Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

โ† Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Submitted by John Dillinger

Tony Marshall, Chairman of the NIS Board

I have followed your blogs [BU] with regards to the Four Seasons and Professor Persaud’s decision to ask the NIS to invest in the project as opposed to bring in international investors like the late PM David Thompson mandated him so to do. Was not the Professor to use his international connections to bring in the investment needed to restart the project? If so should we take it that he has failed to get the interest of the international investment community..the hedge funds, venture capitalists etc. to invest in Four Seasons? If so, then why?

Moreover based on two recent articles in the Nation Newspaper, one on November 24th quoting Minister Chris Sinckler as saying he expects the NIS to make a decision by the end of this week (coming after the now famous extraordinary Cabinet meeting of November 15th to “discuss” the Four Seasons project) and that the Minister of Labour and Social Security was “working closely” with the NIS on the matter. Does all of this smell like a hint of political interference in the NIS decision process with regards to the project at all, especially when it was reported that the NIS had been advised not to invest in the project?

The second major article, coming on the heels of the downward revision of Barbados’s outlook from STABLE to NEGATIVE this week, was an article saying that Standard & Poors was closely monitoring the progress with regards to the projectย  – how strategically timed and well placed for this article. Can we conclude that this is all meant to influence (read: pressure) the NIS into a particular decision. I hope that the Tony Marshall led NIS Board with the learned Dr Justin Robinson as Deputy Chairman would do the ethical and honorable thingย  and resign if they vote with political sword of Damocles hanging over their heads…remember that it is ALL OF BARBADIAN WORKERS future pension that they are dealing with, it isn’t monopoly money – the remainder of us don’t have the benefit of a big UWI pension or large Barclays pension when we retire…we depend on the NIS,

Please don’t throw our money into an empty whole while your own is secure….or else you may be inviting Occupy Four Seasons, Barbados’s version of Occupy Wall Street or worse yet, the beginning of Bajan Spring (our own local version of the Arab Spring) Do you really want that on your conscience gentlemen?


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


  1. @ Uneducated
    My point remains, your government should have given some of the construction activity to other firms instead of all to JADA. Am I telling lies?

  2. Fractured BLP Party Avatar
    Fractured BLP Party

    enuff | November 26, 2011 at 12:22 PM |
    Four years and the apologists still talking about a BLP mess. SMFH
    —————————————————————————–
    Ain’t the victims of the Chernobyl disaster still suffering from its effects some 20 YEARS after ?

    Owen Arthur and the BEES were just a disastrous intervention in the lives of Barbadians between 1994 – 2008.

    Just imagine what this economy in November 2011:

    1. would be able to do with the 70 million dollars spent on GREENLAND ?
    2. would be able to do with the 15 million dollars spent in legal fees to secure a NON EXISTENT fishing agreement with Trinidad ?
    3. would be able to do with 80 million dollars owed to Al Barack……when the original bill presented to the BLP government in 2006 was 30 million dollars……and they refused to pay the man ?

    I repeat…..Prof. Neville Duncan rightly asked a few months ago……WHAT IS IT OWEN ARTHUR PROPOSE TO BRING NEW TO BARBADIANS ?


  3. @ colonel buggy

    aw man, it is bad, but lets face it, she went to the mail. Read $$$$$$$. If NOW was not shut down, it would have been their headlines.

  4. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar
    Carson C. Cadogan

    millertheanunnaki (May2012)

    “IMF Airways ETA June 2012!”

    I notice that you have adjusted your doom and gloom date to June 2012.

    You guys are more fun than a barrel of Monkeys.

    The Democratic Labour Party is doing and will continue to do what is in the best interest of Barbados and we will all continue to benefit, Owen’seethru”Arthur included.

    You corrupt Barbados Labour Party jokers just love to oppose everything.

    You opposed free secondary education, you opposed Independence, you opposed membership of the United Nations, you opposed membership of the OAS, you opposed Radio Barbados, you opposed CBC Tv, you opposed free School meals, you opposed Holidays with pay, you opposed the Constitutinonal Amendments, you oppose, you oppose, you oppose until you are even opposing THE HON MIA AMOR MOTTLEY now. When you loose the next general you will oppose Seethru as well.

    The name of your party ought to be THE OPPOSE LABOUR PARTY.

  5. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar
    Carson C. Cadogan

    millertheanunnaki (May2012 or is it June2012)

    Is Owen”seethru”Arthur living any worse now than he did five years?

  6. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar
    Carson C. Cadogan

    millertheanunnaki (May2012 or is it June2012)

    Do you know where seethru got the Millions to pay Beverly at the end of the Divorce settlement?

  7. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar
    Carson C. Cadogan

    Whatever happen to Seethru’s Marina inquiry?

    Was it still born?


  8. If the Nation report is true what we have is a NIS Board which is a joke and do not merit being labeled independent, Yes and then NO, what is that?

    http://www.nationnews.com/articles/view/nis-shift/


  9. It called being political strong armed david. they left the meeting tuseday and were told don’t come back unless the answer is yes. Wonder if Tony would do the right thing and resign or call out the ministers on this nonsense.


  10. It is clear that the NIS board has NO BALLS only empty sacks!


  11. Solution: re-name the N.I.S., as the National Intravenous Service; ensure it’s mandate is also modified to reflect no responsibility for the well-being of grand-children, or great-great grandchildren; who will duly collect their full pensions, at the retirement age of age 93. Alternatively, just register it as a bank; as it’s already accepting deposits (“contributions”) Yes, there is method to this madness, (which is also prevalent in Europe, and USA): since money will soon have little value, it’s better to just share it out now, and buy anything that is tangible. Like jobs; rotis, gasoline; BMW’s, cruise-trips; $1,800 cell-phones, etc.


  12. I am gonna defend Tony on this one from the get go this was all a done deal by the government all the public was witnessing was the formalities assigned to Tony Marshall and the board as a pretense of FOI. This is nothing new only that in yesteryears the same things were happening but was not opened to the public . Tony did his part that was to opposed but also the government interest as a guarantor for the building of the FOUR Season took precedent as to avoid legal action which would have cost the government plenty and a case they would not have won.


  13. IF WE BAJANS SIT BACK AND TAKE THIS LYING DOWN WE ARE A SPINELESS BUNCH. WE DESERVE WHATEVER WE GET!

    NOW THIS IS AN OPPORTUNITY TIME FOR A THIRD PARTY TO EMERGE, THE MANIFESTO IS ALREADY ON THE WALL ON WHAT THEY MUST DO. BUT THIS PARTY MUST HAVE COJONES TO PUT IN PLACE INTEGRITY LEGISLATION AS THEIR FIRST PRIORITY OF BUSINESS.

  14. Caswell Franklyn Avatar

    Carson C. Cadogan

    At 3:18 you wrote:
    you opposed Holidays with pay, you opposed the Constitutinonal Amendments, you oppose,

    There should be some sanction that could be imposed on persons who comment on this blog who attempt to deliberately mislead. The Holidays with Pay Act was passed in 1951 and came into force the following year on January 11th. As far as I am aware the DLP was formed in 1955, so please don’t go on to say they passed the Act.

  15. Caswell Franklyn Avatar

    islandgal246 | November 27, 2011 at 7:35 AM | It is clear that the NIS board has NO BALLS only empty sacks!

    I can’t agree with you there: they have ball just that no hair has grown on them yet. They are a bunch of little boys!


  16. David,

    What are you cringing about ? I told you since last week that the NIS loan will be approved by the NIS Board.

    Mia Mottley as Attorney for the project must have her way on this one. Remember Chris Sinckler is her bosom pal. No pun intended !

  17. Caswell Franklyn Avatar

    You are acting like this is the first time that the NIS Board was ordered to change their position on an investment. You should recall that the NIS Board said, “NO” to Public Workers Credit Union for a loan to purchase CLICO Mortgage & Finance Company, but were ordered to approve it in order to help bailout CLICO. Now The credit union has a millstone around its neck. Will history repeat itself?


  18. islandgal246 | November 27, 2011 at 8:04 AM | IF WE BAJANS SIT BACK AND TAKE THIS LYING DOWN WE ARE A SPINELESS BUNCH. WE DESERVE WHATEVER WE GET!

    Ever were and ever will be.


  19. WE are looking at the end story. However much of the blame lies with those who were the initiators of the project and the government who relied on what i would term information which was self serving to the investor and shareholders.The so called financial gurus like Persaud should be lynched for getting the govt over its head in this debacle. and the people have a right to be at war with the govt over their hard earned money.


  20. @ Fractured BLP
    $85m extra dollars in 2011 could save us? The fiscal deficit, for the period 2010/2011, is estimated at $751.1 million!!
    After four years of an average of 0% growth, less FOREX, more borrowing and a larger fiscal deficit, I really can not imagine where we would be if the economy was really in a ‘mess’ in January 2008.
    I am still waiting to hear this government’s accomplishments since coming to power. Campaign PR and governing are two different kettle of fish.


  21. Demagoguery: Gaining power and popularity by arousing the emotions, passions, and prejudices of the people by a person, especially an orator or political leader.

    Cost of living
    Corruption
    $75,000 cheque
    Flooding
    CLICO
    Agriculture Protection Act
    Duty free cars for civil servants
    Four Seasons
    What global economic issues what!
    Fishing agreement over a bowl of soup
    Free bus fares
    FOI
    etc….

  22. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    @Carson C. Cadogan | November 27, 2011 at 3:24 AM |
    “millertheanunnaki (May2012 or is it June2012)”
    Cant’ you tell the difference between the date of calling general elections and the date of the IMF taking up permanent residence whichever party wins?
    Please CCC, be fair for once and stop labelling me a party yardfowl. I beg you, please leave me alone when it comes to party pigeon-holing or yardfowl cooping.! Or do you see everyone who opposes what the present administration does as pro BLP?

    “Do you know where seethru got the Millions to pay Beverly at the end of the Divorce settlement?”
    The answer is NO! Maybe your administration can do a forensic audit as in the case of Hardwood Housing. You will then find out where OSA got his millions. While you are at it (the forensic audit of course) you can investigate out the Families First Account and CLICO association. You might just find where Beverly (like Mrs. MT) came into her windfall millions.

    “Whatever happen to Seethruโ€™s Marina inquiry?
    Was it still born?”
    CCC! Surprise! Surprise! I am with you on this one!
    You see I am anti- robbing the Treasury whether by BLP crooks or DLP wannabe bigger crooks in a shorter period. Get my drift, sorry my position?
    Now bugger off, yardfowl!


  23. I believe that some one in the DLP is really trying the patience of the electorate of Barbados. This is the first time in the history of politics that I have seen a party so bent on its own demise. Even if the project is restarted, its success shall not be the finishing of the buildings, but the emergence of a thriving business. That shall take about 4 years. When shall Fruendel call elections to benefit from this success. As it stands, if he rallies until the last political minute, as sound defeat is awaiting. With this stupidity of an investment a sound defeat is awaiting. Shall we the DLP members in an all-for-myself cycle soon? I have been calling this indian financial guru a fraud for a long time, glad to see some body heard.

    To Uneducated:
    You seem to think that two piece of degrees give you some giant of an intellect. Sadly, you shall find it very difficult to match your skills with Miller; he is not easy .


  24. “I have been calling this indian financial guru a fraud for a long time, glad to see some body heard.’

    Le MULE ….Why not financial guru a fraud? ! If it were a black man I wonder how you would describe him? RACIST PIG


  25. lemuel | November 27, 2011 at 9:44 AM | You seem to think that two piece of degrees give you some giant of an intellect. Sadly, you shall find it very difficult to match your skills with Miller; he is not easy .

    Then why waste it, commenting under false names, on BU, while incompetent people offer themselves as representatives of the people? In the end those incompetent people may be doing the best they can โ€“ what are the competent ones doing?


  26. To Island:
    As far as i know the indian guru is of indian descent. If he were a black financial fraud I would call him a black financial fraud. If that is being racist, I am guilty as can be. When indians win spelling bee or mathematical competitions, I have never seen you accusing the white papers or labeling them racist, but I stand by my description of the indian man and you.

  27. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar

    In spite of all the nonsense being written here, we all know that the NIS board did the right thing.

    I tip my hat to them.

    Very responsible Barbadian Citizens.


  28. To Carson Cadogan:
    My paper is telling there seems to be a change of heart to finance the project. How did you know it was already agreed. Are you on the board?


  29. The decision by the Board if we accept that there has been an about turn calls for the immediate resignation of the Board.

    Of course the hand to mout unionists on the Board are thinking jobs and not viability of the project.

    The others are thinking perhaps the enhanced status which comes with being an NIS Board member.

    Sad!


  30. CANT you all see that this DLP government is heading down the same road as the SANDY led government ???

    IF mm Tony Marshall does not resign now !!! he is more mm than at first thought ???

    WHEN are you people going to admit that this DLP government is a big problem ???


  31. This is a DARK day in Barbados politics, imagine the people who this money belongs to have no say in how it is invested or better still given away.Why should a bunch of crooked politicians have the final say in my money when it if possible that they will be removed in a few months.For once I agree with Islandgal246, if bajans sit back and do nothing about this, then we are all spineless, we need to march to Government Headquarters and let the P.M know how we feel. If we allow this to pass, next time it will be worse. I’m not going to be around much longer but it iss my offspring that stand to suffer by the ruthless behaviour of this politicians.

  32. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    @JUST ASKING | November 27, 2011 at 1:12 PM |

    “IF mm Tony Marshall does not resign now !!! he is more mm than at first thought ???”

    This is like asking a dead man to dig his own grave!
    Every little bit counts! That’s how some people who have sold their souls to the money devil see a monthly tax free stipend! The advice of not storing up riches on Earth for the moths to devour after the worms have taken care of their cadavers does ring any warning bells to the fire marshal!


  33. To Miller:
    Is it true what Carson Cadogan said that the NIS shall fund the project?

  34. George C. Brathwaite Avatar
    George C. Brathwaite

    @David

    With absolutely no apology, you are 100 % accurate. The entire board must go if indeed there is a reversal in the decision and the NIS contributions are further put at risk of this dismal administration.
    If Marshall does not lead the resignation of the board, it merely confirms what I with no disrespect have thought of him since 2006.
    Marshall = very intelligent, sophisticated, articulate, speaks about principles and acts with self-serving flexibility. Think back to the lead up to the last election and his role and behaviour as VOB moderator. The more things change, the more they remain the same.

  35. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    @Carson C. Cadogan | November 27, 2011 at 10:26 AM |
    “In spite of all the nonsense being written here, we all know that the NIS board did the right thing. I tip my hat to them. Very responsible Barbadian Citizens.”

    So you are right at the heart of things to know exactly before hand which decisions are forced on political lackeys and public servants?
    Good for you. But the above words will go down in infamy. So much for Westminster style of governance!
    But if the project turns out to be a disaster only lining the pockets of a few contractors you can always put the blame on your favourite whipping boy “Seethru” whether dead or alive.


  36. The article speaks to the NIS analysts sending the board a set of options, it says nothing about the board.

  37. Caswell Franklyn Avatar

    It seems to ME that this whole fiasco, with the Investment Committee being summoned to a special meeting with the Cabinet, is at best unethical and at worst corrupt. Further, if Carson C. Cadogan is proven to be correct then there would be no doubt that process is absolutely corrupt unless Carson is a member of either the Cabinet or the Investment Committee .


  38. we need to appreciate how the business people are thinking on this one. The private investors are most likely waiting for the project to collapse, go into receivership, and they can then come in and acquire prime assets at 20/30 cents on the dollar.

    They have no interest in any rescue of the project and will oppose any such rescue. the question is, do the rest of us have an interest in the rescue of the project.

    Business people are ideologically opposed to the bailout of other business people, they are quite happy to have their own bailout.


  39. This blog is interesting. The complaint used to be that NIS was only investing in government paper. Now they are looking at a domestic private sector investment in our major, if not only industry, in partnership with the largest development bank in our hemisphere, there is also a hue and cry.

    I wonder what robinson has done to miller?


  40. Governments in North America build and repair roads and bridges as a means of generating jobs.

    Four Seasons is a job generating project that could directly employ 1000 people for the next two to three years.

    Let us hope “and pray” that there is an economic recovery in Europe and North America by the time the project is completed.


  41. OSA aint got the nuts to open up the can of worms down at the Pierhead marina. Pure politricking, nothing more.

    I suspect there are two people close to this government who OSA got on a very short list, parris and boyce.

  42. millertheanunnaki Avatar

    @ Business man | November 27, 2011 at 9:59 PM |
    “I wonder what robinson has done to miller?”
    Nothing! Don’t know the academic fellow!

    There is nothing wrong in serving the country in athe capacity of a political appointee. But when your academic training and values inculcated by academic discipline are in confrontation with political opportunism, expediency and sycophancy then there is a problem.
    There is nothing wrong in principle with NIS financing the 4 C Seasons project. I have already given my support but under certain basic requirements being met. People who have a stake in the viability of the scheme have every right to question the process. On what information is such an investment decision is made? Who will be the contractors and consultants involved? Is the investment committee and the Board have a different position to that of the political directorate? This needs to be made clear. No one can gainsay the minister’s and by extension the cabinetโ€™s authority to instruct the Board which investment decision to take. But let it be known that it is a policy decision made by the political directorate in their own right given by the electorate. Nothing absolutely wrong with that!
    But let it be known also that this political decision is not based solely on business acumen and reliable financial information and sound strategic thinking. Where are the financials to provide the basis of this decision-making process?
    This is our money and we require our basic right to information to be respected. Where is the transparency? And this position has nothing to any affiliation to B, D, P or N but only as the contributorsโ€™ right to question what is happening to their money over which there is no direct control but only an expectation that those who are put to manage these mandatory deductions from pay packets fulfill their fiduciary responsibility. Pray to God, we donโ€™t want to see another CLICO.

    Is this clear as crystal to you, business man? Strictly business here, no political hanky-panky!


  43. In case the NIS Board headed by Marshall changes their stance and agrees to the loan, they ALL should resign. Failing to do this, it will show that the members are all creatures of the government and as such,Starcom Network should fire Mr Marshall from the call-in programme, since as they said anyone who shows bias or declares their interest in either party CANNOT be a moderator, that, why Mr Farley was relieved. Also it shows that the ministers, who we employ, is going against the will of the voters (the emploers) and as such should be removed from office. I don’t see why the DLP could force the NIS’ hand on this one knowing it will come back to haunt them in a few months during the campaign to the next general elections. This will only add to the many woes the DLP has to face in that campaign, including the Clico matter and the failure to pass the Transparentcy and FOI Act. The next general elections will be intersting.


  44. I think Miller is on the right track, in that rather than just focusing on NIS saying yes or no, what is NIS saying yes or no to, and if they say yes under what conditions.

    My information from looking at the IADB website is that the IADB is lending strictly for hotel construction. The IADB statement indicates that they beleive that completion of the hotel will serve to trigger stalled villa sales. To my understanding the residential or villa component of the project is being left purely to private investors. The IADBs should be able to insist on draw downs and other conditonalities to try to ensure funds go to hotel construction.

    I think the hotel will have a very beneficial developmental impact on BIM and I can support the NIS helping the IADB provide a lifeline to the hotel under adequate safeguards. I would not support NIS funds being invested in the villa aspect of the project.

  45. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    Alien | November 27, 2011 at 10:06 AM |
    “Then why waste it, commenting under false names, on BU, while incompetent people offer themselves as representatives of the people? In the end those incompetent people may be doing the best they can โ€“ what are the competent ones doing?”

    Well Alien, we take your point. It’s a pity that crap always seem to float to the top. But prove this saying to be not always true. You see we have great respect for your worthwhile and workable contributions in how to tackle the problems of this small island. Your intellectual genius shines through like a beacon of hope. Now if you should remove the alien cloak and let the BU intellectual masqueraders know what you stand for we would promote your eminent qualities fit for electoral success to be the people’s representative. Unlike us grumpy old people who are just critics in the crowd (or like the two old fellows in the balcony in the Muppet show if you are old enough to remember) time has passed us by and we would like to see the younger fellows like yourself take the baton and be the honourable representatives of the younger brigade. Besides, we are set in our ways and modern communication technology (iphones, social networking ,etc) although design and created by our old geyser generation might prove too much of a challenge for the old crew even though we might have to work to 70 before we can dip our hands in the NIS cookie jar.

    So we salute you, Alien, go for it and we will be backing you all the way!


  46. Miller/Alien
    Irrespective of whether we lend or not is not what bothers me, the fact that the clouded way it was done and the pressure placed on an INDEPENDENT Com. to make a decision to satisfy them is where I draw the line. The Finance minister has the right to overturn the NIS decision but if it failed he would have to carry the blame,what will now happen is if it fails it clears the minister of accepting the blame. I remember, some years ago a minister instructing an officer in his dept to do something that he knew was wrong but would make the minister look good, when it backfired, the minister said the officer had the right to refuse. The same thing can happen with this loan.

  47. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    @ The Scout | November 28, 2011 at 1:50 PM |
    I agree.
    That is why the decision has to be transparent. Is it based on recommendations made by the investment committee and sanctioned by the Board without political interference and based on financial and business factors or it is a decision handed down by the political directorate for robotic implementation by the Board and executive management?

    If it a political directive then the honourable thing for the likes of TM and JR to do is to disassociate themselves with this perceived hand wringing?
    Let the pols come to us and assure us that this decision is in the interests of the country. Outline the benefits and the costs. Assure us that there will be no kickbacks and award of contracts based on non-meritorious criteria. Provide a door of transparency so that the people can see what’s going on with the people’s money.
    If this is done and the project does not bring the financial returns the people would have to accept the risks of the undertaking. But if corruption and chicanery surround the project then the pols will have to answer for their injudicious decision and “squandermania”.


  48. Miller
    I agree, so why put the Board under such pressure? It seems the minister and his government has already made the committment and from the fact that the Board has been brought to “court” to revise their decision means there is political interference. It also shows the government and the Finance minister is afraid of accepting the responsibility.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading