← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

The verdict on the recent application by the Barbados Light & Power Company for a rate hike promised by the Chairman of the Fair Trading Commission  (FTC) Sir Neville Nicholls passed without any serious notice by the media earlier this month. The media given its responsibility within the Fourth Estate of the Realm has failed the PEOPLE yet again given its responsibility to keep us informed. The blatant renege by the Fourth Estate of its important civil responsibility means that most Barbadians remain ignorant to the important issues affecting them.

The Head of the Barbados Association of Non-Governmental Organizations (BANGO) Roosevelt King when asked by BU the possible reason for the delay gave the following response:

“Through fear tactics, psychological warfare, oppression and violence many people have been forced physically and mentally, [to not exercise] their right to voice their opinions or their desires to fight against the oppression that they experience. The people are forced to believe, and later come to identify with, the idea that the oppressor has supreme power and is working in the favor of the people. As a result a culture of quiet, non resistant, passive if you will, people are born. This Culture of Silence is longstanding and continues because the people continue to allow the destruction and the oppression to occur, not because they want to, but because fighting against the oppressor seems futile. Those that do fight are eradicated and made examples of in the attempt to silence future attempts at reform. – Author unknown – internet posting”

Be reminded Mr. King’s BANGO participated in the just concluded FTC/BL&P rate hike application.

The culture of silence which permeates the Barbados society does not align with the repeated position that Barbados is a highly literate and educated society. Why does civil society, the Fourth Estate included and by extension ordinary Barbadians continue absolve important agencies like the Fair Trade Commission from being accountable? Is it the PEOPLE are afraid? Is it the PEOPLE are ignorant and need to be educated about what is important to a functioning and cohesive society? Why would the Fourth Estate not see the lack of a report by the FTC by the promised deadline as significant news?

The Nelson Barbados versus many prominent Barbadians court case has been covered exclusively by BU. We understand the blackout by the local media has to do with the position the matter is sub judice. Is this correct Pat Hoyos? BU suggests the real reason has to be the fact the local media is scared shitless about covering the case because of ignorance and the intimidation factor. Until the Fourth Estate discontinues the blackout on the Nelson Barbados/Kingsland Estate/Peter Allard legal matter, the people of Barbados will remain ignorant and consequently vulnerable to manipulation.

After a full year of BU battering the Barbados Fourth Estate it is clear the traditional media remains in crisis. Its willingness to be sympathetic to sponsors  or to promote stories which require little intelligence, competence and effort has created a void. Fortunately we live in the age of the Internet and in 2010 BU suspects this medium will become a louder voice for the PEOPLE.  The void created by an incompetent and unprofessional media now provides fertile ground for the buds of Internet flowers to sprout.  Within the current culture of silence it remains the only hope Barbadians have to change the way business gets done.

As 2010 comes to a close BU  appeals to all civic minded Barbadians and friends to use the Internet medium to make their voices heard. BU will continue to resist the urge to become commercial. The only agenda which BU will promote will be that of the BU family.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

46 responses to “The Blooming Of A Thousand Flowers Ready To Launch Assault On The Culture Of Silence Suffocating Barbados”


  1. Please tell me, what is the verdict…? Pat Hoyas says that he is anxious to get it over with…! No sense of commit period, no sense of responsibility!


  2. sad !
    very
    f****** (friggin)

    sad


  3. Disgraceful!!! Let me show how.

    A Canadian (sex not relevant) sues in Canada and, all appeals having been exhausted, loses.

    The Canadian has a backer. A Bajan multi-millionaire.

    The Bajan devises a plan to re-try the case in Barbados and sets up an elborate system of shell companies with no assets and drop boxes as coprorate, registered addresses, all in the name of a notorious Bajan fraud expert, to pursue this case in Barbados.

    And in Barbados, this Bajan (thorugh his coprorate front and its stoogie officer/director) sues Canada and many prominent Canadians (like Prime Minister Harper and former Prime Minister Martin) for half a billion US dollars.

    Now, even without the twists and turns, do you not think the Canadian Fourth Estate would sit up and take notice and start investigating and preliminary, exploratory stories?

    THEN, the Barbados judge rules that Barbados has no jurisdiction and he makes many comments denouncing the conduct of our Bajan billionaire’s Barbados Bar Association counsel.

    Do you think this (now fair comment) PUBLISHED judgment by a Bajan judge in favour of Canada, Prime Minister Harper, former Prime Minister Martin and others, would escape the attention of the Canadian press?

    Delinquency of duty to the PEOPLE aside, I want to know just who is paying whom – AND HOW MUCH – to suppress this and other stories including to NOT ask Sir Neville to explain himself.

    Frankly, if I want to see what the girls’ netball team at any given school has done, I rely on the Fourth Estate of Barbados. HOWEVER, if I want news – hard news about relevant topics – we have only the blogs.

    Of course, as we all know, there are blogs and there are blogs – but that is a topic for another time.

    And how do we deal with the Fourth Estate to let it know that we are as mad as hell? SIMPLE!!!!

    It is not through the sale of papers to us that the print media derives its income, but through advertising revenue. It is also through advertising revenue that the electronic media derives its income.

    That advertising revenue is determined by the number of people the ad is likely to reach – in other words, its audience.

    Remove the audience, and advertisers will not buy space and the fourth estate will then maybe revisit their obligations to the PEOPLE.

    SO, let us simply stop being the audience of the Fourth Estate. CUT OFF ITS REVENUE!!!!

    End of problem.


  4. Preaching on the blogs will strengthen the resolve of the converted, but it will not attract new members to the cause.

    How do you get thousands of Bajans, that depend on Barbadian media workers to keep them informed, to acknowledge that they are being shortchanged, to demand and expect better and to accept that there are alternatives to the traditional?

    Ignorance is still bliss and there is high probability that it will always be so.


  5. @GL

    Yes and no!

    It is a fight that will not be won easily but the battlelines MUST be drawn by some.

    In 2009 many a call-in program was influenced by what some read on the blogs.

    We can’t give up.


  6. Some weeks ago, two members of the People’s Democratic Congress picketed the Nation Publishing Company, stoutly protesting the significant decline over the last 15 years or so in the overall standard of journalism at the Nation Newspapers – which has been plummeting way below the standard that was initially wonderfully set and maintained and improved upon by the likes of Mr. Harold Hoyte, Mr. Carl Moore, Mr. Al Gilkes, Mr. Tony Cozier, et al. Now, only one of its news publications has been able to set some of its own standards and benchmarks – and in some cases has been able to maintain and improve upon them in terms of content and packaging, and this is the Barbados Business Authority. We dare say all the other news issues of the Nation Publishing Company are often filled with pure unadulterated irrelevant mindless trash!!

    So, with one placard each in their hands, Mr. Akil Umi and Mr Mark Adamson were able to effectively bring to the attention of thousands of people traveling on that Fontabelle Road at the time of the protest, the PDC’s very strong feelings concerning the manner in which the Nation Newspapers have been run by especially those personnel that have been presiding over the editorial and news content within recent years.

    Truth be told, those two patriots reported to the wider PDC, and to many members of the public who were able to know about the protest and had asked about it – on how encouraged they were by the tremendous outpouring of support that was given by countless motorists, pedestrians, passengers in public service vehicles, for their call to the public to boycott the Nation Newspapers – with some of these persons openly stating that they were in agreement with it and how they used to buy the Nation Newspapers, but how they no longer buy any of them.

    Moreover, in response to the PDC’s call for another newspaper to emerge that would primarily be about representing or otherwise being in the vanguard of the interests of the masses and middle classes – some members of the public have even been seriously asking about the realism or real possibility of having such another newspaper, the FORMAT that it will take and funding for it. And one of the things that we in the PDC have been in turn saying to them is that they or the relevant others can use the prevailing computer and information technologies to create their own “online newspapers” – which are cheaper financially to establish, more interactive and more up to date with the news than traditional newspaper formats have ever been.

    Well, some of these same persons appeared to have been accepting that suggestion, and have even been remarking how the newspaper and by extension the news media culture in Barbados will definitely be greater evolving at least in regard of the overall means for delivering the news to readers, listeners, etc.- in the future, in that – these same computer and information technologies will help to make traditional media houses with their out dated top-down, pre-packaged, sometimes politically divisive news details and money sucking corporate ads, relics of the pasts.

    And, it is NOT ONLY at the Nation Publishing Company that there has been the deadly torturing and massacring of many long-cherished news gathering and compiling and reporting standards BUT ALSO it is at the Starcom Network, and the CBC.

    So, the ball is in the court of the users of on-line technologies to help create a diversified responsible platform for the development of a greater modernized, more conscious news media culture for Barbados.

    PDC


  7. David,

    The call-in programs, in the early days, were required listening, remember the early nineties? I believe that issues raised on blogs, that subsequently make it to these programs, are usually the result of a blogger or commenter calling in.

    Today these programs do little to inform or champion the cause of the masses. They main purpose now, is to sell advertising and to promote political and corporate propaganda.

    Media workers (Journalist, Reporters, Moderators) do not willingly mention,
    credit, or cite Bajan blogs as sources, even when the information is credible.
    One is therefore forced to ask, if it is not to inform and educate, what is their true mission and what purpose are they serving?

    A way has to be found to get the message out to the people, informing them of the alternatives that exists.

    Depending on the traditional media to do so is counter productive, IMHO.

  8. mash up & buy back Avatar
    mash up & buy back

    David/BU Family

    The immigration green paper is being discussed on VOB call in show right now.

    David ellis – moderator and the chief immigration officer from Antigua is on the air.

  9. mash up & buy back Avatar
    mash up & buy back

    The panel seem stacked as per the comments in favour of the pro immigration crowd.

    This should surprise no one.

    George brathwaite is now spouting off his hot air and the usual BLP pro immigrants stance.

    Wuhloss.


  10. @David
    I will agree that it is a fight. Decades ago we would have been able to mount demonstrations but today the arena is quite different and the fight has become more sophisticated. It is calling for a lot more planning and resources.

    We at BANGO can only but work towards it because it is a new frontier in advocacy. Today’s advocate must work his/her way to the table. It is more an evidence-based approach and one of the problems is that we have been sitting so long in bewilderment that we are without much of the evidence… but as they say, time longer than twine.

    In the meantime, it is clear that we cannot look forward to any support from the fourth estate, they are completely won over to the other side by economic considerations. More important is that the fourth estate does not constitute civil society leadership, the driving force behind the choice of journalism today is employment of skills to earn a living.

    The members of the fourth estate are average citizens, susceptible to the same pressures that keep the society subdued.

    In the end, advocates are required but will only be those who are brave enough to fight against the odds and in many cases, be prepared to stand alone.


  11. Thanks mash up, extremely difficult to listen 100% at this time but we are trying. We hear George Brathwaite, Norman Faria on the panel. Who are the others?


  12. Actually, General Lee, it IS that simple.

    The only real function that the Barbados newspapers serves is in the area of official notices, like notices of bankruptcy, probate etc. BUT these are also covered in the Official Gazette. In fact, it could be argued that the Official Gazette is more important. So, as the Government would be glad for the money, all we need do is to subscribe to the Official Gazette.

    I admit the mind-set in Barbados and I agree it is an uphill struggle, but it is achieveable and look at the advantages. The Guyanese at the Nation will find that it cannot afford to pay their wages and they may just take themselves and their lack of any discernable journalistic expertise off to Guyana as no one else in Barbados is likely to employ them. What is wrong with that?


  13. It is time Barbadians begin to question why the publisher of the Nation newspaper should be someone of a non-journalist background. Why the Chief Editor is someone who can’t string 10 coherent words in a discussion or represent the newspaper on a panel to discuss any issue of serious note. It should concern Barbadians that Harold Hoyte would have been allowed to sell-out the Nation to a Trinidad concern. The Advocate is known to be run by a businessman and not a newspaper profession. Recently the bombardment of advertising selling advertising has gotten to the point of being distasteful. CBC although there has been some improvement the appointment of Leroy Parris to the chairmanship speaks to business as usual.

  14. mash up & buy back Avatar
    mash up & buy back

    David

    The other panellist is a farmer called stephen elcock – never heard of him.

    Mike browne ususally puts together the panel,so it is NO SURPRISE that he has no one there DEFENDING BARBADIAN BORDERS or the need to halt this influx of immigration madness.

    By now mike browne anti – bajan pro non national stance is very obvious.

    Where is the balance that david ellis is always calling for,and why is he not playing devil advocate and put the side of the majaority of bajans as indicated in the last poll?

    Hmmm.

    Lord help us!

  15. mash up & buy back Avatar
    mash up & buy back

    David

    Who is the publisher of the nation and the chief editor.Somewhere in there is roxanne gibbs I know.

    What is said about this discussion on the green paper,is that something which is critical to this country like barbados is being discussed in this wishy washy way with norman faria,george brathwaite and some lil known farmer.

  16. mash up & buy back Avatar
    mash up & buy back

    Should read:’what is sad about this discussion…’


  17. Man ROK

    Please, WHAT IS THE VERDICT???


  18. The publisher is a woman called Ann Gittens.

    Agree with you a matter of this importance should be discussed by people of high calibre. The new immigration policy is just that and should be addressed by the policymakers. The reality is we will need foreign labour in agriculture and construction but we have to do it in a managed way. To have Faria and Brarthwaite on the panel is fanning an emotional line.

    The Auditor General has already spoken on this matter. Time to move on.


  19. @BAFBFP
    What verdict? The Panel is still deliberating. They have not given an indication as to when the verdict will be returned, unless correspondence to that effect was delivered on the last working day last week. I have not been to the office since Wednesday.


  20. On a panel like the one VOB had today a policymaker (government representative), someone from the Caricom/CSME secretariat, a high calibre journalist, an economist to evaluate the green paper in the context of economic development etc.

    Instead we had a poorakey panel man.


  21. @BAFBFP

    The FTC has a website, one should assume that it will be updated when the decision is given.


  22. David

    It is time Barbadians begin to question why the publisher of the Nation newspaper should be someone of a non-journalist background
    *************************************
    Why should there be a stipulation that the publisher of a newspaper must be a journalist? Many publishers of newspapers are non journalists and the newspapers have excellent records. I think Ms Gittens is a CA surely she is qualified to be a publisher. If you want to make an argument for publishers to be journalists surely an argument can be made for the reverse. As to your argument about advertising, again it is not a charitable organisation, it has to make money or else there is no newspaper. You can’t have your cake and eat it.

    Lord knows I am not a friend of the Nation but one shouldn’t throw out the baby with the bathwater.


  23. @Sargeant

    Name the newspapers for the record.

    Note the point being made. The Nation newspaper has an editor who is not a journalist of note with a boss who does not have a journalist background. Editorial decisions at the Nation can be easily questioned and have been on the blogs with regularity. BTW, what is the latest with the Carol Martindale/Henry saga? You don’t want to know!


  24. @Sargeant // December 27, 2009 at 2:34 PM

    Your argument does not work. Publishing is a very specialized field and just because someone is a CA or an LLB does not fit them to do the job. A journalist definitely stands a better chance. You wouldn’t ask a journalist to run a chartered accountancy or a law office. Being an LLB would be preferrable, bcause at least their obligation to the public would be met in that hopefully (but not definitely) they would know the difference between sub judice and fair comment and PUBLIC INTEREST and do their jobs. However, the appointment of a CA does not auger well for the PUBLIC INTEREST, as the concern is the bottom line – which means concentration on advertising, NOT news.

    So, I repeat. We must start a campaign to get the general public to boycott the traditional media. A month of not buying newspapers (with the threat of more to come) ought to redress the balance. Call it ‘economic sanctions’. You never know, it might hit the world press that Bajans, fed up with their so-called fourth estate, have decided to dispense with it. Good international story there.


  25. Let me take it a bit further.. NO, absolutely NO CA or CA BEng (in the case of Gittens) or LLb is qualified to run any companies in Ba’bados, public or private, other than those which operate in the areas of their specific training. Accountants do not make decisions, Engineers hate risk and Lawyers always seek precedence. They all take forever to get anything done, and they are incapable of having a firm policy on anything. As for economists and historians, all of the above is true.


  26. @BAFBFP // December 27, 2009 at 3:53 PM. Completely agree. Precisely my view as well.


  27. BAFBFP /Amused,

    What is comes down to is not the individual’s training, but the capability of the individual.

    As usual, generalising the status quo cannot work.

    The only solution is to find the best person for the job, be it engineer, doctor, accountant, lawyer, plumber, gardener, policeman, whatever.

    It is the aptitude and adaptation of the individual that counts.

    One can train someone for something specific i.e. as an MBA to run a company, but that does no mean that they will be successful.

    Two words.

    The individual.


  28. @Crusoe // December 28, 2009 at 5:43 AM. CORRECT.


  29. @Crusoe

    Your statement is true but you should attach that some distinguishing quality should separate The Individual from the pack. Even if we accept The Individual had such a distinguishing quality the waning circulation of the Nation newspaper, the lack of a mentorship/leadership program within the Nation to breed good journalists and the sacrifice of editorial content because of relationships is enough for anyone to call a spade a spade.


  30. David,

    I am not familiar with the specific case you mention, but if those are the facts, then ‘res ipsa loquitor’.


  31. No no no NO…!

    Any human being that is prepared to tuck away years of personal development into tedious and deciplined study deserves to be rewarded yes, but that trait alone DISQUALIFIES them from being effective trail blazers… they basically are and can only be back office operatives and nothing more…! Please do not bring Engineers Bizzy and Allan Fields into this either because as many operations that they have managed they have all been in tried and tested areas of acivity. Look, an effective business leader is someone that can SELL, and that takes real tallent. That which differentiates them from the pack is a TRACK RECORD and NOT a certificate of some kind…Period!

    When you think about the make up of our governments… my God!


  32. Are we reading the arrogance of the FTC Commissioners shinning through. The public was promised a decision in December 2009 and after some prodding of the traditional media we now hear Sir Neville moaning about the voluminous material which has to be reviewed.

    Why not show respect to the public by proactively delivering a statement around the same time the decision was originally promised?


  33. Correct. Now the question has to be asked (incidentally which member of the traditional media did the prodding?), with the knowledge that these people are being engaged as consultants, and that as a result their remuneration will be determined by hours spent on the job, should there not have been a dead line date for the delivery of the verdict? What is this, another open ended arrangement unfolding at the tax payers’ expense?

  34. Dennis Jones (aka Living in Barbados) Avatar
    Dennis Jones (aka Living in Barbados)

    @ROK, on the matter of FTC and BL&P, it was clear during the hearing that the regular media were not capable of, or interested in, making the points at issue understood by the general public. You and Chris Halsall made that the point succintly during the discussion on VOB about ‘journalism under fire’. So, one should not keep looking for blood out of a stone and for the ‘4th Estate’ leopard to change its spots.

    The void they are creating needs to be filled, if people are to grapple with issues. Those with expertise need to just accept that as part of what they do, and using blogs is one route, but so too are other media.

    On the matter of the electricity rates, I asked previously whether BANGO, given its role as ‘intervenor’, could (or should) fill that void and set out what it sees as the issues overall. Even with a clear bias in favour of a group of citizens (as made clear publicly by Chris Halsall), that is a job that can be done. I do not recall seeing a reply on that, so if it never came, my question remains.


  35. @David….why don’t you stop lending credence to the 4th estate and do your thing? Look at your site as an alternative media site and not along the same vein as the 4th, because its the alternative sites from whence you gather info that the MSM will not touch because they are controlled by external factors. They serve the money masters. With time BU will slowly but surely rise above the fray. Watch the 4th estate go the way of the dinosaurs!


  36. The thing is that when operations sense that the curtains are soon to be drawn, they have a way of extracting what ever they can in which ever way they can to baloon into retirement…! We see it with Political parties all the time. We see it with C&W and we will see it with BL&P as distributive energy technology rapidly takes hold in the Caribbean. The Nation is grabbing at straws and so too for that matter is Starcom. The internet will kill ’em all.. hahahaha (sung to the tune – Thriller by Michael Jackson)


  37. The C&W broad hint to consumers yesterday that a price hike maybe in the ofting confirms once and for all that this company is about raping the region for all it can get before it LEAVES! Additionally Alex Macdonald is no Stephen Worme; at least Worme uses sweet persuasion to woo Barbadians on his side! The service C&W provides is not only about technical delivery; it MUST be about CUSTOMER SERVICE. Why would they feel justified in hiking rates at this time when its customer service based on all reports is slightly under POOR. At the same time the C&W execs continue to enjoy huge packages relative to market, huge bonuses even at this time of economic slow down, not forgetting they have sent home people or forced them to leave. The wining and dining of the employees at the recent Christmas party by dishing out cash and electronic items will not cut it.


  38. Sorry David,

    But Alex Macdonald (Country Head) should be appropriately compared to Peter Williams (CEO) and not Steven Worme (DPR). Agaiin the focus should be on the FTC who made the original arrangement with C&W.

    Now Alex Macdonaldduck is a product of StarCommical which just recently laid off a hell of a lot of staff (while under Macdonaldduck’s watch) at the barest hint of an economic downturn, and soon afterwards furnished its CEO with a spanking new Fully Loaded 4WD SUV Audi Q7 …!


  39. @ David

    Why not start an FTC Count Down(UP?). For example this is Day 17 since the promised date for a delivery of a verdict. Keep this in your banner or as the perpetual first post on the home page.

    (These commissioners are consultants, hourly rates and the clock is running. With such sterling arguments against any kind of increase at all it is mind boggling that they should have taken any where near this long…!)


  40. @BU Family…

    My best wishes to everyone as we enter the “Twenty Tens”.

    I have just spent a fortnight in a near but foreign sovereign nation…

    The food was better and much more varied; the ambient noise was louder and out of control.

    There was much less garbage around; I felt much less comfortable about the safety of those close to me….


  41. @Chris

    Same to you and yours from the BU household.

    Any hope that you can transmit the rest of your message in clear text?

    lol


  42. @David: “Any hope that you can transmit the rest of your message in clear text?

    Smile…

    What I was trying to say is that while things can always be better, we should be thankful for what we have.


  43. @All…

    Please let us not forget that we’re also still awaiting a decision from the FTC on the Consolidated Reference Interconnection Offer (RIO).

    The public oral presentations were held 2009.06.15.

    Iff (if and only if) the FTC properly insists on an “Outgoing International Call Termination” Service Description to be added to the new RIO, Bajans could enjoy much less expensive international telephony.

    This service description requirement in the RIO was recognized by the Barbados Telecommunication’s Unit’s “Telecommunications Act Review Committee” (TARC) during the drafting of the gazetted Barbados Two Stage Dialing Policy and the Barbados Equal Access and Indirect Access Policy, both passed by the Barbados Cabinet 2007.11.16.

    Why has it taken more than two years (and counting) for the FTC to enable and enforce the laws of Barbados to the benefit of Consumers?

    Good question….


  44. 38 days and no decision..! Wait dese fellas gettin’ pay by de hour I hear…! David you better start counting de hours taken so far in mekkin’ dis decision.. assuming eight hours a day minus two days per week for weekends and multiply the number by $200.00 per hour, per commissioner (six of them)…! My God!


  45. @BAFBFP

    Chris advised on another blog the FTC has advised the date the decision will be handed down is 28 January 2010.


  46. Well Thursday is the day afterall… Why should it take so long to deliver what should really be a very straight forward decision…? Is this a ploy? This company, sorry this utility deserves nothing,,,!

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading