LOPSIDED
by TREVOR YEARWOOD
THE UNFAIR DISTRIBUTION of benefits in favour of Trinidad and Tobago is of concern to Prime Minister Owen Arthur and will come up for serious discussion when Caribbean Community heads of government begin talks today. This imbalance under the Single Market and Economy (CSME) was raised by Arthur yesterday as he addressed the official opening of the 28th CARICOM Heads of Government Conference in the courtyard of the Parliament Buildings, before more than 350 people and a regional radio and television audience.
He said while Trinidad and Tobago was the main beneficiary of the expansion in intra-regional export, apparently only “a few countries” were carrying the weight of the community’s free movement of skills programme. “Already, issues regarding the fair distribution of benefits from the CSME are surfacing,” Arthur said as he took over the chairmanship of CARICOM from St Vincent and the Grenadines Prime Minister Dr Ralph Gonsalves.
He pointed out that while intra-regional exports between 1995 and 2005 had grown from 13 per cent to over 20 per cent of the total exports of the region, “this growth has largely been to the benefit of one country – Trinidad and Tobago”. He told the gathering of regional government chiefs, other ministers and members of the diplomatic community that this situation “is untenable”.
Source: Nation Newspaper
Did BU read this article correctly? Is Owen “CSME”Arthur making anti-CSME statements? Wow…Prime Minister Arthur you better be careful, your statement could be construed as protectionist in some quarters! The posture now emanating from Arthur is confusing to us. One minute Arthur is welcoming all investment that is non-Barbadian, with emphasis on Trinidadian investment, yet in the Nation article he is expressing concern at the lopsidedness of the investment between Trinidad and the rest of CARICOM. One does not have to have a Masters in Economics to know that the cash rich Trinidad, which has a rich venture capital infrastructure to boot, has prepared its companies to be the “economic tigers” of the Caribbean. It follows that the scenario playing out should not have come as a surprise to the directorate of Barbados. Our great surprise on the BS&T, Neal & Massy merger comes from the opposite positions which Barbadians are hearing from our government ministers of late.
MINISTER OF STATE in the Prime Minister’s office, Clyde Mascoll has indicated that Government will not stand in the way of mergers, but encourages Barbadians to invest in shares. He made the comment in response to the situation relating to this island’s largest private sector firm, Barbados Shipping & Trading (BS &T) now facing a number of takeover bids and a merger bid.
Source: Nation Newspaper
Seems to BU that Minister Mascoll is saying to Barbadians that government cannot stop the free for all happening with T&T companies gobbling-up the undervalued Barbados companies. To compensate however he advises Barbadians to invest in the merged entities.
According to Minister Eastmond, In the case of BS&T and the Neal and Massy merger, there never appeared from the outset as though there would be any consolidation to the extent that there would be a controlling interest of 40 per cent or more in the market. The FTC investigation revealed that the 40 per cent threshold has not been reached or breached. Therefore, it was not necessary for them to go on to an adjudicative process.
Source: Advocate Newspaper
Minister Eastmond who has ministerial responsibility for the Fair Trading Commission which is charged with ensuring that there is fair competition after any merger has given her blessing to the merger. In both cases the two ministers have gone public with a pro-merger stance on the issue of BS&T and Neal & Massy.
It was heartening to hear the Democratic Labour Party issuing some political rhetoric designed to piggyback on the emotions which are currently running hot. All sensible Barbadians are aware that a DLP government if driven to office before the “ink dries” to use Thompson’s statement can do absolutely nothing about the merger if it is the desire of the shareholders. However it is refreshing to hear David Thompson nailing an issue in public which coincides with the Barbadian public.
There was a time that the different statements being issued on the same subject from a Barbados Labour Party government would be in unison like the proverbial barber shop quartet. In recent times we have had Rawle “Diabolical Forces” Eastmond, Clyde “JAWS” Mascoll and Lynette “So Cold” Eastmond making statements which all combine to confuse Barbadians on the merger between BS&T and Neal & Massy and other matters.
We end by quoting an anonymous poster to BU:-
On another point however,I note Owen in today’s Nation newspaper is now saying that “there is an imbalance in the CSME in favour of Trinidad re the exports – while only a few country (he really means just Barbados but too shame to say so),are shouldering the burden of the ‘free movement of people’. Isn’t that what we were saying all along on these blogs and elsewhere? Of course the said Owen and some of those men in the Ivory Tower at Cave Hill said we were XENOPHOBIC. Reality now starting to hit Owen,but he ain’t see nothing yet.
Barbados Shipping & Trading MUST remain in local hands. A strategy of the Prime Minister over the years has been the use of symbols to create deep awareness in the Barbados public. It would be consistent if he were to accept that BS&T is a symbol of the tremendous sweat equity which Barbadians have invested over the years. It is paramount that Barbadians benefit first from what the sleeping conglomerate can still offer. The public of Barbados went to sleep on the Barbados National Bank deal, and Barbadians will have to life with the scare of that occurence.
Not This time!
Related BU Stories
Sir Allan Fields The Man Behind The Orchestration To Dump Barbados Shipping And Trading To The Trinidadians
Senator Lynette Eastmond Shut Up!
Prime Minister Arthur Prefers A Neal And Massy Deal~Barbados Underground Say So
BS&T Going, Going, Soon To Be Gone~ The Advocate Newspaper Should Go Too
The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.