slinger | Sun, March 13, 2011 – 12:11 AM

    CONFUSION IS BREWING over the Barbados Bar Association’s recent announcement it is supporting Government’s move to amend the Supreme Court of Judicature Act to facilitate the appointment of United States-based jurist Marston Gibson as next Chief Justice.

    Several members of the Bar’s executive council have expressed disapproval and have charged that the statement is null and void since it was never discussed or approved.

    In a heated exchange of emails, of which the DAILY NATION was able to obtain copies, one council member declared not being in agreement with the announcement, since the fundamental issue was whether the legislation “should be amended to accomodate the appointment of a particular person”.

    Noting there should be no siding with anyone’s political agenda, another council member said the Bar should only be concerned with what was right and legal.

    Another council member queried whether the Bar’s position should not have been okayed in its first draft state before it was disseminated to the Press.

    “This is an extremely important legal development that must not be dismissed as if it were a proposal for two-way traffic along the entire length of Roebuck Street.”

    When reached yesterday, president Andrew Pilgrim said he was aware of the brewing controversy.

    “Council has mixed views on the issue. A number of members of the Bar have expressed the fact that they don’t support the Bar’s statement. Some others have expressed support for it,” he told the DAILY NATION.


  10. toac- the problem in having the appointment of the most important post in jurisprudence in barbados in the hands of a politician and a single politician as well is very dangerous and compromises impartiality in all respects. the other issue is that if the appointment turns out to be a badone, the country is still saddled with the appointment when the pm leaves office be it after one day or several years. justice must only be done it must be seen to be done.


  11. @David. Interesting lead story in the Nation today. Seems that Sir Roy Marshall has weighed in on the subject of our justice system and he is not a happy little camper. He has, in fact, echoed the essence of what BU has been saying for a long time. He also appears, without actually coming out and saying it, to give support to the appointment of Marston Gibson. That is one major lash at the justice system from a man who is undoubtedly Barbados’ most important legal scholar. Until now, I suspect that many Bajans had no real concept of how grave the situation has become. BU has not been understating the seriousness at all. In fact, it is more serious than most non-legal people realise. Something HAS to be done……and fast. Otherwise it will adversely affect the whole structure of our financial sector and of our everyday lives. The sooner Mr Gibson can get here and start work, the better. I can tell you now that ultimatums have been delivered to some of the judges and legal proceedings are even now being prepared against some of them. What sort of message does that send to foreign investors? But the judiciary has left no other option open to litigants.


  12. @Ruth
    Then what would be your suggestions, AS it is the legal system as is is corrupt and they having to choose one from among themselves would be suspect!


  13. yes, justice in barbados has always been compromised against those who can least afford and has been more compromised now moreso with the hindsight after the fact amendment. i note professor roy marshall’s comments that barbados should look for the brightest and best to serve wherever they are. for those in aggreement with the proposed amendment, please note that he did not say outside the ambit of the law.


  14. @Amused

    Indeed and thanks to you and the others who have posted or emailed us info to give this important matter on the front burner. Here is the Sir Roy article you referred to in the Nation. As you say ordinary Barbadians have no clue and the ones in the know don’t want change because of narrow political interest. Remember he President of the T&T Law Society echoed concerns as well yet we have those who would stick their heads in the sand.

    Shame!

    By Wade Gibbons | Fri, March 18, 2011 – 12:10 AM

    LEGAL LUMINARY Sir Roy Marshall says the administration of justice in Barbados has deteriorated to the stage where it has become an embarrassment.

    Sir Roy told the WEEKEND NATION that in a well regulated and run country, prisoners should not be on remand for periods that were sometimes in excess of what their sentences might have been.

    “One of my constant preoccupations is the state of the administration of justice in Barbados, and for that matter, much of the Caribbean. To be brutally frank, I think our present system has deteriorated to a point that is embarrassing,” he said.

    Sir Roy stated that keeping people on remand for inordinately long periods appeared to be standard practice and begged the question whether there were sufficient magistrates and judges.

    “Is the machinery for ensuring speedy trials adequate? Are the time frames for transacting a citizen’s legal business acceptable, and are the processes for charging fees and handling clients’ monies transparent and properly monitored?” he asked.

    Sir Roy, a former vice-chancellor of the University of the West Indies, said none of these burning issues was seemingly being pursued with any sense of urgency. As a result, he added, there was severe public discontent and growing mistrust that threatened the reputation of the legal profession as a whole.

    Call for changes

    The former chairman of the National Commission on Law and Order called for changes in how members of the legal profession were policed.

    “In Barbados the concept of self-regulation is an illusion, because comprehensive machinery for that regulation can hardly be said to exist. Our current arrangement, the Disciplinary Committee of the Barbados Bar Association, is generally reluctant to act against its own, except in the most egregious of cases.

    Sir Roy said that in Barbados the British tradition that the learned professions could be trusted to police themselves was accepted. But he added that in Britain there was strong and effective legislation to regulate the conduct of legal practitioners, and a very powerful, well funded, and serious enforcement body – the Law Society – which ensured that the client was protected.

    He said the level of the quality of the judiciary was fundamental to the proper running of the country, adding it was a sad fact that very few of Barbados’ leading lawyers had the ambition to join the Bench.

    He said it was imperative that Barbados continued to search for its brightest and best, wherever they might be located.


  15. Amused;

    Your oft quoted thesis about the judical system in Barbados and the need for it to be thoroughly revamped has again been corroborated by a leading impartial authority. Kudos to you.

    My problem has been that you and others seem to see Marston Gibson as a messiah, riding in on his white horse, with a mandate to change the system and with all the necessary brain power, money and support from the Government to do the job.

    Besides the vaunted capabilities of Marston Gibson, what else is necessary to effect the desired changes? Doesn’t some strategic support from his colleagues in the judicial system come near the top of the list? The statement from the Bar association suggested that such support might be forthcoming but since then it appears that that support was somewhat contrived. Will that support eventually improve to be adequate for change given the way how current senior legal people are beneffitting from and using the current system?

    My other problem was how could we be so certain that Mr. Gibson, though eminently qualified for the job at the “brightest and best” level, was similarly qualified at the level of showing that he has the guts to take on and defeat the current legal establishment as well as to the “stick to it” level. How do we know that when serious problems occur, as they must if he truly tries to fulfill the mandate you have given him, that he will push and persist and try everything necessary to succeed and not run to New York or some other common law country as he appears to have done before?

    As I’ve said before, I wish him well. It appears that the legal system in Barbados needs nothing less.


  16. @checkit-out

    It is all about judgment by those doing the recruiting and leadership. It will be the remit of Gibson to lead. What should be obvious, and has been confirmed on both sides of the divide, Gibson is from outside the inner circle gives him the opportunity to deliver. From where BU sits he will have some influential players to provide support.

  17. Super Politician Avatar
    Super Politician

    First & Foremost our ‘constitution’ (HAS BEEN) compromised countless in the past, it is the ignorance and lack of knowledge of SOME bajans that has led to this. We do not cherish our history so we do not even know what our constitution consists of. Bajans died for the establishment of the constitution & Independence from colonial government. Both parties have done it to facilitate the financial stake holders and investors in their campaign, in many cases Building Permits, operating Licenses etc. It is the norm now but my view is that the law needed change for a while now however i did not expect the change would come in the form of Political Gifts to individuals who stand outside of the constitutional requirements for chief judge, mind you, clerical officers in the service who have acquired degrees and are held back by minor requirements. The constitution needed change but for the right reasons and not the interests of private & (Equal) pressures.


  18. “Bajans died for the establishment of the constitution & Independence from colonial government”.

    When did this war of independence occurred?


  19. correction occur


  20. maybe the politician is inferring that the riots of 1937 was for a constitution & independence instead of demands for social equality and labour reforms ?


  21. … or maybe to the 1651 invasion of Barbados by Ayscue resulting in fighting and dying.

    First to get hit was an Alleyne who supported the Parliamentary forces. I believe he held the rank of Colonel.

    The story goes he was coming ashore in a boat when he was shot by the Royalists.

    The Parliamentary forces won but weren’t strong enough to hold the island.

    So the two factions signed The Charter of Barbados at Oistins.

    This predated the American Declaration by over a century.

    In fact, you will find Bajans were involved in the drafting of the American Declaration, and of course George Washington spent time here.

    Both documents probably have their genesis in the Magna Carta.

    I was told that Erroll Barrow always said Barbados was independent since 1651 and the 1966 declaration was a mere formality.

    So yes, Bajan blood was shed to gain independence.


  22. This formed the Charter of Barbados. This charter gave Barbados the guarantee of new government with a governor, an elected assembly, and freedom from taxation without local consent.

    I don’t really thing that is independence. They UK still governed our defence and security. without those there is no independence.


  23. @checkit-out | March 18, 2011 at 8:45 AM | I am not for one moment suggesting that Marston Gibson will turn out to be the messiah of the Barbados justice system. We don’t know and only time will tell.

    What I AM saying is that he has the POTENTIAL to be the messiah of the justice system. I also happen to sincerely believe that he has the WILL to do the job.

    However, all I or anyone can do is to wait and hope and see. But that is true of anyone who may be appointed as chief justice. And do you seriously think that we will not all be watching him to make sure he does the job?

    What I am ALSO saying is that it is high time that those with narrow political agendas threw those agendas away and stood solidly behind Chief Justice Gibson to facilitate the changes that are urgently required – IN THE INTERESTS OF BARBADOS!!!!

    @ruth arnetta | March 18, 2011 at 5:41 AM | I am not sure on what basis we are blessed? with your legal opinion, but I, respectfully, disagree. The government has moved wisely and prudently to head off the meritless challenges and time-wasting challenges to the appointment of Chief Justice Gibson, as articulated by you. The government has decided to put the interests of the majority above the meritless political posturings of the minority.

    @islandgal246. Always a pleasure to read your submissions.


  24. anthony

    If you check you will find that the British Army was not Garrisoned here until 1780, 150 years after settlement, and only because the French were making a nuisance of themselves at the time.

    Until then defence was handled by the Barbados Militia which would have seen action for example when they drove off the Dutch admiral de Ruyter in 1655 from their fort where the Hilton Hotel now exists and again a century later in skirmishes with American privateers on the West coast.

    The expedition that captured Jamaica had a strong Bajan contingent and again more than a century later, Barbados contributed to the armed forces that took Guadeloupe in 1794.

    So make no mistake, Bajans shed their blood in the defence of their country. Most certainly, England assisted as well.


  25. Amused,

    I really hope for you sake and for Barbados’, Mr Gibson to quote you”What I AM saying is that he has the POTENTIAL to be the messiah of the justice system. I also happen to sincerely believe that he has the WILL to do the job.”

    He attended Foundation with my brother, a little ahead of me. I hope he does well. But I can tell you trying to be different in the public service is no mean task. I foolishly left the private sector at one time in my career and joined the public sector.

    Needless to say, I did not stay very long. I was told we have done things this way for ever. I tried to make suggestions on improving the ways things could be done more effectively and met bare roadblocks. I was then despised, talked about, they had problems with my clothes, the car I drove and they even came to see where I live.

    And so, I could only wish Mr Gibson luck in trying to change the status quo. As soon as he tries to make changes, the roadblocks will go up and they will tell him he just came and he aint from ’bout here. Believe it or not. The public sector is a strange place.


  26. @Prodigal Son: “The public sector is a strange place.

    At the end of the day, who pays for it?


  27. @Chris. You are, of course, quite right. However, Prodigal Son is taking a realistic view and he is right too, in my humble opinion. I think,though, that the winds of change are blowing strongly at hurricane force and it must be clear that not only the public is fed up with the justice system, but a majority of the lawyers too. And if blood (metaphorical) has to flow, it will be that of the Registry and the Judiciary. I suspect that Sir Roy’s comments have started the blood-letting. Notice how there has not been a single word from the Spratt, whose initials I understand are DS? Game, set and match – and BU, not any other, broke this major story. Kudos to David!!!!


  28. The amendment to the Judicature Act second reading is currently being tabled by the Attorney General.

    You can listen to CBC 100.7 to follow.


  29. @Amused

    I think we all hope whoever is appointed to the CJ position can clean up the judiciary. If he/she can is another matter entirely.

    @John

    Unless security as actually vest in barbados by legislature the point is mute if we police our selves or via foreign powers. They can be overruled at any time making us not independent.


  30. Someone needs to teach this government TACT sooner rather than later. And why is that Suckoo is being told by clerks in Parliament what the Opposition is going to do?


  31. Because the clerks are Dems. Suckoo is one of the biggest disappointments in modern politics.


  32. Mr Gibson C J of Barbados
    Mr. Gibson CC of West Indies Cricket Team

    These Gibson face big tasks
    We need to pray for them


  33. BLP currently attempting to filibuster.


  34. How an astute lawyer like the PM could let a dentist outdo him in an argument about law?


  35. @enuff
    I just tuned in. What are you referring to???


  36. @Enuff

    It is obvious the BLP is prolonging the matter for political gain.

    Division was call on an adjournment motion tabled by Payne which was defeated 19-9.


  37. @ david

    but isn’t the government rushing it so that he can be appointed before the acting cj appointment has to be extended again.


  38. @anthony

    We know that they are but will adjourning the debate change the opposition argument? The BLP is on record as stating it is against the appointment.


  39. true but regardless of what they say on the issue it will go thru the parliament.


  40. David
    Is it not funny how the government is trying to deny the fact that Mr. Gibson is the CJ designate?


  41. @enuff

    unless he said he no longer whats it after all this nonsense.


  42. @enuff

    The debate is to amend the Supreme of Judicature Act to change the word ‘commonwealth’ to ‘common law’. That is what is before the house. We all know what triggered it but the procedure which guides parliamentary debate precludes reference to Gibson and the appointment.


  43. actually that is incorrect david that added sub paragraphs for the common-law separate from the commonwealth sub paragraphs. They could have added commonwealth and/or common law jurisdiction and we could have done this last year.


  44. @ David
    Stupse.


  45. Done. That is all that counts. Time to welcome CJ Gibson home. Now, let us see where we go from here.


  46. Let’s hope this new ALMIGHTY C.J Gibson lives up to all you law adjusters expectations, now the pressure is on him to deliver. For government’s sake, the Barrack affair would go in favor of them, also too Clico will be given a lifeline and not only policyholders will suffer but all barbados because the government will bailout the company in order to protect certain persons who find themselves creatures of a shady person like Parris. I seriously hope that things improve in this country, because we might have thrown the last dice.


  47. Sounds good to me! Now how about some integrity legislation.being the next order of business . As Mia said the people must have confidence in government to avoid anarchy and controversy. Passing Integrity Legislation would do so at this time to restore the people confidence. A Few more hours burning of the midnight candle would be a good thing to restore such confidence.


  48. @Amused

    Isn’t it incredibility hypocritical that the BLP members of parliament would speak to principle on the issue of appointing the CJ Gibson but would turn a blind eye to using the same yardstick when a politician was appointed to the position?

    They console themselves after the fact that Simmons did his job impartially and or he had retired from politics.


  49. anthony | March 18, 2011 at 7:29 PM |

    Unless security as actually vest in barbados by legislature the point is mute if we police our selves or via foreign powers. They can be overruled at any time making us not independent.
    ++++++++++++++++++++++++++

    History speaks pretty loudly, in fact louder than words ….. nothing mute about it.


  50. The BU household congratulates and welcomes Marston Gibson to the crucially important job of Chief Justice of Barbados. We have confidence that he has the goods to make a difference, even his detractors agree he is a good man.

    BU will continue to direct our voice on legal and other matters. No longer will CJ Gibson or others have to worry about the actions of some being done in the dark of the night protected by the fear of the fourth estate.

    To Dale Marshall who referred to the blogs, newspapers and talk shows having their say, as far as we are away only one* blog championed this matter.

    BU thanks all those who participated in this debate, your views were read by many with stakeholder interest.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending