Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

โ† Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Grenville Phillips II, Leader of Solutions Barbados

Our children are currently preparing for the Common Entrance Examination, so we can expect the same debates about the exam that we have been having for the past 40 years.ย  Imagine that.ย  We essentially waste our time on this issue every year while our politicians make no meaningful improvements.ย  Well, not under a Solutions Barbados administration.

The two sides of this debate are that some want to abolish the exam while some want to keep it.ย  The reasons for each side are many and diverse, and all of them have merit.

The main reasons advanced for abolishing the exam are the belief that it perpetuates an elitist society, and that one examination should not have such serious consequences on a childโ€™s future.ย  On the other side, persons believe that it is the fairest method available for allocating students to schools that have a history of higher academic performance and discipline.

Barring any permanent mental challenges, with time, all of our students can master all of the information that they are taught.ย  However, some of them, whom we call early learners, will learn it before their peers.

For example, some of our children may be able to write the alphabet earlier, when they are 4 years old, while others may learn it later when they are 6.ย  If our children are examined on their knowledge of the alphabet when they are 5 years old, then those who learnt the information earlier will do better.ย  However, if all students are examined when they are 6 years old, when all students understand the material, then the test will be fair to all.

We currently teach and examine all students on the information that only the early learners have the capacity to fully understand.ย  Therefore, the early learners tend to do well and are assigned to secondary schools with other early learners.ย  The late learners tend to do poorly in this exam that is designed for early learners, and are assigned to secondary schools with other late learners.

Some late learners will develop into early learners after they have been assigned and will outperform their peers.ย  The remaining late learners will then become: frustrated at not being able to understand the material, discouraged at the consistent low scores they receive, and disinterested in the subject.ย  They finally stop trying to learn when they believe the lie that the information can only be understood by a person who is intellectually superior.

Our school system reinforces the idea in our children and parents that the early learners are intellectually superior high-achievers, and should be directed to more academic study.ย  The late learners are deemed intellectually inferior low-achievers, and are encouraged to work with their hands.ย  When parents and teachers have given-up on our late learners, we perpetuate a slavery mentality that some of us must advance so far and no further.ย  This is the root cause of many of our social problems.

There appears to be a failure to appreciate that when a late learner is allowed to understand what the early learner learnt previously, then both the early and late learners can perform at an equal level of competence.ย  They are all high achievers then, with the same level of aptitude.ย  In a Solutions Barbados administration, the Common Entrance Examination will be fair, and the school curriculum will be rearranged so that it benefits all of our students, instead of only our early learners.

The Government mandates that all parents must send their children to school.ย  After daily rewarding our early learners and frustrating our late learners, the school system sends them back to their parents with false notions of intellectual superiority and inferiority.

Our school system has done all of our students and parents, employees and employers a grave disservice.ย  It has perpetuated the slavery idea that some are entitled to privilege, while others are to go so far and no further.ย  For overseeing this most diabolical system for the past 40 years, and refusing to listen to any voice of justice, the BLP and DLP do not deserve a single seat in our Parliament.

Grenville Phillips II is the President of Walbrent College and the founder of Solutions Barbados.ย  He can be reached at NextParty246@gmail.com

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

63 responses to “The Grenville Phillips Column | Letter – Perpetuating Mental Slavery”


  1. Just wasted 2 minutes reading this twaddle!


  2. @Pingpong

    I disagree it was not two minutes wasted, did not detect ISO9001 mentioned once.


  3. If this is what passes as Solutions Barbados’ education policy then we are in serious trouble. The problem is that Grenville must allow the other 29 of his candidates to express themselves.


  4. Wily Coyote

    Hahahaha….. you should have listened to the “People’s Parliament.” Paul Gibson mentioned ISO9001 on several occasions.

    Grenville Phillips II mean well, but, as “de ole peeple” used to say…….. “he too strong headed.”


  5. Who are we to dismiss Grenville and SB if the current state we find ourselves can be mapped to successive BLP and DLP governments?


  6. Time waits for no one.

    If you can move on at 4, go for it.


  7. David BU

    Are you serious? So far, Grenville Phillips II and Solutions Barbados’ policies are simplistic….or perhaps it is the method Phillips II is using to articulate these policies that makes them appear to be simplistic.

    Additionally, I (and Hal Austin) have often mentioned that Phillips II needs to allow other members of his team to fully explain his party’s policies and how these policies will address the issues confronting this island.

    He had adequate time to select candidates as “shadow ministers” who would have been able address pertinent issues and further articulate SB’s policies. Instead, he wasted time attacking the Opposition.

    In my opinion, so far, the UPP has out performed Solutions Barbados in VOB’s “The People Parliament.”

    Then again…there are those individuals who are quick to dismiss Phillips II offering he and his candidates as “successful businessmen”……….

    ………..but are quick to endorse a “successful businesswoman” such as Natlee.

  8. Frustrated Businessman: Animal Farm sequel playing out in Bim. Avatar
    Frustrated Businessman: Animal Farm sequel playing out in Bim.

    I agree with the issues identified but I do not agree with your analysis.

    The Law of Natural Selection cannot be defeated.

    Hundreds of years of various good-intentioned people’s and institutions’ efforts to do that have failed; Communism being the most glaring example of all.

    Life is competitive from the time we are pushed out to the time we are laid in a king’s or pauper’s grave.

    If you had suggested that secondary school attendance should be re-shuffled after 3rd form exams, I would agree with you whole-heartedly.

    I know of several Harrison and Queens students who could not keep up after 3rd form and I know of several Garrison and Lester Vaughn students who were kept back by curriculum’s that catered for slower students there.

    What we cannot do is pretend that life in the real world is anything other than competitive, that would be doing our children the greatest disservice of all.

    In the real world, everyone in the running race doesn’t get a trophy like they do in primary school.

    The last thing this country needs is more educated and qualified slackers.


  9. Talking Loud Saying Nothing March 28, 2018 at 7:39 AM #

    A couple former colleagues of mine recently returned from watching the England cricket tour and all they could talk about was the quality of the driving.
    I had to remind them that Barbadians believe they are the bet drivers in the world. There is nothing worse than driving a car with an H registration on it.
    In reality, they ignore signals, they drive in any lane and cut across other vehicles and they speed needlessly. Just look at the road traffic accident statistics. That is all the evidence you need.
    I used to think it funny having a public education advertisement on television with a sergeant advising people how to drive at round-abouts. Is there a highway code in Barbados, and if so is it used by motorists?


  10. Can we expect a SB government to implement ISO9001 to make all secondary schools equal ?

  11. Bernard Codrington Avatar
    Bernard Codrington

    @ Hants at 8 :53 AM

    What do you mean by equal? What are the social benefits of an equal school? Can this noble objective be achieved? Or rather has it been achieved anywhere in this world?


  12. @ Bernard Codrington,

    I asked a question. I don’t have the answer.

  13. BEAUTIFUL BEIGE Avatar

    You are perfectly correct and if The Lord’s Return/Armageddon tarries most people of our age are going to face a rebellious crowd of anarchists.


  14. @David

    You’re serious? Because we are where we are we are to accept nonsense?

  15. Bernard Codrington Avatar
    Bernard Codrington

    @ David at 7 : 54 AM

    Even if your assertion is true, and many of us do not subscribe to your observation, the past is the past. We collectively, willingly or unwillingly , contributed to those outcomes.

    The important issue is what do we do going forward. Our mistake was not to examine what the parties promised and their feasibility. We also lacked in our judgement as to what constitute good leadership. We must eliminate emotionalism and despair and select a group of persons that will deliver most of what the country seeks.


  16. @ Enuff
    Good point…
    What would you call the last 30 years of B/DLP …if not nonsense?

    What David is saying is that perhaps you have become so ‘conditioned’ that you have NO IDEA what ‘nonsense’ is…

    Here is a definition that you may wish to play with….
    Anything that defies the VERY PURPOSE of life constitutes ‘nonsense’.

    @ Frustrated B
    Well said.

    Bushie has long called for ANNUAL ’11+ type’ exams – in multiple areas – ranging from academics, to sport, craft, music etc- which would determine the placement of students for the next year – based on performance.

    The NATURAL law is one of survival of the fittest.
    Brass bowls attempt to create systems that guarantee success for idiots.


  17. ”Brass bowls attempt to create systems that guarantee success for idiots.”

    How true! But don’t mek meh laugh so much


  18. At university I discovered that many a student from the top schools were what I call great test takers. They had test preparation down to a science, whether it was cramming, memorising or using some form of mind mapping, they got it done and it worked. They were said to be naturally bright. They spoke with the highest confidence and could rattle off quotes and equations with ease but ask what they love or like about the subject, nothing.

    Students from the newer secondary schools on the other hand relied more on understanding and applying the knowledge they gained. The more they could relate to the subject and connect with the material the better they performed and the more confident they were when the spoke.

    Both types of students are needed but our education system is prejudiced towards the first type. A country cannot advance when we only recognise one type.

    Our government is being led by too many crammers and memorisers. They can write beautiful papers, give great speeches but present them with a situation not in their books or never encountered before at university and they are lost. Case in point, the current situation we are in.


  19. @Bernard

    To throwaway learnings from the past is not constructive. How do we facilitate ideas required to disrupt?

  20. PoorPeacefulandPolitePensioner Avatar
    PoorPeacefulandPolitePensioner

    What makes Philips think that the CE is not currently already set for late learners. The accepted exam passing grade at UWI undergradauate level is 40%!! The conundrum is similar to the dilemma faced by economists promoting the eradication of poverty . . . there will always be relative poverty and so too “later learners”. His proposal will eventually lead to a dumbing down of the analytical stamina in the country and consequently also to the overvaluation of self-serving politicians that are quick to try currying favour with the public that slavery is obviously at the root of our country’s mismanagement. It’s the Educators that are not rigourous enough !!


  21. @Hants March 28, 2018 at 8:53 AM “Can we expect a SB government to implement ISO9001 to make all secondary schools equal ?”

    Children do not have equal gifts.

    Look at Hants and Bernard, and Grenville and look at me.

    So schools can never be equal. Children, their parents and their teachers have differing and unequal abilities.

    But the state must ensure that schools are equitably funded, that is schools which serve large numbers of special needs children should receive more funding per child. All teacher’s should be exposed to the same basic education/training, and be expected to engage in continuing education, all libraries, labs, workshops, music rooms etc. should meet a specified standard. After all we all pay the same 17.5% VAT on mostly everthing, even those of us who are simpletons.

    The state’s duty is to smooth out familial and societal inequalities.

  22. Bernard Codrington Avatar
    Bernard Codrington

    @ Simple Simon at 1 :14 PM

    You are so right and so bright.

    The state’s duty is to smooth out “familial and societal inequalities”. That is what successive Barbados administrations have been doing even before the advent of the labour parties.

    As you admitted we do have a diverse of preferences and abilities bestowed on us by nature and nurture . It is our belief systems that attribute to these varying abilities and preferences superiority and inferiority.

    We should respect each other as fellow humans. Neither jobs,colour of skin or quantities of material wealth should define us. It is the latter deficiency that we should do some work on.

  23. Bernard Codrington Avatar
    Bernard Codrington

    @ David at 12: 20 PM

    New does not imply better. Fit for purpose and in accordance with the social objectives of the citizens is better. It is not change for change sake that we need but progress and development. The electorate will indicate its preferences in the voting booth.


  24. @Bernard

    Nothing wrong with your theoretical statement. The bottomline is that a democratic system is not perfect as far as delivering the ideal to the citizenry, unfortunately it is the best that we have. Do you know how many รขย€ย˜ignorantรขย€ย™ people vote?


  25. Simple Simon March 28, 2018 at 1:14 PM #

    What we are talking about is equality of opportunity, no equality of outcome. In terms of Barbados, we can start by making public the CXC results for each school every year.
    I have been told by a former senior education official that this information is provided by the Caribbean Examination Council to the ministry every year. Why is it not published?
    Second, once we can have empirical evidence of any disparity, we can then redress that imbalance through policy.
    As long as we pretend that some schools are better than others, then we are simply perpetuating a myth.


  26. Grenville needs to get over it that in spite of the fact that he came from a privileged household he struggled at some period during his schooling.

    Even though the school system is not perfect his radical solutions, which is not based on any published pedagogy will not benefit the majority of our children.

    When my children were young one of them asked me whether there is anything that God cannot do, because we are taught that God is omnipotent are we not? i told the child that not even God can change the past.

    Way past time for Grenville to get over his past failures. Time to celebrate his subsequent and current successes.


  27. Simple Simon March 28, 2018 at 2:58 PM #

    What is his privileged background? I understand his father is an accountant. Is that privileged?


  28. @Hal Austin March 28, 2018 at 2:47 PM “What we are talking about is equality of opportunity, no equality of outcome. In terms of Barbados, we can start by making public the CXC results for each school every year. I have been told by a former senior education official that this information is provided by the Caribbean Examination Council to the ministry every year. Why is it not published? Second, once we can have empirical evidence of any disparity, we can then redress that imbalance through policy.”

    Nothing to disagree with here.


  29. @Hal Austin March 28, 2018 at 2:59 PM “What is his privileged background? I understand his father is an accountant. Is that privileged?”

    Compared to my father who was a tradesman who had to leave school at 11, yes an accountant is privileged.

    Compared to families like mine which raised nearly a dozen children, yes a man from a family with fewer than 5 children is privileged.

    Compared to children who faint on hot over crowded school buses those children who are driven to school by their parents are privileged.

    Accountant’s children who have had optimum nutrition from conception to adulthood are privileged compared to the children of poorly paid labourers or the chronically under employed or under employed.

    Compared to too many of our children who are/were raised in father absent families, a man who was raised in a family where both parents were present and deeply invested in his education and his success is highly privileged.

    And remember no child asks to be born in a poor or dysfunctional family.


  30. “But the state must ensure that schools are equitably funded, that is schools which serve large numbers of special needs children should receive more funding per child. All teacherโ€™s should be exposed to the same basic education/training, and be expected to engage in continuing education, all libraries, labs, workshops, music rooms etc. should meet a specified standard. After all we all pay the same 17.5% VAT on mostly everthing, even those of us who are simpletons.”

    I notice every year this same debate returns like a bad, incurable rash….and no matter how many years it returns, the solutions to the antiquated school system kept in place by backward governments will never change.

    the better funded the schools, with the equipment, technology and skills training to match, the better the performances of the children…this is not about competition, take out the competing element and let children learn at their own pace.

    forward thinking societies have already started leading the way in that regard, the information can be found online, it’s not rocket science and it is workable, especially on such a tiny island with a tiny population.


  31. Simple Simon March 28, 2018 at 3:11 PM #

    OK. Or is this an exaggerated notion of privilege? So the children of lawyers are also privileged? What about the children of plumbers? In the UK lawyers pack up their profession and re-train as plumbers and publicans.
    The problem is not privilege, but families that are too big. I believe government should intervene after two children: making the parents pay the full cost of education, health, etc for a third child, and any further children should be taken in to care.
    We have had this conversation before, but a married couple with two children and in work strand a better chance of providing for their children, than a father or mother with five and six children all with different fathers/mothers and only one parent working.
    The respectable working class are the backbone of our society.

  32. Bernard Codrington Avatar
    Bernard Codrington

    @ Simple Simon at 3:11 PM

    Did you really feel underprivileged because your father was a tradesman and had 11 children?

    Do you really want to convince the BU household that you were really unhappy?

    I am asking you to do some personal retrospection and convince me that if you had the power to change your life experience that you would do so.

    God/ nature in its wisdom put you in your circumstance because HE/SHE/ IT wanted to see how you would manage your situation. Did you think you failed? I do not think so. But do you?


  33. @Hal Austin March 28, 2018 at 3:27 PM “OK. Or is this an exaggerated notion of privilege? So the children of lawyers are also privileged? What about the children of plumbers? In the UK lawyers pack up their profession and re-train as plumbers and publicans.”

    i consider children raised in the homes of loving, sensible parents with adequate income and who are highly invested in their children to be privileged to be blessed. Policy makers need to do whatever is possible to remove inequities…but i’ve also said so this afternoon.

  34. Bernard Codrington Avatar
    Bernard Codrington

    @ David at 2:40 PM

    No. I do not know how many ignorant people vote. But whose fault is it that they do not know how they should vote? Ignorance is not a disease. It is an absence of knowledge and thinking skills. Even the educated suffer this deficiency.

    If you were to take a sample of those who did not vote or spoiled votes , you would be surprised to learn that more than 50% of them are educated beyond primary. The other 50% believe that since they did not vote they are absolved from blame of electing a failed administration.


  35. @ Bernard
    SS….Do you really want to convince the BU household that you were really unhappy?
    +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
    Do you also want Simple Simon to convince us that the bright light in the sky at noon is the sun…? Of course she is ‘unhappy’.

    One minute she would never buy a car …and the next, she is calling those who were driven to school privileged… and those in ‘hot busses’ deprived.
    Those busses were like old time BU back then…. the mixing of the sexes… whaloss!!!
    …pity the poor nerds who were ‘driven’ to school….

    Not only is SS unhappy, she likes it that way…
    She is happy with being unhappy.
    LOL
    ha ha ha


  36. The problem has NOTHING to do with equity.
    Neither equality of opportunity or of ‘privilege’.

    The education system should do three main things.
    1 – teach the PURPOSE of being a part of the society.
    2 – help students to IDENTIFY their strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats
    3 – prepare students to MAXIMISE those strengths and to minimise the weaknesses.

    The rest is left to individual free will, initiative, creativity, balls, imagination, hard work etc.


  37. Simple Simon March 28, 2018 at 3:54 PM #

    Are we talking about parenting or privilege, defined as material possessions and opportunities?
    If we are talking about parenting, then I fully agree; parental love and affection is greater than all the money in the world, the same way that running around the Ivy as a kid were the happiest days of my life. I never saw it that we were poor.
    But ‘privilege’ as you define parents irresponsibly driving their children to school, rather than allow them to mix with their peers on the school bus, could in fact be more damaging.


  38. Hal Austin March 28, 2018 at 3:27 PM “families that are too big. I believe government should intervene after two children: making the parents pay the full cost of education, health, etc for a third child, and any further children should be taken in to care.”

    The birth rate in Barbados is already too low at 1.8 per woman. How much lower can we go? How much lower should we go?

    As for taking children into care? Whose care? And at what financial and social cost? If the parents are too poor to provide the basics how then will they “pay the full cost of education, health, etc.” If the money a’int there Hal it a’int there? And also do we have any evidence from the U.K or from Barbados that poor children taken into care do better than poor children raised by their natural parents? Are adoptive parents, foster parents or institutional care better for children?

    And I am glad that you were not a policy maker in my time, because as a number child 7 of poor, minimally educated parents I would surely have been taken into care, probably by some family who were into “care giving” principally for the money.

    I am no sure why people cannot see reproduction and child rearing as the “real-real work” that it is as when my Little Johnny grew up who do you think that it was it that took and continues to take the first cut of his wages? It is not me, as my requirements are zero. Is it the Barbados Revenue Authority and the National Insurance scheme.


  39. Simple Simon March 28, 2018 at 4:48 PM #

    I am sure you have greater expertise than me on demography, but a reproduction rate of 1.8 does not tell the full story. Is this the reproductive rate for all sectors of society? Some ethnic and religious minorities on average have six, nine, 12 children.
    These kids do not remain little for ever. After a couple decades they too will start making demands on the society.
    A little island of 166 sq miles and about 300000 people, over 1800 people per sq mile, is stretching it a bit.
    Then we have to plan our land use, from roads (too many cars), to agriculture to housing. Already housing density is too much, we virtually live on top of each other.
    There are 7.6bn people in the world, and this is predicted to grow to 11bn by 2100. The world is not getting any bigger.
    In the late 1950s, with a much smaller population, the government of Barbados sent a mission to Dominica to discus re-locating some people. Already people are talking about moving Rohingas to Guyana. This will lead to conflict.
    It is either we control ourselves now (there is no rule of law that every couple or individual woman and man should have children).
    Already, we are getting a contradiction: the magic of medical science, in which men and women over the age of 50 can give birth, and the need to control environmental pressure, including over-population and food and water scarcity. Which is it going to be?


  40. @Bernard Codrington March 28, 2018 at 3:38 PM “Simple Simon at 3:11 PM Did you really feel underprivileged because your father was a tradesman and had 11 children?”

    Nah!!!

    Because not only was he a tradesman, that man knew how to make the ground give up ofod, a gift he has left to his children. The old man has long been dead but he is still “feeding us” not with cash left in the bank, but with some land and the skills necessary to make it produce.

    Thankfully at near three score and ten I have never ever gone to bed hungry.

    But some children then and now do go to bed hungry…and hunger is not good for a child…and the state does have some duty in easing the hunger of poor children.


  41. The littlest Johnnie just came home from school, Only 95% and second in class. Give me half an hour so that I can beat him for failing to get the extra 5 marks.

    Back soon.


  42. Simple Simon March 28, 2018 at 5:04 PM #

    …………and the state does have some duty in easing the hunger of poor children.(Quote).

    No. PARENTS have a duty not to allow their children to go to bed hungry if not DO NOT HAVE ANY MORE CHILDREN. Who had the fun? The state steps in as an act of charity, not an obligation.
    This is the culture of entitlement in which some young men and women think it is a state responsibility to pay for their higher education.


  43. Hal

    Where is the proof that in Barbados or anywhere “ethnic and religious minorities on average have six, nine, 12 children” in 2018?


  44. @Bush Tea March 28, 2018 at 4:03 PM “Those busses were like old time BU back thenโ€ฆ. the mixing of the sexesโ€ฆ whaloss!!!”

    Naughty boy.


  45. ugly kids come from ugly parents,if you dont believe it follow an ugly kid home. So imagine if you have 9 or 12 of these hideous creatures roaming around like the offspring of sawney bean blighting up the place. Hal is right two kids and if one of the parents or grand parents are a mutt a sperm bank has to be included in family planning complete with pictures before a govt license to breed will be alloted.


  46. Enuff March 28, 2018 at 5:36 PM #

    Look at UK statistics.


  47. Table 2: Births by term and ethnicity, England and Wales, 2013

    Bangladeshi
    Indian
    Pakistani
    Black African
    Black Caribbean
    White British
    White Other
    All Other
    Not Stated
    Births
    1
    3
    4
    3
    1
    64
    9
    10
    3


  48. “In 2016, the greatest percentage of all live births (60.6%) occurred in the White British group. The lowest percentages for all live births were for babies from the Bangladeshi and Black Caribbean groups with 1.5% and 0.9% of all live births respectively.” https://www.ons.gov.uk/


  49. We have virtually heard nothing from Solutions Barbados, except for Grenville Phillips. So has he invoked a hush order, or is the rest of his party short on ideas! So, if this continues, and you vote your support to SB then you don’t really know what your getting. Likewise a vote for them maybe a vote taken away for real change.

  50. Well Well & Cut N' Paste At Your Service Avatar
    Well Well & Cut N’ Paste At Your Service

    Grenville is devolving, voters are not looking for secretive dictatorships…they already went thriugh the destructiveness of this secretive government.

    It seems more and more as though Grenville is the front for others to take over once he is installed, whether he knows it or not is open to debate, that is what he is projecting, the electorate don’t seem overly impressed by SB and we cant blame them..

    I dislike secretive politicians, they are well known for being up to no damn good.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading