Did I read the Advocate editorial of May 17, 2007 correctly. Just one day after bashing the Advocate newspaper, unapologetically so, we fan the pages this morning only to be confronted by an editorial laced with simplistic analysis. At BU we regard the fact that Barbados’s only conglomerate being gobbled-up by the more cash rich Trinidadian conglomerate, Neal & Massy as deserving of studious analysis. The Advocate editorial makes the obvious argument that market forces in any capitalist market will make decisions with the objective of creating shareholder value. At BU we say brilliant and profound!
To hear the level of virtual panic in utterances from some people on the BS&T/Neal & Massy merger, one might imagine the Barbados partner was being swallowed up against its will. For all we know, the reported disproportionate shareholding may well justify the term take-over, despite assurance from BS&T’s chairman that the transaction, yet to be approved by securities agencies in Barbados and T&T, is a friendly merger of unequals; and that BS&T was not for sale.
BU would have anticipated that a more quality piece of journalism would have analyze and sought to project the fall-out from such a merger given the Goliath status of BS&T; after all its operations is weaved into the Barbados economy in almost all the sectors. Despite our boast of 90+ literacy Barbadians are not financial and investment savvy, this ignorance is exposed when matched against the Trinidad businessmen whose business acumen has been honed from years of functioning in an economy fashioned to serve the world.
Firstly Barbadians should accept that this transaction when approved by the shareholders and regulators must be viewed as a take over. BS&T is an ailing Group and has been for some time. Back in 2003 BS&T believe it or not owned 20% shares in Neal & Massy. However when it had to restructure the financially hemorrhaging motor division, it reduced this share holding to 9% to generate the required cash to offset the resulting write-offs.
Revenue and Net Profit of the BS&T Group improved over the previous year, with strong performances being experienced by United Insurance Company and Almond Resorts Inc. During the year the Group completed another phase of the restructuring of its automotive operations with the establishment of a new Company, Warren Motors Inc., in which it now holds 49%. Warren Motors will take over the operations formerly managed by BS&T Motors.Towards the end of the financial year BS&T reduced its shareholding in Neal & Massy Holdings from 20.1% to 9.2%. The capital gain achieved from this transaction was used partially to accommodate “write offs” incurred in the restructuring of the Motors division and other operations within the Group.Net Income attributable to Shareholders increased by 27%, while earnings per share showed a similar gain over the previous year.The sale of the Neal & Massy shares also had a positive Balance Sheet effect, as it allowed the Company to reduce its debt portfolio substantially.
Source: Neal & Massy
According to the most recent report BS&T shareholding has further dwindled to 3% while Neal & Massy’s stake in BS&T has risen to nearly 24%. Now does this smell like a merger? BS&T really has no choice but to go along with this transaction or face a hostile take over. A check of the Trinidad controlled Sagicor Insurance Company shows that it too has a significant holding in BS&T. It does not take rocket science to deduce that Neal & Massy has the means to support a hostile bid. BU does not intend to focus on the transaction of the take-over because market forces must be allowed to dictate whether the transaction will close or not. However the current public debate must be heard and place in proper perspective. The wholesale acquisition of choice Barbadian properties cannot continue unchecked or we risk being denationalized and “de-culturized”.
Our bashing of the Advocate must continue because the thrust of its editorial scoffed at the Barbadian public cry of concern at its lone conglomerate being snapped-up like a dog would a bone. The Advocate needs to appreciate that although Barbados cannot stop market forces directly; the one way “grabbing” of undervalued companies like BS&T must be of concern. The very high level of Trinidad investment in Barbados and the uncompetitive status of Barbadian companies clearly points to the fact that as a country we must seek to enable our business environment by implementing measures which would ensure that our leading companies are securely capitalized.
The obvious start is for the government to put incentives in place to promote private venture capital financing. So to the Advocate we urge you to call a meeting of your editorial staff immediately, the objective –to chart a new direction, and abort your current feeble attempt at journalism.
Errol Barrow warned us that one day bajans will wake up and realize that Barbados no longer belongs to bajans,that time my friends is upon us whether we like it or not,what i would like BU to do is print a story on the American Federal Reserve and the fraud it continues to wage on the american people,knowing that private bankers run the states,money is worthless paper,there is no income tax law but americans still pay it to the IRS and how the 13 elite bloodlines continue to rule the earth through fear and manipulation of people.
When this is done you will see why there is a need for a world government and why people all over the globe if foolish enough will be drawn into the elitists plans,then you will understand what must happen in the caribbean and why we can’t stop it.
Freewilly~how do you respond to the analogy that in Barrow’s time one mode of popular travel was the donkey card but today it is the motor car. In other words our societies are dynamic and will have to change as the world changes around it to survive.
Also when Neal & Massy bought into BS&T in a big way a few years ago that was when the merger was really suppose to happen but remember it was about the time we had the euphoria of the fishing agreement. The climate was not ready for the merger then.
I suspect many important people have purchased shares back then and stand to make a windfall when the price go up after the takeover.
What about the Bermudez Biscuit Company take over of the 97 year Barbadian owned West India Biscuit Co. Ltd.
wonder what is happening there
Warrior~Bermudez has had controlling interest for awhile. The latest move would give them complete control.
BS&T deserved to be swallowed-up, as they have been content to be a big fish in a small pond for far too long. Over the years the company has been beset by nepotism and poor management. The worst day in their lives was the closure of the Bridgetown Club – I mean, how the Dickens were they going to spend their afternoons? They never had the ambition to expand their business away from Barbados and into the wider Caribbean. It was just too easy pickings having control over food distribution, aircraft handling, etc. A chicken ripe for plucking, and their managment and staff in Barbados will soon find themselves royally plucked as well.
Pingback: Prime Minister Arthur Prefers A Neal And Massy Deal~Barbados Underground Say So « Barbados Underground
Pingback: Former Deputy Speaker Ezra Alleyne~Has He Passed the Point Of No Return? « Barbados Underground