Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Many BU blogs ago, during what this blogmaster described as the Indo-Guyanese “invasion,” this blogmaster warned that Barbados needed a serious national conversation to levelset on the island’s changing demographics. This change, we were told, was driven by an ageing population and the liberalisation of freedom of movement tied to our commitment to CSME and CARICOM.

With the recent appointment of Khaleel Kothdiwala to the Upper Chamber, following the failed attempt in 2022, concerns about the dilution of the Barbadian identity have resurfaced. Regardless of the level of political praise directed at Mr. Kothdiwala, he appears to be an intelligent and articulate young man, and this blogmaster wishes him every success. However, there remains a broader concern about the growing influence of racial and ethnic interest groups in Barbados and what this may mean for the country’s social cohesion.

It is unfortunate that Barbados, once celebrated as a country punching above its weight, now seems to lack the maturity to decide what kind of nation it is being deliberately shaped to become. We cannot have ethnic groups who are born, educated, and working in Barbados and still expect to exclude them from any part of the running of the country. Or should we?

Against this background, the new Immigration and Citizenship Bill, 2026, currently being debated in Parliament should be of interest to the civic minded. The contribution by Minister Marsha Caddle is noteworthy, as she sought to clarify and simplify what is, as in any country, an emotive debate on immigration matters.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

24 responses to “Khaleel Kothdiwala, Immigration Bill 2026 and Barbados’ Future”


  1. Barbados’s population is black and 3.1% is multiracial

    if 1 man and 1 woman make some babies and families by sexing
    how many generations would it take to dilute the 92.4% black

    if black and brown and white and yellow make mixed race children
    then what is the problem anyway


  2. @ David

    I read this article approximately 4 times, yet I don’t understand what point you are trying to make.

    You mentioned Guyanese. Since Rhianna’s mother is Guyanese, do Guyana and Barbados have an equal claim to her fame?

    Peter Morgan, a Canadian, was a former Minister of Tourism. Mara Thompson and Felicia Dujon, both St. Lucians, were DLP candidates in previous general elections, with Thompson being the duly elected parliamentary representative for St. John.

    Isn’t Khaleel Kothdiwala’s mother Black and his father of Indian descent?

    Isn’t Marsha Caddle’s husband, Dr Abdul Mohamed, of Indian descent?

    I’m sure you’re aware the Electoral and Boundaries Commission (EBC) had previously prevented Commonwealth citizens from voting in Barbados, thereby upholding a long-standing policy that the agency was not authorised to register anyone as an elector in island, unless that person was a citizen or had the immigration status of resident or immigrant in Barbados.

    In May 2018, a few days before the 2018 General Elections, the Barbados Court of Appeal ruled that people residing on the island for more than three years should be included in the list of voters, after the legal team of Wilfred Abrahams, Brian Weekes, Gregory Nicholls, Alexandra Daniel and Leslie Haynes who represented Grenadian Shireen Ann Mathlin-Tulloch, Jamaican Michelle Russell, Montserratian Sharon Edgcome-Miller and St. Lucian Professor Eddy Ventose, who formed part of a class action lawsuit challenged the EBC’s position of not allowing them to register and join the voters’ list.

    The Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) subsequently ordered that St. Lucian, Professor Eddy Ventose, was to be added to the register of voters and was qualified and entitled to vote in Barbados.

    My concern is that, while the Arab, Indian, Pakistani and white communities have remained in the background, assumedly making financial contributions to political parties perhaps to influence business descisions in their favour, there is an increasing influx of Jamaicans entering Barbados who, overtime, may be enough to change to political landscape in this island.

    After all, we have a Jamaican, Marcia Weekes, on social media talking shiite and encouraging Bajans to ‘march up and down Buhbadus.’


  3. A country which pretends to embrace ‘others’.

    Yet which has never come to grips with its own majority population at any deep level

    Even as ‘foreigners’ were always accorded a halcyon place within the society, given a pass, allowed to corrupt politicians, etc

    We are now destined to prove Uncle Errol right. For it was he who said one day coming soon Bajans will loose their country.

    That the country now has as PM a woe-unto-man, ignorant about natural population regeneration, intent on following what her European mistresses have told her, we are not to be surprised when similar outcomes there happen here.


  4. I am all for managed immigration taking all relevant factors into consideration. And I am not in agreement with the approach of this government. However, I believe we should be careful not to sound like Magats in the process of disagreeing. There is a way to voice political, socio-economic, racial and cultural concerns without disparaging, demeaning, belittling, stereotyping, dehumanising those who wish to live here.


  5. So ‘success’ is having a lotta childless women pretending to be ‘bosses’, while complaining that;
    – we are no longer a self sustaining society… 90,000 short of inhabitants
    – the men are mostly a bunch of brass bowls, ‘bullers’, and effeminates -except for the ZR and block rejects.
    – we are unable to get any shiite to work – despite having ALL available hands
    – our best young talents ROUTINELY choose to go and live in better managed societies
    – crime, violence and debt is increasingly the norm in all sectors
    – education has morphed into ‘eddykashun’ and we are not even able to resolve an 11-plus issue

    The problem is that we have no national LEADERSHIP
    …. and where there is no vision, the brass suffers,
    …NISSS goes broke, …retirement age goes up,
    …begging becomes endemic,
    …and meanwhile the lotta childless women do what they do best… TALK shiite and pass stupid laws.

    What a place
    What lack of vision.
    What a price we will ALL pay…!

  6. 2 - 6 supermix discussion Avatar
    2 – 6 supermix discussion

    It is good to have an X number of different posters with an equal number X of different opinions to add to the 2 – 6 supermix discussion as it flushes out many points to ponder for consideration which may all have some truth and it’s how the Underground of Barbados blog works best (without all the bitching like bitches).

    It seems a couple of dudes object to women or lesbians in charge and although the incumbent Barbados PM has not officially outed any proclivity leanings, she is not the 1st or 2nd lesbian prime minister in this world and the times they are a changing.

    I like to live in a place with every culture within
    this is what makes London Town more colourful


  7. Lil bit more and I would have been one of those childless women. I loved being everybody’s favourite auntie, but never longed for motherhood. And yet, nobody would have ever considered me useless. This “childless women” insult needs to stop! There are many reasons why many women don’t have children. One of them is that it is so difficult to raise them mostly without the father’s full participation and also to pursue a career. The career is necessary in anticipation of the man leaving you for some young girl and refusing to pay you what the court has ordered after the divorce. I know of many instances where that has happened. I would advise all women to plan ahead and not depend on a man for support.

    My reason for not wanting children was that the world is a frightening place in which to raise a child. Twenty-three years ago, I didn’t even know how frightening it would become. And it is so mainly because of men!

    But, pointing fingers at each other only makes matters worse. Both men and women have contributed to the mess. As adults, we should be trying to figure out how we are going to clean it up. Some people need to grow up and stop with the nonsensical misogyny. Balls are useful for producing sperm. That’s all!


  8. Bushie

    This guvment’s attitude towards immigration, as an organizing principle was always destined to fail.

    This criminal act on which the guvment is doubling down on is already failing. But once trust is put in a leadership who knows no reverse gear failure is unavoidable.

    Besides America, very few countries have lived to tell the tale. And America was,in reality always a lie, a fiction, on all counts.


  9. The Creator did EVERYTHING for a reason. And ultimately, ‘success’ is contingent on trusting the wisdom and logic of that Creator’s guidelines.

    So when a set of confused jackasses take it upon themselves to come up with their OWN guidelines, …when they CLEARLY don’t even know their own ass from their `faces, …Bushie can only dead with laughter like shiite!!!

    Imagine a creature that is SPECIFICALLY designed to create, nurture, mold, and guide the future generation… CHOOSING INSTEAD to take on the role of leader, provider, protector, pot-hole fixer, crime-fighter, soldier and gang fighter… cause they want to show ‘balls’…

    What the donkey would you expect to become of the youth?
    Where the donkey would future citizens then come from? …AI robots?
    Where would the current youth get needed wise guidance?

    Shiite!
    It ain’t OBVIOUS that there would be a SHORTFALL in population?
    Ain’t it OBVIOUS that the current youth would lack WISE guidance -and turn to the BLOCK rebels instead of to caring MOTHERS?

    Ain’t it CLEAR that pot holes would remain a bridge too far…
    Can a bunch of women REALLY control modern drug GANGS?
    … or does THAT require some REAL MEN with REAL, BIG balls?

    Also, whereas effective male leaders like Barrow and Adams pursued OWNERSHIP and PRODUCTIVITY, …the ‘economists’ and effeminates were all focused on getting ‘dollars’… and hence pursued begging, borrowing, FDI, and prostitution (AKA Tourism), …and selling the family silver.

    The PREDICTABLE RESULT:
    – We are not sustainable as a society – cause the women are mostly “Y-men’ and the ‘men’ are increasingly effeminate.
    – Our children are hopeless – no guidance, no jobs, no ownership, no future beyond laboring on some Massa’s modern plantation…
    – We are in DEEP and increasing debt – to the same damn white people who spent the last 500 years mistreating our fore-parents
    – Our NATIONAL assets belong to PREDATORS like Emera, FLOW, Digicell, Massy, SAGICOR, etc
    – etc etc etc

    The ONLY damn positive is our vote in support of CUBA (now THERE is a country that STANDS UP against brass bowlery – and suffers the consequences, somewhat like the original Bushman who was crucified)

    So… we IGNORE the Creator’s manual, write OUR OWN shiite rules, …and are now complaining that the machine ain’t wukking right…!

    What a bunch of BB JAs…
    What a place!
    What blindness!


  10. ” Balls are useful for producing sperm. That’s all! ”

    I’m a doctor..

    and hormones, with testosterone serving as the main male sex hormone.


  11. @ Bush

    Woman can be good leaders, with less ego and bravado than men

    Look at USA

    Obama is good at arguing and insulting the racist whites

    The racist whites hate being exposed for their evil ways

    so they doubled down with a racist president who is a foolish fool


  12. Bushie

    Nonsense!

    What creator what?

    Even a fool could see that there was never any creator has still believed by many, as you can’t but see it, some brass bowl body with a mind representing some primordial analogue contemplated by humans.

    Except, Mother Nature Herself, of course! And she never required such spooky mental gymnastics as best practiced by you.

    And it’s another ignorance to talk about anything being created as if a work completed

    For Pachamama is still at work. The universes are still expanding. We can still hear the resounding explosion of that much maligned Big Bang 14 billions years hence.

    Stop being ignorant!


  13. @Artax

    As a country there is a conversation to be add about how we want to fashion our small society with the talk about adopting an aggressive immigration policy.


  14. @ Kiki
    “Woman can be good leaders, with less ego and bravado than men”
    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
    Some children too… even a rare jackass…
    So why don’t you step up to the plate den?

    What the Hell are you doing in London anyway?
    Hanging out and collecting scraps on the steps of the same racists that you claim to dislike?
    Seupsss…
    If Bushie ever get hands on BU’s ‘ban-key’ – your little Sri Lankan burro will be history…


  15. Can the young lion tame the tigress?

    Say, Khaleel, Shakespeare sent you a message. He said: “Tell young Kothdiwala ‘to thine own self be true. And it must follow, as the night the day, thou canst not then be false to any man’.”

    All evidence suggests that we are not only faced with a one-party Government, we are faced with a one-person leader, and there is seldom, or maybe, never, any dissent from other Government members in Parliament or the Senate. The many laws passed only to be backpedalled speaks to a lack of effective debate.

    But we believe you have within you the integrity to stand up and say: “Madame Prime Minister, I cannot with any conscience support you in this matter.” The biggest avalanche can be triggered by the smallest pebble rolling down a hill. And, perchance, others may get the courage to follow you.

    Absolute power corrupts absolutely. We see once-great America now controlled by a mentally-deranged, narcissistic despot who would think nothing of taking the lives of thousands of innocent people. Let’s try to get Barbados back on the road to being a democracy.

    Surveys

    So, Khal, start with some obvious issues. Those high-intensity white vehicle lights “cause intense discomfort and temporary flash blindness”. Surveys show that “nearly 90 per cent of drivers consider modern headlights too bright and a threat to road safety”. Get them banned.

    We have limited agricultural land. Yet, instead of building on the rocky “rab” land traditionally used for sour grass pastures, we are allowing more and more agricultural land to go into housing and buildings. If ever again deprived of imported food, Bajans could face starvation. When my sister-in-law Senator Frances Chandler asked an MP how come some fertile farm land was approved for housing, she was told “Money pass”. Fight for our agricultural land, Khaleel.

    And in your role as a youth developer, show the youths examples of Blacks who have risen to be successful businessmen despite little education and humble origins. It is my opinion that positive encouragement will do far more that the constant harping back to black slavery and inhuman treatment. May Allah guide your efforts, Khaleel.

    Let me now turn to that greatest of Bajan delicacies – black pudding and souse. Its origins are a tribute to African ingenuity. “Enslaved Africans were given the less desirable, discarded parts of the pig such as the ears, snout, tongue, trotters and head. The plantation owners kept the prime cuts. To clean and preserve these meats without refrigeration, they were boiled and seasoned in lime juice, salt, hot peppers, and so on.”

    The pudding was made by stuffing pig’s intestines with grated sweet potato, herbs, spices and pig’s blood. “Some culinary historians note similarities to British sausage-making traditions brought over by early European indentured servants in the 1600s, which merged with African ingenuity.”

    Nowadays Bajans, black and white, line up on Saturdays for their pudding and souse. I started as a boy with Delcina in Jackson, moved on to Miss Lucas in Chelsea Road, Commander Marshall, Mrs Connell in Dayrells, Mrs Grant by YMPC, Noreen in Shorey Village. After a break I have finally, and happily, latched on to Omar.

    Mrs Grant deserves special mention. She had a salt bread over the door whom I would greet. She would give me a plateful to eat. Then I would take my share and one for the priest, who would give it back to me.

    She was from Surinam and a Catholic. One rainy Saturday night she doused me with seven different spirits in bottles to ward off evils. Then she sprayed on an extra strong spirit in an aerosol can to take revenge on anyone who harmed me. I have seen him in action, no lie.

    Long live pudding and souse, our national hero.

    Richard Hoad is a farmer and social commentator. Email porkhoad@gmail.com.

    Source: Nation


  16. Sorry @michaellashley, given you track record and the transport ministry with enactment of laws, there is no confidence in you.

    Lashley: Bills include safeguards

    Minister of Legal Affairs and Criminal Justice Michael Lashley is reassuring Barbadians that the new Immigration and Citizenship bills will not open the floodgates, telling the House of Assembly that procedural safeguards are built into the legislation to balance national security with natural justice.

    “We don’t want Barbadians to think that we’re opening the floodgates,” Lashley told the House during a short contribution to the debate on Tuesday. The Citizenship Bill, he said, carries safeguards: written notice of deprivation, disclosed grounds, and an independent inquiry committee chaired by a legally qualified person.

    Lashley, noted that civil society, political parties and ordinary Barbadians had helped shaped the bills at the committee stage. He said, “that creates a whole atmosphere of transparency and accountability”. He also welcomed a provision requiring the minister to table a register of new citizens in Parliament, likening it to the Housing Act’s requirement on land acquisitions.

    The minister said the legislation would strengthen Barbados’ efforts to combat human trafficking, illegal firearms and transnational gangs, recalling that he had faced questioning from international partners only last week.

    “We will be bringing these pieces of legislation that will secure our borders and protect the public interest and national security,” he said.

    The bills create a list of persons barred from entry – human traffickers, drug traffickers and serious criminals – and make it an offence to enter Barbados using false travel documents or passports obtained by fraud. Lashley recalled a court case in which a man appeared with a fraudulent passport and, six months later, reappeared under a different name and passport number, a loophole that previously carried only minor penalties. Under the new bills, the conduct is a summary offence with fines of up to $150 000.

    He also revealed a personal brush with the existing regime. Born outside Barbados to Barbadian parents working in England, he was told on returning home that he had to register as a foreign student at the community college. “I have a card that I walk with, it says ‘citizen by descent’,” he said. “I was the victim of our Immigration Act.”

    In closing, Lashley echoed his colleague, St John MP, Charles Griffith, arguing that the modernised regime would allow skilled grandchildren of Barbadians in sports, music and other fields to return to the country and share their talents.

    “Although we have the safeguards, we still operate in the interests of natural justice and fairness,” he said.

    The bill was passed.

    (MB)

    Source: Nation


  17. Same difference, Dub. All connected.

  18. Righteous Synergy Avatar
    Righteous Synergy

    Wait there is a joyful noise – come revelry
    To be in tranquility and inna plenty
    EMBRACE THE GIFTS OF JAH FOR THE WORLD TO SEE
    Everything is not just dishonour and depravity
    Let them hear a sound resounding with equity
    All the members of the earth that was born from Trinity –
    In Africa, Ethiopia is your ancestry”


  19. Well, well, well! If you poke hard enough, you get the full story! We got the full frontal racism from Lawson. And now, we get the naked misogyny from Bush Tea. FINALLY, we can see him in all his masculine “glory”, swibbly balls and stick and all!

    So, women must all stay at home having babies and raising them. What happens if we are barren? What happens if we lack the “maternal instinct”? We are useless to society?

    What happens when women have no presence outside of the home, no voice, no money, no power, no control over their destiny?

    We are treated like property, to be discarded on a whim, without recourse. We are beaten and raped without recourse! We are even murdered without recourse! We know the history, even the very recent history of the patriarchal society. We have the statistics.

    Most of the time, we women need protection from MEN both inside and outside of the home!

    And what does it control the scourge of criminal gangs? (Mostly made up of men, we should note.) It takes brains more so than brawn. And surprise— we women have brains! Besides which, there have always been kick ass warrior women out there who would bust Bush Tea’s pathetic ass!

    It’s all well and good for Bush Tea to assign these roles based on physical characteristics. But what happens when one party consistently fails to perform the assigned role? When women all stayed in the homes having babies and raising children, what were the men doing, both outside and inside of it?

    THEY WERE FAILING MISERABLY to provide and protect!

    But…I guess that is the fault of the women, for not guiding the next generation in the right direction. Can’t be! Because I remember Bush Tea telling me that ultimately, it takes a man to raise a man!

    This world is the way it is mostly because of male leaders. It changed somewhat for the better when people, including women fought for the right to participate on an equal footing. We still have a way to go. And yet, I wouldn’t have wanted to grow up in my grandmother’s day, when her sister’s husband killed his wife, burst my grandmother’s ear with a hammer and “en get a day”.


  20. And now that the floating shit is flushed for a bit, perhaps we can address the real issues with our immigration system.

    I have seen stubborn floaters resurface, not fully flushed. I will deal with them as needed.


  21. Correction: what does it take to control


  22. Just one more thing. I remember being told the story of Barbadian “paydays” of old.

    The story is that when the men in the neighbourhood received their paltry pay from the plantations, they would stop at the rumshops before going home. One word from their wives, as they saw what was left, and a chorus of cries would erupt like a Mexican wave, from house to house, as each arrived at their abode and every woman received her weekly share of licks.

    Judging from what I saw of men in my grandparents’ days, dat en nutten to doubt.


  23. “This “childless women” insult needs to stop! There are many reasons why many women don’t have children”

    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

    I wholeheartedly agree.

    Perhaps we’re purposely ignoring any biological, medical or personal reasons for some women not having children to assume they’re all lesbians.

    There are ALSO MANY CHILDLESS MEN as well, including politicians, priests and prominent members of the society, to whom misandrists would equally apply the ‘insult.’

    However, the misogynist may ignore that childlessness to focus more so on the contributions those men made to the country.

    I know of a situation involving a man who does not have any children because his wife unfortunately lost two pregnancies as a result of a vehicular accident and after tripping over an open culvert in Bridgetown.

    He thought about going outside his marriage to father a child, but decided to remain with his wife instead.

    Him being a ‘childless man’ does not mean he’s ‘buller,’ but is as a result of unfortunate circumstances and subsequently a personal decision he made.

    These types of conversations open the doors for people to characterise specific groups of people within the population.

    The so-called ‘moralists,’ for example, often express judgmental and demographic characterisations, such as ‘multi-partner fertility,’ to describe ‘an individual who had biological children with more than one partner over the course of his/her life.’

    The truth is, over the years we’ve had childless women AND men, as well as both men and women who had children, all of whom have ‘talked shiite and passed stupid laws.’

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending