Compiled by the Department of Management Studies, UWI – Click image to read in PDF

The news that Barbados Dairy Industries Limited (BDIL) has delisted from the Barbados Stock Exchange (BSE) followed by confirmation from the Chairman of Banks Holdings Limited (BHL) Sir Allan Fields that BHL board will be discussing a similar option is not good news for the local investment climate. To state that the Barbados investment climate from inception of the BSE has never been bullish would be an understatement. The delistings will not help to improve the current state. The fact that there has not been any significant interest shown by Barbadians in the traditional and social media is confirmation that the profile of the Barbadian investor does not factor stocks in their investment portfolio.

How should the Barbados authorities who want to develop a financial market with rich options for Barbadians respond? It has become a head scratching exercise. How can we blame non Barbadians for buying out Bajan companies when the locals have demonstrated over time there is no appetite to invest in equities?


  1. Here is the Annual Report for the T&T Stock Exchange 2012:

    http://www.stockex.co.tt/website/uploads/TTSE%20Ar%202011.pdf


  2. There is a perception that the small size of the Barbados market makes it too easy for large shareholders to manipulate the stock price. Add to the the “put through”system that allows large shareholdings to change hands at prices higher than the listed price, giving small shareholders no chance to see their shareholding increase in value at the same time. Shareholders in Almond have seen their value disappear, and companies like Goddards Enterprise, for example, have their share prices way undervalued.


  3. I think that part of the problem is that there are too many small, stock exchanges in the Caribbean region. Some of which are quite illiquid. At the end of the day, the goal is to accumulate capital. I think that in these hard financial times the nationality of the investors is secondary. Perhaps there is need for more public education to encourage persons to invest, in local businesses.
    I think that the creation of a regional stock exchange could create synergies and attract more regional and international investment.


  4. @Peltdownman

    If what you say is true do you think the average man carries the perception you suggest?


  5. @fragile80

    Understand your point but the number of exchanges does not address the problem of an obvious lack of confidence by the average man in buying stocks. This is not seen as a viable means of wealth creation. It is mainly the upper middleclass/professional who see buying stock as a means to diversify investment portfolios other than leaving the money in the bank or credit union.


  6. @ David
    Many Barbadians feel – perhaps erroneously – that the Barbados Stock Exchange is a little Club managed by a tight little group to which they have been selectively excluded from the real decision process.

    They have no confidence in those who control the buisnesses, perhaps this is misguided but one cannot be a Lion in the morning and a Lamb at night.


  7. @Yardbroom

    Did not want to be the first to communicate what you have accurately posited.

    The question must be what is it we need to do to be the catalyst for a new way of public thinking. Coterminously, how can the club be dispersed.


  8. @ David

    Yes the average man may not see the stock exchange as a viable investment. But I think this is still tied into the inefficiency of our small regional markets. There is little or no movement , nothing to really entice people to invest. So education alone will not work if the market is not functioning as it should.


  9. @fragile80

    Yes but the dynamism which you want to see is linked partly to ignorance about how public companies operate. There is no curiosity by average folk to read balance sheets etc.

    By efficiency of the regional stock exchanges what specifically do you mean?


  10. @ David
    This will be very difficult to accomplish – in the present interlude – given the mind-set of those to whom I have referred. The seismic shift necessary will require more “will” than is presently evident in Barbados by….. those who can.

    This mind set has held us back from real democratic development and ensured vested interest make short term gains much to the disadvantage of the “majority section” of our society. Much can be done to reverse this trend but we need a real leader of the people, for the people, which genuinely includes all Barbadians.

    We live in a bubble that can easily be pricked.


  11. A market is efficient if the prices of the stock reflect the true underlying value as stock prices change based on the availability of news and information. So for instance, if a company is making a 5 million dollar loss, one would expect the stock price to drop to reflect this. However in the regional stock markets the prices hardly change no matter what is happening to the companies.


  12. @fragile80

    Thanks, on the same page.

    What role do you see for the brokers and those who hold seats on the respective exchanges to be part of the solution here?


  13. @ David

    Well first I think that there needs to be movement towards integration of the exchanges so that we can enjoy synergies and have more efficiency. Once this has been accomplished then public education on the part of the brokers and exchanges will be needed to encourage the average person to invest.
    I think that FICS and First Citizens investments services in Saint Lucia have been doing a lot in terms of encouraging persons to invest.


  14. @fragile80

    Here is a document which strikes back to 2008 which sought to distill the strategy to harmonize regional stock exchanges. Perhaps if Dr. Robinson peeks at this blog he will give is a current state.

    http://www.cartac.org/UserFiles/File/CGSR%20Annual%20Conference/Update%20on%20the%20Implementation%20of%20Caribbean%20Exchange%20Network%20(CXN)%20-%20Marlon%20Yarde.pdf


  15. @ David

    Interesting read. Thanks for sharing…


  16. I note the mention of the insularity of our Caribbean nations and I see this as a major stumbling block.
    Even cricket ( which once seemed like a uniting force) is full of division these days; far less for more complicated financial issues…


  17. Good point and you can add the UWI. It appears the three campuses are mostly operating as autonomous institutions. It will be a long pull.


  18. http://www.nationnews.com/articles/view/bank-rebranded/

    So de tall boots on de hot chicks is Canadian eh!

  19. The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall Avatar
    The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall

    @Hants: “So de tall boots on de hot chicks is Canadian eh!

    No. But we know how to “hot” them up…

    We give them a little back bacon, and then have them kill a baby seal using a rowing paddle. All are brought down in a private jet.

    It puts a little “lift” into their step.

    (I’m joking, of course.)

  20. The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall Avatar
    The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall

    @BU.David…

    C&W just farted in the middle of our conversation.

    You might want to tell cwc-launches-pay-tv-in-barbados that BU is not interested in advertising for LIME.


  21. @The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsal

    It looks more like the rebranding of a bawdy house.


  22. @Hants

    What is your beef with the article? That Canadians taking over 🙂

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading