Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Here is what Kammie Holder is writing elsewhere – Credit to Nation Newspaper 16/07/2010

Kammie Holder

Too many of our leaders seem allergic to eating humble pie and come over as  insular in their thinking. The CARICOM Single Market and Economy is under threat by narrow political ambition.

The Caribbean Court of Justice is still not accepted by Trinidad where it is headquartered. St Lucia does not give LIAT the financial support even though it heavily relies on intra-regional trade and tourism.

Guyana offers land to extra-regional countries cheaper than it offers it to fellow Caricom members. Where is the visionary leadership within the Caribbean? The new prime minister of Trinidad and Tobago, Kamla Persad-Bissessar, recently made what I considered to be the insular statement that “Trinidad will not be an ATM”.

Would you believe that Trinidad’s largest market for its goods has been within the Caricom for years? These Caricom  countries seem obligated to acquire Trinidadian goods, despite that cheaper alternatives can be had within Asia. Thus, it’s imperative the new prime minister of Trinidad tread cautiously and think before making such ready statements. Someone should remind Persad-Bissessar that elections are over and words can be misconstrued.

Just for the record let me share some info on Trinidad trade. While it exported EC$2.4 billion to CARICOM members in 2004, imports from within CARICOM were EC$247 million  in 2004 as taken from the Caricom Secretariat website. Someone should share the aforementioned information with the prime minister of Trinidad and Tobago.

Trinidad owns half of Barbados, or so the man on the street believes, which redounds to an inflow of cash that strengthens its economy. Trinidad is flush with cash, thanks to its oil wells; but what would happen if oil prices plummet below a viable extraction level.

Remember, united we stand, divided we fall!

Who among our current crop of leaders are willing to speak up and out about the impotency of current leaders to make decisive and visionary decisions. Each Caricom country has a part to play in the development of its CARICOM neighbour for the greater good of the region.  Synergetic relationships are a must if CSME and CARICOM are to work.

Long live the visions of Eugenia Charles, Errol Barrow and Tom Adams. These were true regionalists.

Kammie Holder, the boy from the village is in amazement at how the people are united but the leaders divided.

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

96 responses to “What’s Wrong With Our Politicians?”


  1. Why do we hold up politicians as miracle workers?


  2. @ Kammie

    Maybe you should stay with things that you actually understand – like ML vehicles driving the wrong way on one way streets….. LOL

    What relevance has the vision of EWB from 1960 to the reality of the Caribbean in 2010? Can you not see the difference? ….EWB would have!!

    What united we stand divided we fall what!!??
    Did you not hear that cliches are passe here on BU? In today’s highly competitive world, that should be upgraded to read :

    Divided, the smart, creative ones have a slim chance of survival…… United we just make an easier target and we all die together.

    Trinidad ‘owns half of Barbados’ because Trinidad’s Businessmen are more aggressive, innovative and creative than our ‘retailers who call themselves businessmen’…. they did that without CSME no?

    We buy their goods because they produce better quality and at lower prices than we ever can. You may get cheaper junk from China – but the poison that they occasionally dump into their products, the cost of shipment, language, and the insecurity of supply deters the rest of us.

    CSME is long outdated as a viable option for the Caribbean. It was, in the 1960’s when things were quite different.

    However, maybe unlike all the other apologist for this nonsense, you can actually offer some suggestions as to how a common market could actually help our situation.
    (Remember no cliches, no nonsense about xenophobia, and no generalizations allowed)

  3. G.C.Brathwaite Avatar
    G.C.Brathwaite

    @ David
    “Why do we hold up politicians as miracle workers?”
    A valid question. There is myth and reality embedded there. If politicians are listening, if politicians are using the technologies, human resources, and tools that are available, then there is validity that they can get the job done. Sorry to say, it is rare that such a combination works in practice (at least in the Caribbean).
    I look forward to the politician or group of politicians that would make the reality more potent than the myth. Actually, I hope to play my part in such a regime.
    Enough said, that was my weekend jive.

  4. Straight talk Avatar

    This small island state will survive, because the salt of the earth will overcome all hardships.
    Back will come caring, sharing and charity for the less endowed, and the discredited politicos will have to take their chances with their ill-gotten gains as refugees in the hell holes of America, or in the case of Duguid, Canada.


  5. I am hoping for a royal flush at a hundred!CSME must be played seriously!The main players must stay in the game!!!

  6. G.C.Brathwaite Avatar
    G.C.Brathwaite

    With all seriousness. The CSME and CARICOM as a whole have issues. I do not believe that these issues are insurmountable. We have to revisit several of the assumptions made, learn from past mistakes, and more than anything else, stick to the commitments that are fashioned out. Indeed, because the leaders seek to pacify the national polities and play to the popular sentiments that would earn votes, they sometimes err only to make about face. When I reflect upon research work that I am currently undertaking, it becomes more obvious why there is necessity for the CSME and simultaneously a rethinking in terms of goals and how we would achieve them. Anyway, let someone else have their words, I may only incur the wrath of all of you that are taken up in the spirit of crop-over festivities.


  7. @Bush Tea

    What is your viable option to CSME. You seem vehemently oppossed to it.

    BTW please stop stomping your big foot on Kammie neck .I don’t like that!

  8. Straight talk Avatar

    Raymond:

    No matter what you may read, the game as you call it, is up.

    There is no way back from this cauldron of toxicity.

    We have survived through borrowing on the strengths of future growth, and there is very little chance we can manage the steady decline, let alone the chimera of growth.

    The old engine of capitalism has seized up through the lack of cheap oil.

    We are now facing Chinese hegemony, or more correctly hedgemoney.

    The US dollar will collapse as soon as the rest of the world finally realises, as do its rivals, it is based on the worthless paper its Treasury prints.

    China increased its coal burning by 45% last year alone, ignoring the deals it has made throughout Africa and more controversially Iran and Venezuela, China has soaked up all the energy supplies it requires to fuel its nonstop charge to superpower status, whist the West footles around with carbon taxation and climate change.

    The decline and fall of empires is nothing new, they rise through ingenuity, application and sheer hard work, and decline through the the exact opposites of lethargy, outsourcing and slothfulness.

    We in Barbados must align ourselves to the winning team if we are to survive as an independent nation.

    The choice is ours, beggars or choosers.

    Which course will we take?

    The easy path to oblivion , or the hard road through pride and industry, to success.


  9. ‘Trinidad ‘owns half of Barbados’ because Trinidad’s Businessmen are more aggressive, innovative and creative than our ‘retailers who call themselves businessmen’…. they did that without CSME no? We buy their goods because they produce better quality and at lower prices than we ever can.’

    I don’t know about all that, I know they can copy well. Name me one good quality Trini product besides Angostura bitters? lol


  10. Kammie man I am sure you know that sometimse we have to tell our own children (and/or spouses) that we are not an ATM. So what’s wrong with Kamla being pragmatic?

    But I do agree with you that it looks very foolish to have a court sited in Trinidad that the Trinidadians do not recognize. And it als make us look very foolish to be lurking on the grounds of the Privy Council after closing time.


  11. Lets face it, we have a long time before we are able see politicians with the guts, gall,gumption and the likes of Dipper Barrow and Tom Adams who had no reservations in calling a spade, a frigging spade,and would not have accepted some of the mouthings we now hearing from run of the mill, yes sir, no sir Caribbean leaders. But it goes further than that. We have just signed,yet again, some bi-lateral air space agreement with the USA, giving the USA some level of freedom to use our air space and we theirs. Pray tell me what have we got in the lines of aircraft capable of utilising United States air space. And another thing , we allow every Tom ,Dick and Harriette in the Commonwealth to come into our country without a visa,and if we want to go to Australia, we must be in posession of a visa. How come that we are able to enjoy visa exemptions with many other countries outside our ” Commonwealth family of Nations”,but need one for sister-nation,Australia. Even under a specific condition, Bajans are able to enter hard- nosed, die- hard Russia without a visa.


  12. @ ac
    Kammie is my long time friend, I know exactly how hard his neck is, and therefore how much stomping it can take….LOL
    …Don’t worry bout him – he good!

    @ enuff
    Believe it or not, there is not a thing wrong with copying. In fact, technology is much too complex for anyone to be completely original.
    It is accepted modern practice to copy the very best models available and THEN add your own innovation.

    Benchmarking is the term.

    @ G.C. Brathwaite said…
    “….When I reflect upon research work that I am currently undertaking, it becomes more obvious why there is necessity for the CSME and simultaneously a rethinking in terms of goals and how we would achieve them.”
    *********************************************************************************************
    One of the most coherent explanations the bushman have heard so far, in support of CSME.

    ….just thank God that the bushman will not be marking your thesis. Can one have grades down by Z…?

    @ ST
    How is it that you understand so many complex things and yet refuse to contemplate the most fundamental of all knowledge ….? BBE.

    @ ac (again)
    “What is your viable option to CSME. You seem vehemently opposed to it.”
    **************************************************************************************
    Bush Tea is NOT opposed to CSME.
    It would be quite fun to have it, and the bushman would be quite proud if we could accomplish this objective.

    My problem comes when it is touted as a solution to the dangerous problems that we face…… It ISN’T.
    My problem is the huge COST involved. …. The resources (that should be usefully engaged) that are wasted.

    NO one has EVER given BT any sensible benefits to be realized from CSME!….. You know any ac?

    Suppose the news came that a nuclear bomb was headed for Barbados – due next 10 hours. Would you spend the time forming a community group? (strength in numbers) or would you find a small sharp crew willing to get to Grantley Adams and find a plane by hook or crook…?


  13. @Bushman

    Question Would barbados benefit better without CSME? You say that there are no sensible benefits to CSME.However in your opinion what are the alternatives. I have read CSME agenda and if the countries apply the laws as implemented they are many benefits from which they can gain.Now it would be interesting to see any changes which you might have that would be of benefit to barbados and the other CSME countries. I am LIstening !


  14. I have read CSME agenda and if the countries apply the laws as implemented they are many benefits from which they can gain.
    ****************************************************
    Well name one nuh!


  15. @Bushman

    Free movement of goods and service. Normally any country wanting to do so in anothercountry would have to go through many barriers to do so .However CSME makes it easier for a company to do so . I believe competition is good as it makes a company want to do the best to make a good productand also it helps in wage control. However I am still waiting to hear of the many other alternatives you have to CSME please educate me ,I am listening


  16. @Bush Tea,

    Here again are the stated objectives/benefits of CSME:

    “The CARICOM Single Market and Economy is intended to benefit the people of the Region by providing more and better opportunities to produce and sell our goods and services and to attract investment. It will create one large market among the participating member states.”

    “The main objectives of the CSME are: full use of labour (full employment) and full exploitation of the other factors of production (natural resources and capital); competitive production leading to greater variety and quantity of products and services to trade with other countries. It is expected that these objectives will in turn provide improved standards of living and work and sustained economic development.”


  17. @ ac & Brutus

    Thanks.
    But the bushman was looking for benefits that actually makes some sense……
    Free movement of goods and services?

    Name any good/service which you can afford- from anywhere in this world – that you could not access in a short period, working only from your computer at home….Anyone with money to buy, or who have goods/services that customers want, can operate practically anywhere in this world right now.Just look at T&T.

    The only serious exceptions being the developed world who have blocked our possible exports to them via complex (and creative) non- trade- tariffs….. after we had foolishly signed trade agreements with them. (so they can ship their junk here)

    Besides, what CSME free trade market can be meaningful when GATT, NAFTA and a host of other more inclusive agreements have already superseded it in any case?

    @ Brutus who quoted:
    “The main objectives of the CSME are: full use of labour (full employment) and full exploitation of the other factors of production (natural resources and capital); competitive production leading to greater variety and quantity of products and services to trade with other countries. It is expected that these objectives will in turn provide improved standards of living and work and sustained economic development.”
    *********************************************************************************
    Ha Ha Ha Did you really read that!!??

    …sound like something from George Brathwaite’s thesis…. ROTFL.

    Brutus, that is best described as twaddle or gobbledygook.

    @ ac
    One obvious benefit of scrapping the idea is that we would save ourselves MILLIONS of dollars that could then be used for something useful – like alternative energy.

    Another is that we may then seriously look at dealing with the REAL problems we have as politicians would then stop talking junk about CSME.

    …..but mostly, bush tea just don’t like foolishness…… It just bugs me!!


  18. @Bush Man

    Name any country in the world that you can set up a Company and employ people with out going through a lot of red tape. The above which i cited make it easier for people living in these countries which are members to do so., Try doing that in the USA. .NO it is not as simple as buying a watch on the internet and probably soon that too might have it laws, Do not underestimate the power of governments when they have their interest at hand. I will submit to you that without CSME a lot of the neighbouring countries would have a hard time selling or promoting their goods in neighbouring islands.
    IF Governments have the need to pursue alternative they would. Sharing ideas is also what CSME encourages bythe countries and the need for alternative energy
    should and can be a joint effort by all CSME members which in turn can save thosecountries millions of dollars and not having one country to do its own research and funding.
    Question Are you an isolationist.


  19. @Bush Tea,

    You keep saying that no-one has said what the benefits of CSME are, but when they are listed for you, you dismiss them as “twaddle”. The objectives seem very reasonable to me. Are we supposed to accept them as “twaddle” simply because you say so?


  20. Nobody is addressing the fact that T&T and Jamaica don’t seem to have the appetite for CSME. Why did Manning make the decision to join with the OECS? Why has Jamaica been lukewarm to to embracing fully the CCJ.


  21. G.C.Brathwaite // July 16, 2010 at 8:12 PM

    @ David
    “Why do we hold up politicians as miracle workers?”
    A valid question. There is myth and reality embedded there. If politicians are listening, if politicians are using the technologies, human resources, and tools that are available, then there is validity that they can get the job done. Sorry to say, it is rare that such a combination works in practice (at least in the Caribbean).
    I look forward to the politician or group of politicians that would make the reality more potent than the myth. Actually, I hope to play my part in such a regime.
    Enough said, that was my weekend jive.”

    It is always easier to evaluate a dead politician than a living one. Cynically put, the living are continually evolving, and the dead can’t bite, when you write shite! This may be one reason why we may ascribe greater insight, focus, and achievement to EWB than, say, to the RHOSA.

    BTW, when Dr. George Brathwaite, ABD talks about getting the job done, I wonder what job is that. When I was finally toilet trained (yes! On matriculation into the U(C)WI) I learnt the difference between real “jobs” for his/her constituents as the #1 priority of every responsible right-thinking successful politician and “jobby”!


  22. A Caricbbean single market and economy is theoretically, as Brutus above has specified the theoretical benefits, an obvious and clear way forward, if one considers traditional economic theory.

    Theoretically, the Caribbean can send a man to the moon, but it is neither a priority, we do not have the funds without extensive borrowing, we will take a few years due to the time to organise logistics and maybe even most of all, a longer time to decide and agree, if at all, on who actually pilots the ship, whether a Bajan, Trini, Jamaican, Guyanese or St.Lucian (apologies for those left out).

    THAT is the crux of the matter i.e. prioritisation and the ‘intent’ of the participants involved in CSME.

    A s said ad nauseum on these blogs, it is laughable that we can talk about CSME with puffed out chests, yet cannot sign a fishing agreement (with or without the ‘real reason’ of territorial issues underlying), we cannot get full participation on the CCJ, we cannot even have a West Indies cricket team without political interference and one-upmanship.

    Hence, I join the cynics and say that we are merely wasting time in any effort to further the issue, should keep Caricom as is and leave it at that.

    While perseverance is commendable, in circumstances where some show clear inclination to treat elsewhere or even show disdain for such an arrangement as CSME, I fear that we are merely hoping on a whim and a prayer, in an effort to maintain efforts for no other reason that following common economic theory.

    Other realities must also be accepted, such as the EU’s own current problems with their own union.

    Surely, the duct tape of EU loans has temprorarily covered the cracks in their union structure, but I fear that they will appear again ata a later date and to a greater extent, if not driven by financial causes, then for political reasons.

    Bear also in mind, that despite the efforts of successive Barbados governments to further the CSME ideal, I perceive that Governments of other islands have been quick to jump on our PM’s recent position, which to me appears to be more cautious. I could be wrong.

    Then too, the Trinidad PM’s recent and surprising comments, resonating the theme of ‘Oh Solo Mio’, have been most unfortunate yet enlightening.

    It is time that we consider the question as to whether our quest for a political and economic ‘Valhalla’ is actually achievable, seriously.


  23. Politicians are affected by the bad and longstanding effects of emancipation from enslavement-like most other people


  24. The inability of Caricom to establish a viable regional transportation system demonstrates their inability to make CSME work. How can we focus on movement of people ONLY. Trade is integral for business and pleasure. We saw more movement of people before CSME came along. Don’t forget how our leaders jumped at the crack of a whip to proclaim sunset legislation for CWC 2007. Therein lies the problem.


  25. Both these DLP and BLP factions must be sent packing from the parliament of this country within the next seven years.

    So, in the lead up to 2017, there must be substantial moral, political, material, financial and other supports given by “all and sundry” to the PDC, the PEP, or any other serious people-centered developmentalist parties that are or will be around to receive them.

    RIGHT NOW , THANKFULLY, THE STATUS QUO IN BARBADOS IS BEING CHANGED AND FOREVER!!!

    There are two things that need to be said though.

    One, is that as time goes by as many people as possible in Barbados must support as much as possible anti-STATUS QUO, anti-ELITIST, anti-OLIGARCHY, anti-TAXATION, anti-INTEREST RATES, anti-BIG GOVERNMENT parties in this country.

    Any genuinely pro-masses, pro-middle classes, pro-republican, pro-national developmental like the PDC must be supported at all costs!!!

    For, the DLP and BLP models are utterly philosophically ideologically politically bankrupt.

    Interestingly enough, we recently found a very salient comment that has been made by a person on the Cafferty File (Jack Cafferty’s Blog) @http://caffertyfile.blogs.cnn.com – under the thread – Tea Party favourable rating is almost as high as Dems & GOP.

    We think it necessary to reproduce it here in light of the above first point.

    The person blogged: “I think that just the fact that our main stream media is so anti tea party makes me believe they should be supported!”

    Great statement indeed!!!

    That kind of instinctive, urging support for the Tea Party in the USA, is the kind that many people here in Barbados must strongly make too for the PDC, and other serious people-centered in the country in light of the fact that both DLP and BLP have proven that they are NOT FUNDAMENTALLY about securing the nation’s or the country’s interests, but FUNDAMENTALLY about securing the personal, familial, cronistic, financial, and business interests of a few inside and outside of this country.

    The DLP and BLP are essentially CORRUPT and have long been shamelessly corrupting many of the affairs of this country!!

    Quickly before we get to point two, here is another blog from the Cafferty File under the same earlier mentioned thread, that is fairly meaningful and that is about the SAME Tea Party Movement in the USA:

    “It doesn’t really matter what they call it … the Tea Party, the Coffee Party, or whatever. There is a large segment of the population who is dissatisfied with not only what government does, but how they do it. The direct answer to your question is that there is large demand for responsible government, and a wholesale belief that we’re not getting it in the current two-party system. Politics in this country has become so shrill and sometimes downright nasty that it is conceivable that we’ll see in the near future elections with three, four, or even five political parties. European style coalition government might happen here soon. What is certain is that large change will occur … hopefully it will begin with an end to the gerrymandering that virtually guarantees minimal turn-over in the Congress. These guys need to know that their jobs are on the line from the moment they are sworn in. That is not the case now in most districts.”

    We in the PDC and so many others in Barbados must surely get more Bajans some thinking in this vein!!!

    Now to Two.

    The PDC has been observing – as expected – at least two very disturbing grotesque trends taking place in Barbadian politics, and even reaching as far as on this BU blog.

    The first odious trend involves a few, unconnected and ungrouped Barbadians that have for a long time been doing NOTHING, NOTHING ABSOLUTELY to help change the overall political direction in this country, but who – on realizing that there is such a party called the PDC, and that there are instances whereby many of our policies, philosophies, and positions are greater more exciting many more people in the poltical market – have been fairly quick though to baselessly falsely criticize us ( we have no problem with proper construcutive valid criticisms), for simply producing great ideas and policies for the betterment of this country and its people even humanity.

    With regard to the other henious trend. This has involved another meagre number of unconnected ungrouped people in Barbados that have been recognizing that we have been making a couple of political steps up on the behalf of the indigent and voiceless – and who principaly because of this – have become fairly mean in their attempts to stall our advance towards helping change the political mindsets of esp. those people who yearn for greater political social political material and financial change in this country and for the better – through they seeking to engage us in petty and childish juvenile talk conduct ( which we clearly have no time for ).

    What makes these two sets of people look so badly feebly in the eyes of our party and so many other people is that they have NOT been seen by us “attacking” or “getting in the way of” those in the DLP, or in and the BLP, or and those in the elite corridors of this country who have been the principal ones who have been making life a living hell for them and so many others in this country, but they have the gall to be “attacking” us or “getting in our way”.

    Well, we have got a little to say to these people, simply get up off your backsides and use your God-given talents and your supposed educational qualifications and common sense and make very special determined efforts to rescue the suffering and the vulnerable among the broad masses and middle classes of people from the dreaded clutches of the damned DLP and blasted BLP, and the pernicious of the elite of this country.

    We say make that your bounden duty!!

    And, dont worry to much about us for we are going to remain as focussed and methodical as ever in our efforts to help the underpriviliged and the down trodden among us in this country, and to HELP CHANGE THE STATUS QUO FOR EVER.

    Indeed, with the Almighty’s we will!!

    PDC


  26. @ ac
    …and why exactly are you interested in setting up a company in the USA? …but even if you are, and you have access to to the required funds, what would stop you from doing so? Everyone else in the world does it without a problem…

    You say “I will submit to you that without CSME a lot of the neighbouring countries would have a hard time selling or promoting their goods in neighbouring islands.”
    ********************************************************************************************
    OHHH….. how did you arrive at this conclusion bozie? Does Trinidad seem to have a problem with exports to you? … or do THEY have CSME?

    It is not an issue of CSME or not CSME. The issue is the ability to produce high quality, competitively priced goods and services. THAT is the challenge.

    ….which part of that do you not get?

    …..in any case, as expected, Crusoe has put the whole matter in much better context than a bushman ever could….. it is a matter of prioritizing, but if some of you want to concentrate on this useless, expensive and unrealistic goal – feel free to do so….


  27. @PDC

    BU is willing to give you a voice on Thursdays. Keep your submission to 750 words and email us on Wednesday nights.


  28. @ Brutus
    The objectives seem very reasonable to me. Are we supposed to accept them as “twaddle” simply because you say so?”
    **********************************************************************************************

    You must have realized by now that Bush Tea is a simple-minded, down-to-earth, grass-roots, semi-literate who has this ‘problem’ with foolishness.
    I hereby apologize for this……

    Do you REALLY think that because Owen Arthur’s CSME secretariat said something like ;
    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
    “The main objectives of the CSME are: full use of labour (full employment) and full exploitation of the other factors of production (natural resources and capital); competitive production leading to greater variety and quantity of products and services to trade with other countries. It is expected that these objectives will in turn provide improved standards of living and work and sustained economic development.”
    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
    …that the bushman would be satisfied? That is just a load of nonsense!!
    ….these are words that says nothing, means nothing and only just barely makes grammatical sense.

    ….you know that too Brutus. Let us deal with SPECIFICS.

    You see, the Bushman is old enough to know that very few people seem able to think for themselves, and that ‘leaders’ are generally those who know, and take advantage of this fact.

    Concepts like ‘CSME’, “EDUTECH”, “Free Trade” etc, easily capture simple minds and allow ‘leaders’ free reign to spend millions, talk twaddle and play games – instead of having to deal with the REAL issues that need to be addressed.

    ….so after 15 years of wasting hundreds of millions of dollars, Minister Jones now announces (what Bush Tea said from day one of its launch) that Edutech is essentially a waste of money and effort – and we all know where education has gone during that time.

    It is all an exercise in idiocy.
    Where there is no vision, people will perish – and a country ALWAYS get exactly what they deserve.


  29. Ok, Bush Tea, let’s break it down a bit. Remember we were only talking about the objectives and potential benefits of CSME.

    You said above (8.19 am):

    “Does Trinidad seem to have a problem with exports to you? … or do THEY have CSME?

    It is not an issue of CSME or not CSME. The issue is the ability to produce high quality, competitively priced goods and services. THAT is the challenge.”
    ______________
    I would argue that the issue of ability to produce high quality, competitively priced goods and services IS a CSME issue. The argument is that this ability is enhanced if companies have better access to a wider pool of labour and a wider market for their goods. You have referred to Trinidad, which is a good example because compared to Barbados their companies have easier access to a much larger market and a much wider pool of labour.

    I have no problem if you say that you don’t agree with that argument, but don’t say that it is nonsense. If you argue that we will never have the ability to implement CSME successfully then I have no problem with that either.

    You say that the millions of dollars could be better spent on alternative energy, for example. Don’t you think the chances of success would be greater if alternative energy projects could be done at a regional level?


  30. @Brutus

    Your example is too simplistic. Do you appreciate the level of subsidization which T&T industries receive? On top of that their low cost of production puts them in a very competitive position. In a CSME scenario how do you intend to treat with this disequilibrium?


  31. @ Brutus ….OK,
    …maybe my language tends to be a bit ‘bushy’ – so I tend to say that something is ‘foolishness’ when I mean that I disagree – as you so helpfully point out….sorry.

    …so let me say that I disagree with your above comment that;
    ******************************************************
    “I would argue that the issue of ability to produce high quality, competitively priced goods and services IS a CSME issue.
    *******************************************************

    It really ISN’T.
    The ability to produce high quality, competitively priced goods and services is strictly a function of ingenuity, creativity and guts. It reflects a willingness to do research, take risks, face challenges and believe in oneself.

    Trinidad has no larger market than Jamaica. It is minuscule compared to Haiti’s.
    There are HUGE countries that are desperately poor – with massive markets, limitless resources and people just like ours…. and there are minute countries, companies and even families that are unimaginably successful…..some without easily discernible assets…..
    ….do you need me to name some of these countries?

    Your suggestion that alternative energy could enjoy greater success ‘if done at the regional level’ is so full of holes that you probably regret using that example….. you surely remember the ‘fishing agreement’ – and the ‘ease’ with which we resolved our international boundaries recently….. LOL

    Look at the great companies of the world – Apple, Google, Ford, even local examples like Sagicor, and Oran – Did they need large-based agreements in place to get started? Who created ready markets to facilitate their successes?

    One man in a small room with minimal technology – but with maximum CREATIVITY, INGENUITY, SELF CONFIDENCE and GUTS can conquer the whole world….


  32. @ David, “Why do we hold up politicians as miracle workers?”

    Politicians present themselves as miracle workers when they are campaigning.

    Edutech was a good political gimmic but doomed to failure.
    Barbados can find the resources for “startup” but not for “upgrades and maintenance”.

    I glad Kamla Persad-Bissessar said what most Trinis are thinking.

    Owen Arthur can be commended for his efforts but caribbean integration will not work.
    It is not about insularity. It is about Power and egos. Dem en want nuh small islanders callin shots.

    Nuh Federation, Nuh CSME.


  33. Hants
    But power and egos come under the guise of ‘insularity’ too.
    As for what Kamla said about TT not being anyone’s ATM machine; Hants, sometimes I go to use my ATM card and de machine doan got in a red cent. So she in lie. LOL


  34. @Bush Tea,

    Apple, Ford – are you serious? You can have the greatest idea in the world and all the ingenuity, guts and self-confidence but none of these companies would have succeeded without ready access to capital. How does an entrepreneur in Barbados with a world changing idea attract the capital that would be needed to make the idea a commercial success? Post it on the net and hope that someone with capital sees it? If he/she gets the capital, then can the product/service be produced competitively within the region? Maybe the investors will decide it makes more sense to base the company in the US, or China, or even Trinidad!!

    Oran – is this company really a success story? I don’t know. How does Oran compare (in terms of profitability, quality and pricing) to similar companies in Trinidad and Jamaica which have greater access to capital and cheaper labour, raw materials and other inputs, and larger markets?

    Sagicor – would no doubt be a lot more profitable and competitive if it did not have to deal with different laws for insurance, labour, etc in the various Caribbean territories in which it operates. Again, Sagicor is a great example because they could not have reached this level of success in only the Barbados market. And remember, you need capital to expand – Sagicor had to go throughout the region and then to London to get capital.

    Remember that we need our companies ideally to attract investment from outside of the region. They therefore need to be able to generate enough profits to compensate the investors. This means they have to be competitive, and this is enhanced by (1) easier access to the combined labour markets and of the region, and (2) easier access to sell their products and services to the people of the region.


  35. Man Brutus, you really scraping the bottom of the barrel now…
    …you running from pillar to post as my mother used to say…

    OK – so now the problem is lack of capital is it?
    …and somehow you see a way that having CSME will solve that problem?
    Come on man – leave that level of argument to Bajan Truth….lol

    Actually Brutus, there has NEVER been a time in ALL of history when it has been easier to access capital.
    …of course if you are talking about some incompetent mendicant, running around begging cap-in-hand for some god father to give him all the funds that he can get his hands on… that is another matter.

    But access to sound, reasonable BUSINESS capital for serious intelligent entrepreneurs has never been easier at ANY TIME in history.

    …and by the way, anyone with an innovative, idea who cannot SELL his project creatively and attract funding is not a candidate for the kind of success of which the bushman speaks in any case. This is why we Bajans know all the answers on the call-in-shows and these blogs, and yet foreigners run our businesses.

    Brutus, why don’t you concede quietly – you have no case in this argument – although you tried valiantly to represent your client Bajan Truth. LOL

    One needs to understand the whole existential situation of our world -and the overarching strategic vision of its creators, in order to fully digest the complexities of these scenarios.
    ……in bushman terms, there are much larger issues at stake here while we argue over these minor trivialities….


  36. @ Bush Tea:

    “….so after 15 years of wasting hundreds of millions of dollars, Minister Jones now announces (what Bush Tea said from day one of its launch) that Edutech is essentially a waste of money and effort – and we all know where education has gone during that time”

    It probably not generally known, but the RHOSA was initially skeptical about the “Edutech” project, probably because, as an economist, he did a quick and dirty cost/benefit analysis and found that it would not work. However, he took the path of the “true” politician and enthusiastically supported it since he thought that it would give the BLP a big bank for the buck for bringinging ICT to educational development in Barbados.


  37. @ Lincoln

    Tells us a lot about RHOSA.
    I have a sneaky suspicion that he was skeptical about the Greenland landfill fiasco too……. maybe he also had concerns about 3S and VECO.

    Actually bushman really liked Owing a lot. Always felt that he had some guts….. but the bushy is yet to recover from that ‘personal bank deposit’ and the lame response…

    …amazing how one’s instincts can become clouded when one has secrets to be guarded…..


  38. I am not an economist but it is clear that these institutions including caricom, csme, are just talk shops between people looking to carve out a legacy of their own. how can we boast of pushing these institutions when the fruits are heading in one direction. Over the years it is clear that Barbados is now simply an appendage of our neighbor to the south. It is my view to become a regionalist you must be a strong nationalist, we must come to the table as a strong entity to assist in the regional effort. Here we are now nothing of substance to call our own because every thing is now owned by T&T thanks to the B’dos Stock Exchange and local mutual funds and white barbadians. The last monument of Barbadian ingenuity (Banks Breweries) is about to be taken over by T&T again via a scam in the form of a loan concocted by Fields and King. This will not only create a loss of ownership by Barbadians but another serious blow to our psyche as a people.
    I cringe when I heard D. Skeete on our radio talking about the BNB is now better managed and stronger under present management than before. Is he a bajan? Why do these politicians and so called intellectuals continue to try to pull the wool over our eyes. we need to go back and rebuild Barbados, create a strong nationalist thinking,then we can go forth and assist in the regional effort. We just are not ready.


  39. @Bush Tea

    Wasn’t Liz sceptical too as Minister of the Environment to boot but felt collective responsibility to cabinet was larger that personal beliefs?


  40. Bush Tea

    I want acess to Capital .. You could help point me in a direction that … well just point..!

    (By the way I wid you.. if the for argument’s sake the only reason for dropping CSME is that it is costing money with no progress in sight, man save the foreign exchange)


  41. Politics in Barbados and the Caribbean is about support for big (foreign exchange draining) businesses. Edutech and CSME were God sends to such operations. RHOSA answers to such operations as well, particularly those of an expatriate nature…!


  42. The biggest disappointment to date and a legacy of both parties so far has been the inability of the Fair Trading Commission to fairly represent the PEOPLE. It seems big business because it has the resources has been able to co-opt the support of the FTC over the years. Did anyone notice the battery of lawyers and experts flown in from over n away to represent the BL&P? On the other side of the room we could see BANGO et al struggling to compete. Bear in mind those struggling were representing the PEOPLE. The government has had nothing to say through it all. Was there an under the table deal with LIME by the way? What are we missing?


  43. CCC

    “The last monument of Barbadian ingenuity (Banks Breweries)”

    Which part of Banks is Barbadian ingenuity? Banks was started by Peter D’Aguar and a few Portugese Guyanese before you born.

    Please go check your history on this matter. Don’t argue now. Check your facts!


  44. To Annonymous;
    This is how it should work. The barbadians have developed and maintained the breweries to the highest standard to become what it is today a source of Barbadian pride. This is regional development is all about. it is not about invading the economic and financial landscape of your neighbour. That breeds a form of colonialism. Bring your expertise and resources to to assist in development. We will all become stronger together. What we are experiencing is just exploitation. What are the effects on our people??


  45. @ Carlos

    Sound points! Bush Tea would only digress in saying that BNB probably IS better managed currently. However we all know that under previous management, politicians had a direct hand in decision making and did not permit management to function independently….. and that ‘management’ did not have the guts to challenge the position.

    Your points about Banks Holdings are bang on. There is an obvious agenda being promoted by these players to the detriment of ordinary Bajans.

    ..all they would need now is the CSME excuse in place, and they could REALLY play their dirty games.


  46. I need to look at you different Bush Tea, I think i like your style, but have you looked at the operations of the bank recently?? Its reputation is now sliding fast. The computer system and the financing of it can hardly be a wise decision, the new location on Broad street was not a n improvement by any means and the attrition of senior bank staff to be replaced by trinis cannot be overlooked. What about the other issues in granting loans to whom, there are myriad of problems. Do not mistake aggression for competence.


  47. Carlos

    Banks beer would be chased off the market if any and I mean any of its competitors had the foresight to runa campaign that has as its theme “LESS GAS… MORE BEER…!”


  48. Bush Tea

    Acces to Capital, what is on your mind that I can use right now…?


  49. David;

    To me the biggest sham about the BL&P hearing is that we had a Sir representing a commission that found in favour of the company, and another Sir that acted as chief counsel for the company, both Sirs therefore acted against the interests of the ordinary majority who of course would have elected the officials that thought it appropriate to make these men Sirs in the first place…!


  50. Now we have another Sir deciding that it is not really necessary to consult with ordinary small investors before a decision is made to dilute their share holding interest in the company and the same FTC Sir (who came out yesterday to show some kind of disapproval) but in the fullness of time will run true to form.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending