Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

There is another important exercise unfolding in the Barbados Parliament. One of the most important working committees of parliament – PUBLIC ACCOUNTS COMMITTEE (PAC) – chaired by leader of the Opposition Reverend Joseph Atherley has been meeting to call to account the workings of the Transport Board. The revelations from the PAC so far corroborate the Auditor General’s several reports over the years – see recent Auditor General Special Audit of the Transport Board 2019. The Transport Board joins the Queen Elizabeth Hospital, Barbados Water Authority and other SOEs to be deliberately mismanaged by BOTH political parties over the years to facilitate the siphoning of taxpayers dollars to feed corrupt behaviour.

 

It is good to see the PAC doing its work and carried live for the public to follow. From the number of views logged on the videos it tells a story of perennial disinterest by the general public. Truth be told the matter of a lack of civic awareness and lack of engagement in our system of democracy by Barbadians is a subject the BU family has flogged unmercifully over the years.

Some of us are quick to call for impact assessment studies; environmental, traffic, social  to be undertaken to inform important decision making by the authorities.   The blogmaster takes the opportunity to ask for another study to determine the impact of a poorly run Transport Board on the nation of Barbados about to celebrate our 53rd year of independence.

After watching the first PAC meeting on the 4th November 2019 the blogmaster decided to visit the Bridgetown river bus terminal early a morning to observe and experience first hand. The terminal has the look and feel of any public terminal, the PA system was used efficiently to inform the public when to queue at the gates.  A few private buses co-opted by the Transport Board to supplement public transport were seen doing the job. The one negative was the length of time one had to wait for a bus. The blogmaster boarded a bus at 9AM and scores of children were still in the terminal and standing at bus stops along the route waiting to be transported. The look of resignation on the young faces suggest the wait was a normal occurrence.

The mismanagement of the Transport Board and other State Owned Entities (SOEs) by successive governments have had a debilitating financial and SOCIAL impact on our people. A mismanaged Transport Board continues to contribute to the degradation of our society and the powers that be prefer to serve self interest rather than deliver on the mandate to serve the people. Something has got to give!

 

 

 


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

162 responses to “Call to Account – Corruption and Mismanagement Rife @Transport Board”


  1. I read the link that Waru sent from a different post. It was discovered during an audit that 7 buses had disappeared Hal calls this incompetence; I call it brazen corruption.


  2. “I call it brazen corruption.”

    Hal has never been familiar with the definition of the word corruption.


  3. @TLSN

    Was an audit done of assets? If so when it discovered that the buses were not accounted for?


  4. Go and listen to the committee hearing or read the special audit report.


  5. @ Hal,

    We elect toxic governments and seem surprise when they act against the interests of the people.

    Piece The Legend has invested all his dreams in a so called third party.

    That this party and their predecessors are incapable of managing a healthy transport speaks volumes about our under development as a nation.

    What is a reasonable minimum test for a government. If it is incapable of running a reasonable transport infrastructure does it deserve to remain in power?

    This government has failed all the minimum requirements for a reasonable government.

    Any ideas as to how this country can move forward with the same old actors. I despair.


  6. @ TLSN

    You are describing incompetence, not corruption, unless it is corruption of the brain. It was not always thus. When the Transport Board was first created (and I am going to the cremation of the very first female bus conductor in Barbados this week, Nita from My Lord’s Hill, who worked on Route 20), I had bragging rights in the UK. When Britain introduced voting at age 18, I laughed, we already had it in Barbados. I can go on with genuine progressive policies.
    I have tried comparing the Mottley government with the 1961 Barrow government and was told I was personalising the politics. How silly. Sir Grantley, and Barrow, by being in the right place at the right time, did amazing things for Barbados.
    The other person who it is not fashionable to mention was the late Ernest Deighton Mottley, the current president’s grandfather. She is no match for him.
    Imagine the president spelling out her vision for Barbados by 2030 and all she can think of are school children being bilingual and able to swim. She is a preacher, a hand waver, a hand shaker, but she is not a policy wonk. Se is not comfortable with details and policy is about details.
    Which is fine, but she can do a Boris Johnson and surround herself with bright and able people, not just childhood friends.


  7. All of this debate about Atherley being an “ illegitimate “ leader of the opposition and here the man chairing a PAC meeting. Sometimes we laugh so as not to cry.
    Is this PAC illegitimate then?
    Just asking……….


  8. @William

    Does it matter? The outcomes from the PAC is always the same.


  9. We complain about Barbadian workers arriving late for work as if it is a right. Have we ever stopped to ask ourselves why? If from the time a child is required to travel to school by bus all he/she knows is arriving late, waltzing into school and saying “De bus did late” and that excuse is not challenged, what do we expect when the child becomes an adult and has to report for work at a specific time?

    Will this country ever be able to extricate itself from the morass of problems in which it finds itself? I doubt it. Attitudes are too ingrained.

    We complain about the slow pace of conducting business with government departments, we accuse government workers of being unprofessional BUT what about our banks and the inordinate amounts of time wasted when conducting the smallest of transactions? Have any of you attended a doctor or attorney recently, by appointment, and not have to wait for such a long time that you wondered if only the time of the “professional” was valuable?

    What about attending an official function where the minister or other high profile dignitary arrives very late as if it their right to have mere minions milling around to await their esteemed arrival?

    Have you ever invited the press (including TV coverage) to cover an event and they show up when it suits them?

    Too many generations of Barbadians have been trained to disregard the professional discipline of punctuality, so the transport board is not the disease but merely a symptom of the greater cancer that is consuming our nation.

    After 53 years of independence (?), we find ourselves:
    Heavily in debt
    Dysfunctional hospital
    Transportation in disarray
    Water distribution undependable
    Roadway system under severe stress
    Waste disposal and collection unreliable
    Future power needs unsecured
    Crime on the increase

    53 years of independence indeed.

  10. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    It is Rev Atherley ‘s responsibility to make sure it is not the same. I hope he has benefited from the past mistakes of previous PACs. He is an able and intelligent man.


  11. @ Hal
    You are correct! It’s massive incompetence by the Duopoly. Once real digging starts both parties would be found to be equally incompetent.
    Imagine going before a committee, declaring that buses missing and don’t even have bus numbers. What about engine numbers. Each vehicle should have an identification (VIN)number. Basic common sense. Then the committee asks about a missing bus only to be told that it was sold to a former employee.
    Corruption incompetence or both ?


  12. Historians will one day carry out extensive research on how Barbados became a failed state.

    Future generations will need to know how it was possible for a country that had a minuscule population, that shared the same religion and racial background, having had no history of crop failures, no experience of war and natural disasters could have failed so absolutely.

    Wil they argue that it was due to incompetence or corruption ; or a mixture of both.


  13. @Vincent

    The PAC structure allows Atherley to be that difference?

  14. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    How about Irresponsibility and negligence? Are we not sitting down watching each other and hoping the other would volunteer to do the job,especially if it involves stress? On the other hand, if there is largesse every one jumps up to share.

    In the exercise under review do you notice when the witnesses hesitate and take a fifth amendment silence or gives evasive answers ? What Independence? Where is it? Where is the courage? Where are these craftsmen of our fates?

    Are we waiting for the politicians to create it for us? We are just not ready. Failed State? Has it occurred to many that we are a state? How can one fail something that one does not acknowledge one has or is?

    We really mekking sport.


  15. @Vincent

    Good comment, there is the saying we get the government we deserve.

    How many so-called innocent citizens are privy to the graft that occurs at the SOEsfor example and say nothing? What about the criminal activity in our districts?

  16. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ David BU at 9:41 AM

    Are you saying that the PAC structure did not afford previous PAC chairmen the opportunity to make a difference? If anything Atherley is at a disadvantage compared to previous Chairmen of PAC.


  17. @Vincent

    You are aware the PAC has been stymied over the years by red tape, legalese and political chinnanagins. We like it so.


  18. @ Hal
    I see that the Duopoly has achieved the 2020 Vision:
    No water
    Poor public transportation
    Poor roads
    Record crime
    Lots of garbage
    Electricity black outs

    Can’t wait to see the 2030 vision achieved.

    The Duopoly Rules

  19. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ David BU

    Nothing has changed. There is even more red tape,legalese , political and other shenanigans.


  20. @Vincent

    And there you have it!


  21. @ William

    How can one steal a bus? Can people steal houses? We have people in Barbados (lawyer, priests, undertakers and others) who steal estates with impunity. We have civil servants who change the names on official records for their friends and not a word is said.
    When grieving relatives give undertakers money to buy graves for the dead, whose names do you think they buy the graves in? We have already talked about nurses stealing from patients, but such stealing is part of our culture. The dockers used to steal the imported produce; the servants used to steal from their employers, etc.
    We have lost our moral moorings.

  22. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ Hal Austin at 10 :03 AM

    Why did you start at the lowly dockers and servants? Do you not have any anecdotal evidence higher up the social scale? High Wind really knows where Old House lives.

  23. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ Hal
    Ignore previous submission. Speed reading is a >>>>..!

  24. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ Hants at 10 :42 AM

    Thanks for the information. I notice the cure /procedure is somewhere in the future. Still a work in progress.

  25. fortyacresandamule Avatar
    fortyacresandamule

    @HAL. Trust me, in a corrupt and dishonest society nothing is impossible to steal, especially movable property. A few years ago the impossible was made possible by a state in the region:They stole a whole beach in broad daylight.

  26. NorthernObserver Avatar

    “Are we not sitting down watching each other and hoping the other would volunteer to do the job,”
    Why? The answer lies somewhere in the social backlash, and targeting, which occurs whenever one speaks out or joins a battle. The fear of offending, or being labeled.


  27. @NO

    The fear of doing our civic duty. It is the only way the system can work for us.


  28. @ Fortyacres

    Is Barbados a failed state?


  29. @David (BU), has it be noted that Tobias Clement resigned from the New National Party which won all 15 in the last general election in Grenada and he is now the leader of the opposition in that country?


  30. My question to those involved at the PAC is the same I always ask when we hear these things and it’s “so what we doing bout it?”

    Next just 3 questions that if answered would quantify the lunacy at the TB.

    What were the total expenses and income when we had 200 buses on the road?

    What are the total expenses and income now that we are struggling to have 50 on the road?

    Has the expense to income ratio been maintained, or do we now have a situation where the expenses have been maintained but our income has plummeted?

    Get the answer to those 3 questions and conversation done there. But wait hold on, the TB are years behind on their audited financials aren’t they? Alright don’t worry let we just pelt another $60 million in their cheque book this year.

    A case of utter lunacy is corporate management funded at the taxpayers expense!


  31. @Bajan in NY

    It will happen in Barbados eventually. It explains the large cabinet for now.

  32. NorthernObserver Avatar

    “…..the only way the system can work for US”?
    I will suggest many ‘others’ have discovered a way the system can work for THEM. And not only in Barbados. The concept of “us”, or the greater common good, is reserved for charities or other volunteer organizations. Almost anything else within the public realm, has been politicized. You cannot be appointed unless you play within certain boundaries, in fact, much of the time those in decision making capacities, do not even consider, or know of, those beyond such boundaries.


  33. Touché NOrthern.

  34. fortyacresandamule Avatar
    fortyacresandamule

    @Hal. ” Is Barbados a failed state”? It depends from what angle, degree, and reference point you are judging the situation. Is the failure economic, political, institutional, social etc or a combination? And to what severity? My personal reference point of a failed state in the region is Haiti. Therefore, I wouldn’t say we are a failed state at this point.

    I would characterise our situation more like an incestuous, corrupt, and incompetent banana republic. Which left unchecked, could potentially erupted into a full blown failed state.

  35. SirSimpleSimonPresidentForLife Avatar
    SirSimpleSimonPresidentForLife

    @Hal AustinNovember 26, 2019 10:03 AM “We have already talked about nurses stealing from patients, but such stealing is part of our culture. The dockers used to steal the imported produce; the servants used to steal from their employers, etc. We have lost our moral moorings.”

    How can we have lost “our moral moorings” Did “moral moorings” ever exist in Barbados?

    The English came and stole the land from the indigenous people, then they stole the labour, and the reproductive capacity from the enslaved Africans. And this stealing went on for hundreds of years, royalty was involved, Parliament was involved, so were the judges, so were the priests, everybody who was anybody was in on the stealing.

    All I can say is that we learned very well from our higher-ups and better offs.

    And to say “lost moral moorings” what.


  36. @ Fortyacres

    Are our democratic institutions working as they are meant to? From the courts to the Transport Board, from schools to utilities, from administrative class to politicians? Are you happy with they way they function, with the way decisions are made, with how people/institutions are held accountable?


  37. Scandal Sheet Item 4: Ross University Villas
    (C) The most recent scandal to hit Skerrit was over a number of luxury villas designed to house the faculty of American-owned Ross Medical School. This line of questioning was introduced in the Parliament by Edison James, ex-PM for the opposition United Workers Party (and by all accounts an expert in feeding from the public till during his tenure as PM). Renneth Alexis, a friend of Skerrit’s, quickly professed to be the sole owner of the properties. According to James, the construction cost of the eight villas was listed in bank statements at $1.25 million USD, but some private estimates state the actual costs of construction could be as high as $2.5 million. Almost 75 percent of these official costs were paid by loans provided to Alexis, allegedly by friends of Skerrit. There is no documentation of who provided the remaining 25 percent investment in the properties. James claims that Skerrit has financed the bulk of the investment, simply using Alexis as a front to avoid the type of criticism he has received over his publicly disclosed assets.

    Dominica has its woes too!!

    https://www.weeklyblitz.net/news/dominica-pm-rosevelts-corruption-exposed-by-us-authorities/

    Skerrit eyed the 30-0 in Barbados at the time and opined a clean sweep could happen in Dominica too because Dominica did not need an opposition!!

  38. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ Simple Simon at 12 :44AM

    Surely you are not suggesting that at no point in our history were our leaders tied to high morals and appropriate standards of value? I lived in a period when Barbadians were admired for our trustworthiness,decorum and respectful behaviour. Surely you heard very often that men’s words were their bonds.? Your mind seems to be getting selective. That means we are or have reached the stage where we do not know right from wrong.
    . On a matter of History, It is reported than when the Portuguese landed in the 16th century theire were no Amerindians on the Island.


  39. @ Vincent

    Ignore the waffle.


  40. What Simple Simon is saying should not be dismissed. Much was going on with our leaders that the general population knew not of or spoke not of. Maybe we were living in a fools’s paradise. People are just more brazen than they were before. And the general population no longer “knows” its place and believes it should share in the spoils.

    That decorum and respectful behaviour by the “elite” was a veneer. To find out who they really were you would have to ask their maids. Of course the maids knew to keep their mouths shut. Mostly. It was a way to keep the general population in line. If one spoke too loudly or passionately or stood up for one’s self one was labelled as lower class, ungentlemanly or unladylike.subhumans.

    That still obtains for women.


  41. ‘On a matter of History, It is reported than when the Portuguese landed in the 16th century theire were no Amerindians on the Island.”

    you know they lied, they are brutal, savage beasts, lying is not a stretch for them, they have lied for centuries, still are.

  42. fortyacresandamule Avatar
    fortyacresandamule

    @Hal. Hell NO ! Nothing seems to function smoothly. Even basic service delivery turns in an exercise of atomic splitting. And surprisingly, this dysfunction also shows up in the private sector.

  43. fortyacresandamule Avatar
    fortyacresandamule

    @John. That same Ross unviversity that was poached by the PM, which subsequently relocated to Barbados?


  44. @ Fortyacres

    So, is it a failed state? Or just grossly incompetent?


  45. @Fortyacres

    Here is a story, but do not laugh. Prof Persaud is the prime minister’s chief economic adviser, so presumably he is an advocate of austerity. But, it appears, he is a signatory of a letter by over 160 UK economists who are calling for massive state spending by a future Labour government. Which side is he on? We ought to know.


  46. How people could actually take Hal Austin seriously? Look at the above statement. I just caaant!


  47. Is the UK in an IMF program?

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading