
BU read with interest in the media an update on the status of the eagerly awaited Integrity Legislation (IL) by Prime Minister Freundel Staurt (Ag). He indicated the IL could be introduced very soon. Of interest to BU was his explanation the IL would be fairly wide in scope to include key partners in the private sector. The need to implement IL which is relevant has always been advocated by BU. It is against this background the stunt by Opposition Leader Mia Mottley and former Prime Minister Owen Arthur to declare their assets has exposed itself to be a forgettable political gimmick.
An example of how a relevant and effective IL can help to expose corruption in a public or private sector scenario is easily illustrated if we read the Auditor General’s (AG) Report 2009. On page 63 of his report, the AG refers to a few suppliers to the School Meals Department who are allowed duty free status to import for that department only. Here is the AG’s audit note. … However, there is no system in place to monitor the amounts imported by suppliers and ensure that goods allowed duty free status are imported for Government Departments only. As a result various suppliers imported goods in excess of what had been delivered to the School Meals Department. What a sweet deal!
The first question which comes to mind, why has the AG not mentioned the names of the suppliers in his report? Perhaps the one time the understaffed and hardworking AG Department has opened itself to criticism. There is little doubt after reading the AG’s report that some Custom Officers, School Meal management or both have benefited from the sweet deal. Are we being harsh in our conclusion? Here is the AG’s audit note. …Some suppliers were using both original and duplicate copies of authorization from the School Meals Department in order to obtain goods duty free. Only the original authorisation is intended to be used by suppliers as a waiver for imported goods, and the duplicate copy should be kept as a personal record. However, these duplicates were used by the suppliers to obtain goods free of duties to which they were not entitled.
Even if the supplier did not know that the original document must be presented to the Customs Department as the authorization, don’t you reasonably believe the Custom Officer should have been aware? Give us a break! If we had IL on the books maybe, just maybe…
It gets better.
The suppliers contracted to supply the School Meals Department are issued with certificates which indicate the items to receive duty free status. Equally as important is the amount of the item to be imported which is also recorded on the certificate. Surprise surprise, guess what the AG’s audit exposed? Here is the AG’s audit note, one of many. …One company had contracts to supply 3,001 bags of English potatoes weighing a total of 68,122.7 kilograms (kgs). A review of the ASYCUDA++ computer system and a comparison with the School Meals Department’s records showed that for the academic year 2007-2008, the company made twenty-nine (29) customs declarations of English potatoes consigned to the School Meals Department. These amounts had a net mass of 716,542.79 kgs an excess of 566,692.79 kgs over the contracted amount. A check with the School Meals Department revealed that over the two academic years 2007-2008 and 2008-2009, the requirements of the Department totalled 123,760 kgs. In this case the particular supplier not only exceeded the amount approved to gain duty free status but used a COPY of the tax waiver certificate to obtain the goods. What a sweet deal!
The responses given by the Customs Department and the School Meals Department management would merit instant dismissal in the private sector, not so government departments (Read pages 67-70 of the Auditor General 2009 to see for yourself).
Would you have confidence in a Customs Department whose systems cannot account for 41 cars leaving the port without being completely processed and the relevant duties collected?
Thieving Galore!






The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.