Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Submitted by Thomas A. Harper


Were it not for this alternative, the impotence or cowardice of the local news media would have left us without an avenue through which to express legitimate concerns regarding the administration of certain sectors of the people’s affairs.

While we are aware that democracy is only a process through which we get to elect our dictators, we must exercise what freedom we still have to express our views, even as the press cowers behind its self-imposed iron curtain.

Be that as it may, in view of certain recent disturbing trends emerging within our judiciary that are excusably perceived to be bringing comfort to none other than the lawless, the following questions must be asked.

Is it now impossible to commit murder in Barbados?

Has the right to say no to sex on demand at anytime or under any conditions or circumstances been revoked?

Is saying no to sex on demand at any time and under any conditions or circumstances now reclassified as provocation?

Is it now the legal position that brutally killing a person for saying no to sex on demand at any time and under any conditions or circumstances be considered a provocation?

Is it now the legal position that saying no to sex on demand at any time and under any conditions or circumstances considered a provocation the magnitude of which evokes more sympathy for the killer than it does for the victim?

Why has it becoming increasingly and alarmingly difficult to distinguish the role of the prosecutor from that of the defense attorney?

Why do pleas accepted and sentences handed down for taking a life cease to reflect punishment that fits the crime, or come even remotely close to justice appearing to have been done?

Is plea-bargaining (which very closely resembles legalized perjury) that facilitates the perpetrators desire for a slap on the wrist not a slap in the face of their victims?

Is the ever increasing easy access to the plea bargain designed to eliminate the work required to prove the commission of the actual crime committed, thereby   facilitating the desire for shorter work days and getting everyone home early?

With the ever reducing options of self-defense open to victims of criminal assault, what message do these disturbing trends sent to callous killers, and perpetrators of heinous crime, or is the message intended for us their future victims?

I am fully aware that posing queries of this nature is like tiptoeing through the an over active minefield, and that they are very likely to arouse more rancor for the person posing them than for the perpetrator of senseless brutal killings. However, someone must seek to raise awareness of a problem that left unaddressed will inevitably bring us very close to the Jamaica experience. Unlike the press, being neither impotent or cowardly, I have chosen to be that someone who dares raise awareness of these troubling emerging trends, and call for recognizable justice to be restored, and bear any consequences of so doing.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


  1. Hasn’t the system (legal) placed the media in a corner where it can’t speak about the system (legal and otherwise)?


  2. Not slowly or steadily, it HAS been compromised. It has become quite clear that the criminal is received with sympathy in the courts, and the implication is that the victim probably “deserved it”. I also could not believe it when the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) dropped murder charges against a killer whose sole reason for perpetrating the act was that he was refused sex on demand. Does the same DPP go home and tell his wife that, as a mere woman, she has no right to refuse sex? That if she refuses sex she deserves all that she gets? Violent crime is now rampant in Barbados and they can quote all the visitor arrival figures they want – when they start to fall off again, don’t necessarily look to economic reasons for the problem.


  3. Part of the orderly society which has been the foundation of Barbados society through the years has been the confidence in our law and order system. It is starting to become unraveled despite the protestations by the legal profession.

    Is it we have become educated fools and we cannot see the weeds sprouting on the lawns?


  4. Justice must not only be done, but it must be seen to be done and justice delayed, is justice denied.
    It would appear that Dale Marshall and Ariel Brathwaite – two recent Attorneys General of Barbados, Owen Arthur – a former Prime Minister and Charles Leacock – current Director of Public Prosecutions have never heard of these two Axioms of British Jurist Prudence and if they have, they do not believe it and they certainly do not care about them. In short, none of these men care anything about justrice or the administration of it in this island.
    Since August 2006, I have been trying to engage all of these men in meaningful dialogue about the administration of justice in Barbados. People are committing all kinds of crimes in this island – ranging from perjury to murder with impunity and these men and others to whom have been entrusted the sacred trust and responsibility to administer, defend and uphold the administration of justice on this island, continue, on a daily basis to turn a blind eye and a deaf ear to the perpetration of the ensuing injustices and the pleas and cries of the victims and their families.
    When they are approached, they become defensive, accusatory and with outright cowardice, hide and elope through back doors, leaving you waiting for them. They also promise to get back in touch with you, but never.
    An email was sent to the Attorney General citing a case in England, in which a mother was sent to jail for eight years for trying to pervert the course of justice, while a female on this island was not even interviewed by the police and the DPP and the Attorney General see nothing wrong with or similar in nature or deed between the two females for similar acts. However, the Attorney General contacted the writer of the email and accused the writer of sending him rude and obnoctious emails.
    How can justice be had on this island, when the very instruments required to do it do not exist on this island – Transcripts of the procedings of the Coroner’s Court. The lack of proper forensic facilities on this island and the absence of trained forensic personnel. How can we have forensic personnel and police officers who are not naturally curious and inquisitive or trained to be? Every time the police appear at a scene, it MUST BE SEEN as a potential crime scene. And even if it is not a crime scene, every effort MUST be made to preserve and recover ALL evidence. If one wants to have an easy life as a criminal, then Barbados is the place to choose to practice your trade/profession. Barbados is a holiday and criminal paradise. If the criminal justice and judiciary systems do not get their acts together, take their responsibilities seriously and vigorously persue ALL who will seek to persue criminal activities on this island and bring them to justice and prosecute them to the fullest extent of the law, then it is only a matter of time, before the life blood of this island, Tourism, is very seriously and adversely affected and Barbados is plunged into the pit of economic chaos and ruin.
    The water is never missed until the well runs dry. Barbados and ALL Barbadians had better awake from our slumber and sleep and stand on guard, before it is too late and we loose what it has taken over three hundred years to aquire.
    Our elected officials, our judiciary, our police and every resident and visitor to these shores MUST come together, pool our resources and actively and robustly wage war on crime, criminals and criminal activity.

  5. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar
    Carson C. Cadogan

    OFFTOPIC(you can skip if you so desire)

    taken from Barbados Free press:-

    Corruption and corrupt people now rule the BLP

    The Barbados Labour Party is becoming a war zone with the ‘gang of five’ now trying desperate measures to destroy “the decent four.” They cannot get Mia Mottley or William Duguid because they have pedigree so the soft targets in that mix are Rawle Eastman and Cynthia Forde. We have already told you that Clyde Mascoll will be the BLP’s candidate in St. Thomas, while Douglas Skeete (George Payne’s cousin) will replace Rawle Eastman in St. James North., hence a scheme had to be hatched and carefully executed, to discredit Forde and Eastman.

    Of the two, Rawle’s illness (serious diabetic) makes him the softer target. Everyone knows that Rawle Eastman was seriously ill for a long time and was even given long leave from Parliament, ever since his appearance on the call-in-programme sounding incoherent. Our reports are that he often has to rely on strangers when he fails to eat properly and on time and that makes him vulnerable to be exploited. George Payne knows that and enters Haniyfa Reza White, stage right.

    Who is paying the legal fees for murder accused Haniyfa Reza White (the woman now stalking Rawle Eastman) in her counter suit against St. James North M.P., Rawle Eastman? Is it George Payne? Is it true that Haniyfa Reza White was one of the persons down to vote in the elections George Payne rigged? Is this then part of the master plan to discredit Eastman for pointing out to the country last year that George Payne was engaged in electoral fraud, election rigging, which is corruption and organized crime? Why would Owen Arthur and George Payne feel they would get away with this when the BLP benefits from taxpayers money, which give the electorate the right to demand accountability and answers?

    Owen Arthur’s style is the ‘politics of fear,’ while George Payne’s is ‘the childish politics of spite.’ They both feel that once they take-out Rawle Eastman, no one else would be willing to stand in their way. George Payne has never been scared to let it be known that his cousin Douglas Skeete will replace Eastman as the candidate for the BLP in the next general election. Owen Arthur has also made it clear that Skeete will be the candidate. Everyone knows that you cannot enter Parliament if you have a criminal record, hence Haniyfa Reza White and her counter suit.

    Now you understand why four months after the ‘BLP’s annual conference voting list was rigged’ citizens still cannot hear a single word from Owen Arthur about the corruption that George Payne engaged in. Frankly, Owen Arthur has turned a blind eye, as any poppet-leader would. But it has given the citizens of this country the proof that they need, that corruption and organize crime now rule at the BLP? Owen Arthur has never explained to this country why he put $75,000 intended as campaign financing into his personal bank account.

    Under its new corrupt leadership, the BLP is preparing for an assault on the Barbados Treasury but it must be stopped. A group of men, who rigged the BLP’s election to get the result they want, are showing that they have no difficulty taking out Rawle Eastman or anyone who gets in their way, neither will they think twice about rigging a general election by re-aligning boundaries. What next? Will Owen Arthur create a $500 Barbados note and put his name and face on it? Who will they target next? The Commissioner of Police? The Governor of the Central Bank? Trade Union Leaders and Head of Private Sector Companies, who do not give Owen Arthur and his ‘gang of five’ campaign funds, to put into their personal bank account, again?

    Who are the people Owen Arthur and George Payne are taking money from? Whoever they are, it is clear that they do not want to do business with Prime Minister Stuart of even Mia Mottley. That is why anyone who messes with Owen Arthur and his ‘gang of five’ are now becoming targets, since their financial backers have to protect their interest. With the assistance of Haniyfa Reza White, Rawle Eastman has now found that out the hard way.


  6. there is no such thing as justice in real life it is an abstract nebulous concept that people who have been screwed have to argue about and make people understand what their problem is with proof etc based on some wishy washy abstract morals written on bits of paper as words in stuffy legal books


  7. @CCC

    Why would you repost when BU has a separate blog on the same matter?

    Very interested to read your answer also do you do reposting on the other blog?


  8. @ David
    I read this for the first time here in this section. “Repost” allowed be to see it.
    @CCC many thanks for the info.


  9. So far not a comment from the legal eagles on BU…ummmm.


  10. David
    Is this the mahinery being used to justify the appointment of Mr Gibson as C.J

  11. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar

    DAVID

    You are the owner of the blog if you don’t like it just take it down.
    It is your blog not mine.


  12. Off Topic

    The Arab nations are removing their despots from power, I hope the revolution spreads south to some African nations. There is a report that the son of the leader of Equatorial Guinea (his father seized power in 1979) has commissioned a $380 million yacht.

    Further south in Zimbabwe, some people who were watching the demonstrations on TV in Tunisia & Egypt were arrested, word is that Mugabe plans to charge them with treason.

    http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/world/africa-mideast/son-of-african-strongman-plans-380-million-yacht/article1924211/

    http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/22/world/africa/22zimbabwe.html


  13. @The Scout

    If you are going to be critical please be fair. Isn’t Thomas Harper the same person who submitted the blog Manipulating The Law To Accommodate Marston Gibson?


  14. Why are there so many attempts to take this thread off topic? Could there be an agenda here?


  15. What about the way Al Barack is being treated with respect to money owed to him by gov’t? The court can’t seem to demand that Barrack be paid in cash (or else), so he’s being told that he’ll have to sell the property which may prove to be a difficult task. Even if he’ able to find a buyer, he may not be able to recover all that was owed to him.

    Would this ever happen to CO Williams? Would this ever happen to Bjerkhamn? Would this ever happen to any foreign owned construction comapany? How come it’s happening to Al Barrack?


  16. @Zack
    To answer your question if this could happen to COW, the answer is a resounding no. When Don Blackman was minister of works, he sent out the road works project for tender and did not entertain COW’s bid,(which was one of the lowest) COW took
    him to court and won and was paid by government.

    When one looks at the judicial system here you see the disparities clearly. A man killed his son, and has not faced the court to answer any charge but is allowed to walk around freely, he is probably not even in the island, now tell me if that can happen to any of your children or family if they were cleaning a gun and it ‘accidentally went off.

    A man kills a woman because she refuses him sex and he gets a lighter sentence because he was provoked with what was hers and the right to say no.

    A man is beating a woman in the heights and the police can’t enter into the gated community, but a society that has two sets of law, one for the Meads and one for the Persians, do so at its own peril. Enough said.


  17. @Fran
    So true. But we don’t revolt…we don’t gather by the thousands in Bridgetown or Bay Street to protest against what we see as wrong. We just quibble amongst ourselves and business continues as usual.


  18. By the time Al Barrack gets any of his money he will be too old and stressed out to enjoy it.
    What is happening to Barrack appears to be cruel and unusual punishment.


  19. @Hants
    I like how you put it, “cruel and unusual punishment”.


  20. @Hants

    By the time Al Barrack gets any of his money he will be too old and stressed out to enjoy it.
    What is happening to Barrack appears to be cruel and unusual punishment.

    We have a couple things at play here.

    A flouting of the law, a court order/arbitration has been ignored. What does that say?

    The sluggishness of the government to settle may not be about a lack of funds after all but a belief that Barrack is a front man.

    It will be interesting to see government’s next move or should it be the court?


  21. @David,

    Did Barrack construct a building?
    Is the owner using said building?
    Did the Court award him payment for work on said building?

    The answer is yes,yes and yes so front man,back man or inside man,
    Barrack should be paid.

    I invite Amused,Anonlegal and Jeff Cumberbatch to explain in eloquent legal terms if I am correct.


  22. http://news.barbadostoday.bb/barticle.php?ptitle=NHC%20break&article=2991

    From my understanding of the current state. Barrack has charge order on the nhc warrens building valued 72-77 million and the land in rices st. philip valued 12 million. the issue seems to be that barrack side argues they might not find a buyer for the building the current finical climiate and the land seem to have been developed on so there seem to be unknow what the current size of the land the. so thats why the lawyers placed an order to seize nhc property. the judge has argued that the current property if it where to be seized would result in little reduction of the debt and interfere with the statutory operation so it cannot not be approved. so i guess if barrack could find buyer that would be what the judge would argue is a reasonable amount for the assests barrack could finally get paid. until then the charge order remains in effect.


  23. On the subject of efficiency in our court system, we keep hearing g that a judicial manager in the CLICO has to be appointed/approve by the court. Does this mean the application is before the court and awaiting a ruling or what?


  24. @anthony…

    With regards to your referenced link to BarbadosToday reporting of this decision…

    Please correct if I’m wrong, but in a true democracy are not all decisions of the law courts supposed to be openly published for all to know?

    Have we not learnt from our eastern colleges?

    Or, perhaps, we’re all about to learn.

    Very, very, quickly….


  25. If you are interested in the Barrack judgment, it is below:

    http://www.lawcourts.gov.bb/Lawlibrary/events.asp?id=805


  26. Chris, take a look at the link below:

    http://www.lawcourts.gov.bb/Lawlibrary/Judgments.asp


  27. I would hope so christopher. ( some cases judgement are post on the courts website ) By the way the judgement was given on the feb 8 so i guess no one bother to look into until now.


  28. I read the judgement above provided by Anonlegal.

    It seems clear to me that Mr.Barrack should have been paid but instead Government has chosen to delay payment.

    Not nise.


  29. @Anonlegal… Thanks *very* much for the link.

    I have read many of the decisions.

    Just wondering… How can the Barbados Supreme Court of Judicature Court of Appeal (with three Judges Sitting) take nearly three years to make a simple decision on a matter originally argued five years ago?


  30. Which case are you referring to christopher ?


  31. anthony… Which case are you referring to christopher ?

    http://www.lawcourts.gov.bb/Lawlibrary/events.asp?id=803

    AKA “Civil Appeal No. 23 of 2006”.

    As usual, I’m more than happy to be corrected….


  32. Once the govenment pay Barrack others might come crawling out of the wood work with said claims and the government ain’t about to let that happen. Delay! Delay ! till Barrack becomes exhausted and keel over and dies. No Government gonna pay he !


  33. Then it goes to his wife or kids or failing those the executor of his estate. It doesn’t just end like that.


  34. What is the next move in the Barrack case guys?

    Sir Richard is suppose to be a top lawyer, one must assume he has a strategy.


  35. @Christopher

    Who knows. I surely wouldn’t want to wait that long. If technology was moving at the pace of these lawyers/judges we would still be in 4004 cpus.


  36. @David

    The quick solution would be to find buyers for the warren building and the land. Once they can be found the judge can use the charge order to sell the assets and have the funds paid to barrack. Other than that we have to wait for government to either settle or pay barrack in full.


  37. YUh tink so!, They too will die trying! Fuh these matter would continue until the lawyers become the beneficiaries


  38. @anthony

    Even if a buyer is found in the current environment the opportunity to realize close to market price will be a stretch.

    In hindsight Barrack should have taken the deal offered by government.


  39. @david

    Well the judge will accept down to force sale price. Not that I see anyone coming to buy right now but it may happen. Hindsight is always 20/20 but there was still no guarantee that would have paid him . As stated in the document they did pay him 2.5 million but not a cent more. If this continues the judge will undoubtedly seize nhc assets and start auctioning away or place hold on all assets they are selling such as coverly and other housing.


  40. If the court does that Barrack will still be the loser.


  41. How would he be the loser david? they will sell/hold assets until the debt is satisfied. point 92 Corporation’s having assets worth approximately $418,383,105.39 and liabilities of $239,761,711.09. This meant, he submitted, that the Corporation’s net worth was $178,621,394.30 which exceeded the judgement debt, including interest. The problem will always be the loss of time nothing else right now.


  42. I understand that government has put the case back in the court, i don’t know how this could happen because the government had already lost the appeal. Whatever happens with the Barrack case is going to be a poor reflection on the government, because a precedent would have been set, namely if one does not like the decision by the HIgh Court just don’t pay and keep putting it back in court. I thought that there was only one appeal to the appellant court and from there it would be the CCJ. This case is going to have someserious reprocussions on Barbados


  43. @anthony

    Meaning that it will take time to realize those assets, he will still have to wait.

  44. Mash Up & Buy Back Avatar
    Mash Up & Buy Back

    Barack,sorry I meant George payne and dale marshal and crew deserve not one cent of taxpayer’s money.

    That judgement/settlement was flawed and slap in the citizen’s face.

    Barack knew he did not work for nor deserve these tens of millions of dollars and therefore he should have accepted the original offer by government,note this DLP government and not his pals in the BLP who at the time had money running out their ears,mouth and nostrils.


  45. @david

    ok understood.

    @scout

    Do you know under what grounds they trying to appeal now ?


  46. There is no quick solutionto this matter . It is all about principle. With Barrack standing his ground . The government standing theirs . In the end this matterwould stayed tied up in the courts until kingdom come. Barrack has already shown his unwillingness to compromise with a settlement by the government, and the government was only too happy with his decision. If the government has gone back to court with an appeal . It may be to show reason as to why Barrack should not be paid because they have shown “good Faith” and reason with intent on paying him and Barrack refused .


  47. Anthony
    I’m at a lost as to the reason for the return to the court and about the legality of such after losing the appeal. As I said this is setting the SUPREME COURT’S decisions in jeopardy, since anytime one does not agree with a appeal court’s decision, one can use this caes to prolong payment, the International world is viewing this caes carefully and a Int company is willing to buy out Barrack Con and it’s debt just to get at the Barbados government for non-payment, this would make top Int headlines. THE BARBADOS GOVERNMENT IS PLAYING WITH FIRE, WHILE THE INTEREST IS INCREASING.


  48. The citizens of Barbados need organize a protest march in support of Al Barack. One day it is he and next it might be you. We as citizens of a democratic country must protect our constitution and our judiciary. Without them we are under a dictatorship. Any elected government should never be above the law. How many of us have the GUTS to go out and PUBLICLY throw their support behind him?


  49. a/c
    How can a government stand its ground on an apellant court’s decision not to pay a client? Isn’t this bordering on arrogance and dictatoral conduct? When we blend this with what they are doing to appoint their man as C.J, this country is heading for some serious problems. Given that the Barrack matter was inherited, the DLP government had a good opportunity to sit with Barrack when he came to them by joining the membership of the party, but they were arrogant and evasive with the man as some senior members wanted to resolve the problem amicably, while others were holding out; this has lead to this present standoff which is NOT in the government’s favor and is beginning to smell funny. There is another inherited problem which will some blow up in this government,s face and that is the payment of millions of dollars owed to property owners whose property was compulsory taken, some for over twenty years, and no compensation recieved to date. This environment is not the type that a politically appointed C.J would like to come to office, he will be in trouble if he does and in trouble if he don’t side with this government


  50. Scout said:

    “I’m at a lost as to the reason for the return to the court and about the legality of such after losing the appeal. As I said this is setting the SUPREME COURT’S decisions in jeopardy, since anytime one does not agree with a appeal court’s decision, one can use this caes to prolong payment,”

    Scout:

    I will be honest, I haven’t been paying as much attention to this al Barrack matter as I should (I know, shame on me). However, I think you may have misunderstood a few things. From what I understand, no one has lost on appeal.

    From my understanding, the High Court has held that the application for sale and seizure of goods (writ of Fiery Facias) was not an expedient way for Barrack Constructions to enforce the judgment it obtained (NB: this makes sense considering that the amount owed is over $60 million. It is highly unlikely that Barrack Construction would be able to liquidate $60 million worth of NHC’s chattels easily).

    The High Court also seemed to have been satisfied that the NHC has made an effort to facilitate payment to Barrack Construction. You may be reading this and asking yourself – “what effort!?”

    Well, it would seem that the National Insurance Board (“NIB”) had a prior charge over the property which was the subject to the charging order obtained by Al Barrack. This means that if Barrack Construction successfully sold the charged property, the money owed to NIB would be paid first. Whatever was left after NIB’s debt was paid would then go to Barrack Construction. The amount that would have been leftover would not have been enough to settle the entire debt and Barrack construction would still be owed money at the end of the day.

    It would seem that NHC thought it better to pay off the debt owed to NIB so that if the Warren’s property is successfully sold, the proceeds of sale would immediately satisfy the debt owed to Barrack construction.

    Justice Crane Scott has decided that in these circumstances the application for the sale and seizure of goods should be stayed (i.e. should be put on pause) until Barrack Construction has attempted to exercise its rights under the charging order which it has already obtained.

    So in summary, this seems to be what is happening:

    1. Barrack construction was awarded a lot of money in an arbitration.

    2. In order to enforce the judgment that it obtained Barrack Construction obtained a charging order over various properties owned by NHC.

    3. Barrack construction subsequently sought to obtain an order allowing it to sell goods and chattels owned by NHC

    4. In the court’s view an order for seizure and sale of goods and chattels would not have been a very efficient way to enforce this judgment because of the amount of money owed.

    5. The court also took the view that the charging order already obtained may very well be enough to enforce the judgment.

    6. In light of the foregoing the court held that the application for the seizure and sale of NHC’s goods should be put on pause until Barrack Construction attempts to sell the charged property.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending