Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Dr Brian Francis: Photo Credit Nation

BU has led the call for academics on the ‘Hill’ to speak out on the many issues which are at play in our society. The challenge it seems is that many of them can be tarred by a political brush if we are to judge by their public offerings. What purpose is learning if it cannot be shared dispassionately to enrich the human space we occupy?

Recently Dr. Brian Francis, a lecturer at Cave Hill, UWI, generated a furious debate triggered by a post-Budget discussion, when he ‘knocked’ the recent budget delivered by Minister of Finance Sinckler. Again BU was forced to ask – was Francis providing analysis as an economist or a partisan leaning academic?

The attached document titled The University of the West Indies, Cave Hill Campus, Departmental Reports 2009 – 2010 on  page 148 lists Dr. Brian Francis as a Member,  Economic Advisory Team to the Leader of the Opposition, Barbados. Readers are free to draw their own conclusions when perusing or listening to Dr. Francis’ analyses. All the public require is transparency.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


  1. If Dr. Franciis wants to cry to the press let him come clean on what is on his resume.

     http://www.nationnews.com/articles/view/uwi-lecturer-under-fire/ 
    Sat, September 10, 2011 – 12:05 AM
    A UNIVERSITY OF THE WEST INDIES (UWI) lecturer says he has become the victim of several personal attacks since he gave a “thumbs down” to this year’s Budget presented by Government.
    Dr Brian Francis, a lecturer in economics at the University of the West Indies (UWI) Cave Hill Campus, in a post-Budget discussion last month criticized Minister of Finance Chris Sinckler’s  financial proposals, calling the presentation “a huge mistake that is going to hurt the economy very badly in the long run”.
    Francis says from then he has “become the target of senseless attacks and abuse by politicians and assumed supporters of the ruling Democratic Labour Party who did not share my perspectives”.
    He also said some of the attacks levelled at him were heavily influenced by the fact that he was not born in Barbados.
    Full story in today’s SATURDAY SUN.


  2. page 148 lists Dr. Brian Francis as a Member, Economic Advisory Team to the Leader of the Opposition, Barbados.

    An de man doan expect licks from de party he opposing?


  3. i have to comment because some of the views on this forum never cease to amaze me.dr justin robinson is a known supporter of the democratic labour party. his views are always slanted in favour of the party he supports’ yet he is not demonised on this forum, he is respected even though his views are obviously pro-dlp.


  4. And there in lies the problem in this country, everything done or said has the under current of some form of partisan politics.
    I hope one day the media in this country will have the intestinal fortitude to let the public know the political leaning of these so called commentators / experts / know all.


  5. Who is Dr Francis Charles?


  6. @spratt

    Who is Francis Charles?

    Let us discussed the leanings and affinities of our professionals.

    Let the transparency begin.

    It is not enough to say it happens over there so it is fine.


  7. The man came out with full blown criticism of the budget and then admitted he hadn’t read the document. Then it turns out his position isn’t so independent after all, he is an Economic Advisor to the Leader of the Opposition.

    He can’t be in Church and Synagogue too.

  8. My address is West Terrace Avatar
    My address is West Terrace

    Brian Francis is patently a jackass he criticizes but dont expect to be criticized. Jesus Our Lord was criticised in fact crucified and you are not Jesus you come across as a joke.

    You advising Arthur but you want Sinckler and the Dees to give you a free pass.

    You attack Sinclker without even reading the man’s budget then you have the temerity to say no one challenged what you said.

    Now thats an untruth we have said you are talking garbage for starters get your facts right Barbados does not have an embassy in Thailand. Arthur in dire straits if he taking advice from you. Mia will take care of you and the short drunkard. Dont fret up yourself you are not that important.


  9. @ bajejun

    “partisan politics” or a Dictatorship. nuff said,


  10. My question was a genuine one, David. The headline refers to a Dr Francis Charles, the text to a Dr Brian Francis. Are they one and the same?


  11. What I find disturbing about Dr.Francis is that he like most other Caribbean persons wants to make Barbadians feel so guilty about defending Barbados.
    His mouthing’s sound just like Owen Arthur, that we must the the only country that must bow down to make the CSME work.
    As a UWI economist what are your thoughts on the Jamaican economy? Why only criticize the Barbados government budgetary proposals.
    Barbadians are demonized in the Caribbean every time we have to defend Barbados.
    What kind of economist is he who cannot see that the US and UK economies our major tourist markets are stagnating. His solution to our problem is that he wants the government to do things that would be political suicide at this time? He wants the government TO CUT EXPPENDITURE drastically WHICH TECHNICALLY MEAN TO LAY OFF MANY GOVERNMENT WORKERS that Owen appointed before he left office.
    The world economic forum just voted Barbados the highest in the Caribbean in terms of places to invest. How come we are so bad Dr.Francis? Do you have any comments on St. Lucia economy? Why can’t you go back to St. Lucia and advise Stephenson King.
    Why are Owen Arthur and his economic gang preaching such gloom and doom for a country that should be worst off because of what is happening in the world.


  12. In January we had a non Barbadian contesting a seat in our Parliament. We heard how “un-Caribbean” we were, how rude and selfish we were to dare oppose the lady.

    Fast forward a few months and a non Barbadian dares to offer an opinion on a budget and you get the same people who lambasted those who had a problem with a non Barbadian entering our Parliament, lambasting a non Barbadian for daring to disagree with the budget. So what if he advises the Opposition leader? Every body has to support the nonsense this DLP is doing?

    Last year the same Chamber invited Justin Robinson a non Barbadian who praise the budget to the hill, no problems with that though, he supports the DLP.

    How small minded we have become!


  13. As a lowly (partisan DLP supporting) contributor to BU who happens to live in Canada please allow me to regurgitate recent news from The Star.

    “Investors mulled over a weaker-than-expected jobs report in Canada, a may-not-be-strong-enough jobs creation package from U.S. president Barack Obama, and stern warnings over the lingering debt crisis in Europe.”

    “Canada’s economy shed jobs for the first time in five months in August, pushing the unemployment rate up a notch to 7.3 per cent, according to a report from Statistics Canada.

    Economists warn the rate could edge higher by year’s end, as consumers slow their spending and a lack of business confidence weighs on hiring.”


  14. @Prodigal Son,

    When you get in the political arena you will share licks and get licks.

    You an Owen are welcome to continue spittin your venom on the DLP.
    That is your right as the OPPOSITION.

    BU is an equal opportunity snake pit where Democracy thrives.


  15. DO you call harrassment and threats from YARDFOWLS most of whom are of the female species -criticism in an academic kind of way ????


  16. Hants,

    I have been staying off this blog for a while because of the fear of attacks from the likes of you. I got tired of the personal attacks. Dont you see what this kinda of thing is doing to US politics?

    You live in Canada and must have your say on everything that goes on here but I who live here must not voice my opinion? I wont be going in any snake pit with the likes of any Dem, rest assured.

    Be fair, man.


  17. Lord, how I get in this one now. I have not unpicked my teeth about the budget.


  18. David the blog master said on September 10, 2011 at 6:37 PM “If Dr. Franciis wants to cry to the press let him come clean on what is on his resume.”

    But David since Dr. Francis’ resume is in the public domain it can scarcely be said that he needs to come clean. He is clean. He has stated in a public document that he is a Member, Economic Advisory Team to the Leader of the Opposition, Barbados. Nothing wrong wid’ a fella advising the Leader of the Opposition, nothing wrong wid’ advising the Minister of Finance either. All sensible politicians know that they do not know all, and sensibly choose some intelligent, well educated advisers. Nothing at all wrong with that.

    Nothing wrong with Dr. Francis having to take some political and verbal licks either. It seems to me that the Doc is a big, big fella who must be prepared to take his [political and verbal] licks like a real real man once he engage heself in we politics.


  19. But Justin it ‘in na point saying “looka me crosses”

    You did unpick ya teet last year about the budget. Didn’t you?


  20. @Random Thoughts

    The document is now a public document, it was not until BU posted it.

  21. George C. Brathwaite Avatar
    George C. Brathwaite

    @Justin Robinson

    Maybe you should do so, your words appear to be taken without much fanfare. But tell me something my learned friend, if the 2010 budget was okay and you said so, does your silence on the 2011 budget indicate a different measurement? Just asking because as you know, I am caught between a rock and a hard place.


  22. Had no real problems with the budget. I liked some of the initiatives, and would have liked to see more in terms of divestment of aspects of government.


  23. It is always invigorating when members of the academic community provide their objective perspective on national issues. I believe the motive behind the Barbados Chamber of Commerce inviting Dr. Francis to speak was for him to put forward his objective view of the Budget. However, it’s humanly impossible for him to remain impartial when he is secretly advising the Leader of the Opposition on economic matters. In light of his actions, he is fair game in politics. If he don’t like the heat stay out the kitchen.


  24. The BLP will not win the government by saying the government did a bad job in managing the economy. In fact they are doing a good enough job in keeping the economy from doing what Owen Arthur, Clyde Mascoll and Dr.Francis (as Owen advisor) were predicting that the economy would have crashed in 2009, 2010 and 2011.
    By the way how comes Owen crying to have Mascoll in parliament. Mascoll contested against Chris and loss in St. Michael North West. If Owen is saying that the feeling on the ground is to return the BLP to government why did he not send Mascoll back to where he is the home town boy? Maybe he is not hearing well and wants Mascoll in a safe seat for other reasons beside economics. I even have a feeling that a safe seat for Mascoll may not be a safe seat after all. Let’s wait and see.


  25. Well said Ayub.


  26. @David

    Thanks for posting the UWI document, as an aside I noticed that two of the Deans attended the school that overlooks the Bay in Oistins. I also saw another Professor listed who attended the same school, there may have been more but time did not permit a complete review. Our master plan is on track, first the PM and now the CJ we had a minor set back when a top Civil Servant retired …. We are biding our time but we are slowly taking over……


  27. @Prodigal Son wrote “You live in Canada and must have your say on everything that goes on here”

    Until the properties I own in Barbados are sold and I renounce my Barbadian citizenship, everything about Barbados concerns me and I will voice my opinion on anything I choose.

    You are free to do the same.

    I will make a concerted effort to avoid commenting on anything you write.

  28. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar

    The crooked Barbados Labour Party is in severe disarray. Expect anything and everything from its members and supporters. Including economic Bush Doctor, Brian Francis.

    The latest cockup from within the BLP.

    From the Nationnewspaper:-

    MIA AMOR MOTTLEY speaking.

    Questions have been raised since an August 27 newspaper ad, promoting a BLP St Andrew branch meeting, described speaker Dr Jerome Walcott as “incoming chairman”.

    Mottley, who announced in May that she would throw her hat into the ring, told the SUNDAY SUN she was unsure how such a declaration could have been made when nominations for positions within the party remain open until later this week.

    “No one has asked me if I’ve withdrawn, and to the best of my knowledge I’m still in the race . . . . So I really am not sure where that came from,” she said
    Nation Newspaper.

    Forbes magazine, and with good reason, just named Jamaica the fifth worst economy IN THE WORLD, not just in the Caribbean but in the entire WORLD.

    Forbes’s top 10 worst economies in the world are: 1. Madagascar, 2. Armenia, 3. Guinea, 4.Ukraine, 5. Jamaica, 6. Venezuela, 7. Kyrgystan, 8. Swaziland, 9. Nicaragua, 10. Iran.

    The latest demonic occurance in Jamaica is the beheading of Jamaicans by other Jamaicans.

    The private sector in Jamaica is saying that the rampant crime in Jamaica is having a great negative impact on the Jamaican economy.

    Why is no one talking about these things but They only care to point fingers at Barbados?


  29. Carson C. Cadogan, please go back to sleep.

    Jamaicans ain’t cutting off one another heads because of demons. They doing it when their heads are full of marijuana, and they are fighting with other drug dealers over MONEY, plain and simple, nothing demonic about it.

    And contrary to what Minister Jones said Bajan boy children are NOT misbehaving because they are possessed by demons. Bajan boy children are misbehaving because their fathers have abandoned them, and their mother’s boyfriends hate them. And too often the heads of the boys, their fathers and their stepfathers (and their mothers too) are full of marijuana If I had to live without my father, and with a step father who mistreated me (and my mother) I’d behave like I was demon possessed too.

    But before we come up with SENSIBLE policies to deal with family dysfunction and drug about we sit on our assess and talk foolishness about demon possession.

    But as a Christian this morning I must be the devil’s advocate (lawyer) and ask you and Jones to stop blaming my client (the devil) for men’s selfishness and cruelty to the boys of this country (and no doubt Jamaican boys as well)

    I know what I speak of, my own brother is one of those selfish stepfathers who can’t stand his wife’s son. He is my brother and I do love him but he certainly could not live in my house and treat my children so. But too many women put up with damn foolishness from too many men as though there is anybody on the face of the earth with 3 balls.

    Stupseeeee!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


  30. Central Bank of Barbados
    BOARD OF DIRECTORS

    Dr. R. DeLisle Worrell. Ph. D, Chairman
    Grantley W. Smith, Esq., B.C.H., D.P.A., B.A. (Hons.)
    Mr. Cecil McCarthy LL. B, (UWI) L.E.C.
    Ms. Onika Stewart LL. B (UWI) LL. M (Lond) L.E.C.
    Justin Robinson B.Sc., M.Sc., Ph. D
    Mr. Ashley Toppin JP, FCCA
    Mr. Harold Hoyte, G.C.M
    Mr. Elson A. Gaskin, LLB. (UWI) L.E.C. Legal Counsel / Secretary to the Board

    People grow up!!!


  31. Sep 10, 2011 (Caribbean News Now – McClatchy-Tribune Information Services via COMTEX) — KINGSTOWN, St Vincent — If US diplomatic cables published by WikiLeaks are to be believed, the policewoman, who in 2008 accused St Vincent and the Grenadines Prime Minister Dr Ralph Gonsalves of rape, was offered US$185,000 in cash, a low-income house, and an opportunity to study abroad to drop the charge.

    St Vincent and the Grenadines Prime Minister Dr Ralph Gonsalves

    However, a source close to the alleged victim said, “She is vehement that she never got paid off.” “Further, I know of a regional attorney who works with the officer who says that she swears not to have received money,” said the source, who spoke on condition of anonymity.

    “I know that this officer is still harassed by police high command. Recently she won a scholarship to go to a university to study and was turned down. These actions do not indicate a person with whom the state has made peace,” the source said.

    However, four cables from the US Embassy in Bridgetown to Washington detail the alleged covert manoeuvres as lawyers sought justice for the cop, who claimed Gonsalves sexually assaulted her on January 3, 2008 while she was on duty at his official residence in Kingstown.

    According to the documents, attorneys Kay Bacchus-Browne and Nicole Sylvester asked US officials to intervene and Sylvester claimed to have smuggled the woman’s police uniform to Trinidad for DNA testing.

    However, according to the cables, Bacchus-Browne and Sylvester’s effort were brought to naught when “an insurance company executive with ties to the Gonsalves government” likely struck a deal that reportedly led to the woman settling the case out of court.

    The negotiator is said to have been “on the ULP’s short list to contest one of the constituencies held by the opposition” and chaired a statutory corporation. Further, an individual close to the cop, “no longer able to handle the stress and weakened by the entire ordeal, played a large role in convincing [her] to sell out,” the leaked documents allege.

    “The cash portion of the payoff was deposited into [a] bank account in Canada,” the cables said.

    The cables purport to document the developments that led to the policewoman on September 12 retaining as her new lawyer Jaundy Martin of the firm Marks, Martin and Associates, the same firm of which former ULP senator Ronald Marks is a member.

    The cop changed lawyers without consulting or informing Bacchus-Browne or Sylvester and while Sylvester was overseas. The new lawyer filed on September 15 the relevant court documents discontinuing all of the claims against Gonsalves.

    Prime Minister Dr Ralph Gonsalves said that he is innocent and the charge was politically motivated.

    On February 1, 2008, Gonsalves called a press conference declaring himself innocent of the sexual assault charge filed as a private criminal complaint against him on behalf of the female cop.

    The charges stemmed from an alleged sexual encounter between Gonsalves and the female member of his security detail at his official residence at Kingstown on January 3, 2008.


  32. The comrade has a sizable belly. Can he do anything though?


  33. @Enuff

    What is your point?

    Are you suggesting that Dr. Justin Robinson is advisor to the government because he sits on the CBB and NIBs?


  34. 1.Justin Robinson | September 10, 2011 at 10:24 PM | Had no real problems with the budget. I liked some of the initiatives, and would have liked to see more in terms of divestment of aspects of government.

    Dr. R, which entity(ies) would you recommend be divested at this time and would your recommendation be to sell to the public, along with simultaneous listing on the BSE, or to a private group?


  35. @Prodical Son ……..re sep.10th. your comparison is one of apples to oranges.If it were not for this forum many would have accepted the goodly Doctor’s comments as objective criticism.Take for example the lashes thrown in the health Minister by one Sandra Husbands some months ago.It took B U, not Nation Views that brought the actual story to tell us that she is going to be his opponent next election.Do you not see where and how such shabby journalism can be construed as deliberate attempts to mislead the public? If you do not see that surely you cannot miss the fact that outside residence is in no way a divestment of hometown interest.


  36. @Dr. Robinson

    Divestment you say?

    Hell no!

    What do we have left to sell anyway?

    Didn’t T&T buy it all?

  37. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar

    Random Thoughts

    “Jamaicans ain’t cutting off one another heads because of demons. They doing it when their heads are full of marijuana, and they are fighting with other drug dealers over MONEY, plain and simple”

    The first two people who were beheaded, was (1) a law abiding mother and (2) her 18 yr. old daughter two Christians for over a decade. The Daughter was due to start a course at the University Of the West Indies in Sept. 2011. Upright citizens of Jamaica.

    With all these problems plaguing Jamaica, people including Jamaicans can still find the time to belittle the Govt. of Barbados who is doing a wonderful job keeping the country afloat.

    The others were not drug dealers either. So get your facts right.


  38. Where in Barbados can Clyde Mascoll win a seat in parliament? Lets take them at their word that all is well in “de hive”.That takes St.Thomas off of the table of choices.Dugid’s replacement has already been named.Where else can Owen cram him down people’s throats?There is a school of thought in de hive that Richard Sealy is weak as a candidate.Perhaps Owen can show some spunk and try St.Michael South Central.Belmont Funeral Home does a great job with duppies.Politically thats what Clyde Mascoll is to Bajans.


  39. @Enuff

    what you havnt said is better than what u said. Please bring some reasoning to the table, there is a differnce between an advisor to the leader of rhe opposition and someone merely sitting on a board to deal with broad policy of an enity.


  40. I am thinking more along the philosophical lines raised by Ms. Mottley in her Chamber of Commerce speech.

    Clearly there is a lot of devil in the details and some may not be feasible but:

    Maybe in the case of school meals the employees could be facilitated to form catering type businesses that can sell the same servcies to the state.

    Maybe in the case of sanitation drivers and some employees could be faciliated to form businesses that can sell the same services to the state.

    The state still pays for the services but it can be delivered in a way that may well promote greater effciency and accountability, as well as create a new class of entrepreneurs and hopefully new wealth.

    Who knows!


  41. @Hant

    Do not let anybody on this site, and I meany anybody prevent you from giving your perspective on any subject that appeals to you. You are a Barbaian and is entitled to comment on anything happening here.

    Peace and love.


  42. @Dr. Robinson

    You are off tract on this occasion, can the private sector provise meals at ten cents a day to the poor children. Wouldnt we then have to give a subsidy to the same catering companies. How is the arrangement between the tranport board an ucal woking out. hope i got the name correctly.

    How many private schools are there now and dont govt assist them in paying for some of the teachers. Most pf the private secondary and private schools cater to the middle class who can afford the high school fees, the two private schools which cater to the lower class are struggling to survive.

    I await your response


  43. Obediant | September 11, 2011 at 11:31 AM
    I think Dr. R is saying that the GOB will still incur the expense, but, hopefully, the private sector will produce the meals more efficiently than the GOB was able to, thereby reducing the expense incurred by the GOB when it purchases the meals from the private sector. In short, the private sector employees are expected to be more productive that the public sector employees. The NCC will also fit into this category.


  44. There would be savings for sure.

    One simply has to read the Auditor General Reports through the years to understand the ‘tieffin’ which is prevalent by the School Meals Department and vendors while entering the procurement process.


  45. Quoting Carson C. Cadogan “The first two people who were beheaded, was (1) a law abiding mother and (2) her 18 yr. old daughter two Christians for over a decade.”

    And the beheaders were…???


  46. Quoting David the blog-master “One simply has to read the Auditor General Reports through the years to understand the ‘tieffin’ which is prevalent by the School Meals Department and vendors ”

    But David [and Dr. Robinson too] do you have any evidence that the private sector is less t’eifing than the public sector???

    After all aren’t private sector t’iefs raised in the same homes, schooled in the same schools and churched in the same churches as their private sector counterparts?


  47. @david

    what happens to awardee getting inflated contracts for kick back. that is thiefing too. by the way the gov is not bouned by the higest or lowest bidder.

    thiefing is institutionalised in the private and public sector..pur private sector is very inefficient and because most service sector companies are interrelatedt there could be collusion in inflating cost.


  48. what about the opportunity to empower the workers and possibly create a new class of entrepreneurs while still providing the service to the users such as the school children etc. at no direct cost to them?

    I am not ideological about the efficiency of private versus public providers, and as a worker who is paid by the government myself I cast no aspersions on the work ethic of such. However, if people are the owners of a company providing a service, they probably will have very different incentives than if they are employees.

    My broad perspective is, can we find ways to keep the social protections we have, while finding ways to deliver them more efficiently, and possibly create new opportunities. If the school meals providers are faciliated to form catering companies for example, they will not only have the school meals contracts, but they can do other jobs as well.

    For me these are thoughts floating around.


  49. I agree that we should take a closer look at the UCAL model an dhow that has worked or not worked.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading