
The Attorney-General of Barbados is the primary legal advisor to the Government of Barbados – Wikipedia
Good luck to Barry Gale QC who defeated ‘pooch skinning’ Alair Shepherd for the position of President of the Barbados Bar Association (BA). Not sure if outgoing president Andrew Pilgrim was able to achieve anything of note except to attain the status of Queens Counsel which lawyers are willing to ‘die’ for it seems.
There was a time when individuals worked hard because there was a consciousness that it was the right thing to do. How ones legacy might be defined was an inevitable consequence. Truth be told in defence of today’s incumbents which see a level of mediocrity hitherto unknown, it may simply be a matter of (in)competence.
Former Attorney General David Simmons is highly regarded by the legal fraternity and the general public. BU however has always been halting in our praise for two reasons. When Simmons demitted the office of Chief Justice (under duress) the delivery of justice caused by the weight of a heavy case load and an inefficient Court Registry should have been the performance indicators which painted his legacy and NOT the quality of his decisions. It was insightful to read Barry Gale’s comments soon after assuming the office of President of the BA concerning the court system. In summary, a mess!
Let us not forget the unholy haste which saw him (Simmons) transitioning from a member of the Executive to the Judiciary. This also gives those with apolitical perspectives a voice.
Soon to follow was Mia Mottley (MAM) who like Simmons is generally highly regarded. However, if one is to critically examine her tenure as Attorney General. The court system did not improve in any appreciable way under her stewardship. When BU reflects on MAM’s tenure as Attorney General the burning down of Glendairy Prison vividly comes to mind. Mind you, MAM was congratulated on the way she managed the events which ensued BUT BU has always preferred to recall the warning from Reverend Gordon Mathews whose repeated cries went unheeded in the months and weeks leading up to the fire that it was a disaster waiting to happen. Demonstrated leadership would not have seen this blot in our history. MAM’s legacy will have to accommodate the Glendairy fiasco.
What is it about Attorney Generals of the recent past which have captured our attention! Although the incumbent is still trying to find his way after five years his legacy may turn out to be the poorakest of them all AND to think it is a work in progress!
From arms distance it seems most if not all of the departments which Attorney General Adriel Brathwaite leads are experiencing some form of dysfunction or unrest. Let us go quickly pass the issue of keys lost at the prison. Some Officers of the Barbados Fire Service have decided to join those of the Barbados Police Force in suing the Attorney General over promotions. What about the issue which has been heavily covered by BU regarding some lawyers who have refused to pay BA fees? The issue of the backlog of cases in the courts has not improved despite the appointment of the much heralded CJ Marston Gibson. Integrity Legislation saw its final reading in parliament but its proclamation and operationalization remain a mystery as to when. Although the Preservation of Antiquities Bill was marshalled in parliament by Minister Stephen Lashley the drafting and legal guidance resided under the ambit of Brathwaite.
Note we have not found the blog space to mention Maurice King of ‘there are no gangs’ fame or Dale Marshall who allowed the moral of the Police Force to dip to an unholy low. Brathwaite is the incumbent. Why was he reappointed again? How are we to determine measures of performance for the AG position?






The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.