Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

The article (below) by Barbados Today attempts to capture the contribution on VOB 92.9 Starcom by Minister in the Ministry of Finance Ryan Straughn on the economy and his forecast. To be honest after listening to Straughn – a key man on government’s finance team – the blogmaster was not optimistic the country will see an ease in two years. There are no shovel ready projects and the those in the pipeline are all tourism flavoured.

The banking systems is reported to be awash with money: Barbadians not borrowing, banks not lending or both. There is the sick National Insurance Fund. Not exhaustive but there is a beleaguered middles class who has endured belt tightening mode for more than 10 years under permutations of the Medium Term Fiscal Plan and the Medium Term Development Plan. Now there is BERT!

Thanks to @John A

David, blogmaster


 


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

252 responses to “Two More Years”


  1. PRIME MINISTER MIA AMOR MOTTLEY says she cannot give Barbadians assurances there won’t be more layoffs, or that taxes and fees will not increased
    .

    She explained that the big corporate tax cut meant that Government had $40 million less revenue and had to get funding in other ways.(SC)


  2. Now the gift of 40 million which was handed to Corporate would have to be financed by working bajans who are struggling daily to keep their head above ground
    Trickle down economics or as some say vodoo economic only help the rich


  3. Your head is so hard.


  4. Maybe u should send that message to Mia
    She gave back too much in a time of austerity
    That amount could have been smaller


  5. I think what we need to look at is not only what he said but what it meant in the bigger picture to us as a people.

    Basically his speech confirms that BERT has failed to encourage any economic growth over the last 2 years.

    When he says people are not spending despite them receiving tax returns, he is therefore confirming a lack of buying power by persons. After 8 years of economic famine and no growth, a $100 today is only worth in real terms about $70. This based on a worker having been on a wage freeze for 8 years while inflation galloped along.

    So we must ask now where is growth of 1.5% going to come from? No doubt all hope will be tied to the one horse race of tourism and all that revolves around it. Of course the governor can always come back in September and revised growth estimate down to say 0.5%, as his predecessor did for the last 4 years so that back door is available to him.

    My question is how are we going to get growth of 1.5% when all we are doing is looking at tourism? To obtain growth would all the productive sectors not require equal attention?

    I have said BERT would produce no growth from day 1, so now we must ask the MOF when will a real growth plan be rolled out and how will it assist ALL sectors of the economy?


  6. @John A

    Do you accept that austerity or fiscal tightening by definition would have suffocated growth read contraction? When was the timing of the tax cuts etc and have they had time to take effect. Does it matter? How would it have been possible for growth to happen editing domestic and external debt restructure.

    Asking for friends.


  7. I would also suggest we take note of 2 articles in Barbados Today.

    British arrivals down from them leaving the EU.

    The second one is ” IMF austerity plan may need topping up”

    The first speaks for itself while the second hints to more taxation on the horizon.

    Tell me which of these is positive for economic growth of 1.5% this year?

    Reality vs propaganda


  8. @John A

    To be fair to the Prime Minister her comments were of a pragmatic flavour. Bear in mind we are coming from a place of embarrassing financial indiscipline. The government is driving towards a debt to GDP number of 60% and primary surplus of 6%. Against this Tennyson Josephs article in the Nation is worth the read. Where will the extra come from to move the primary surplus number now that the so-called lie hanging of debt restructure has been completed?


  9. @ David.

    We raised $400M in New taxes and then we forgave $400M in vat liability owed to the state. Had we of cleaned up the money pits, sorted the leaks in customs and addressed the failures in our collection agencies, there would of been no need for the massive austerity program. Instead of that we took the easy way out and brought more taxes to a failed collection system. It was like having our broken transport board and leaving it as is, but instead we increased bus fares and threw more money at a poorly run entity, hoping it would fix it. Economic lunacy at its best.

    They were elected to bring change and address the above issues. If we wanted more of the same we could of left sinkler as MOF.


  10. The excessive taxation is the problem. We must radically reduce income tax and VAT. We must also devalue the cursed Barbadian dollar to a 4:1 ratio. All this will boost the economy.

    In return, we must clean up the civil service with its many slackers, sleepers and free riders. We must get rid of at least 10,000 civil servants over the next 10 years. The remedy is simple: early retirement at 55, no new hires, financial incentives to emigrate. No one should be laid off.

    We must also shrink the bloated welfare state. Let’s face it: the welfare state has made people lazy, fat and lethargic over the past decades.

    But we also all know that nothing like this will happen. We cannot change people. We will continue to groan under the excessive tax burden, the civil service will continue to paralyse the economy and people will continue to demand social entitlements in their blindness and arrogance.

    The wealth of the Hindu Guyanese remains as our only hope. In the best case scenario they will build so many casinos, brothels and hotels in Barbados with their petro-dollars that Barbadians will at least get new jobs there.


  11. @John A

    Have to agree with your comment about the leaking tax bucket. Even now there is no evidence the holes have been adequately repaired. One sense this solution did not fit the plan that was hatched before the election win.


  12. @ david

    I would liken the road we took to a shop keeper with a theft problem thinking it can be fixed by increasing prices and sending home staff to cut his expenses. In the meantime he continues to lose money daily in theft which he leaves unaddressed.

  13. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ David BU

    I hope you realize that this submission is going to yield the same responses as the previous two dealing with BERT. There is no revelation of any plan for sustainable growth.There are said to be intermediary construction projects that are short term ,unless we intend to cover Barbados in concrete. The final output of these building projects has an upward boundary, a declining demand for tourism related services.
    Is Tourism contracting or increasing ? On what assumptions is this based?

    I understand the pressure to get answers but you have to change tactics.


  14. @Vincent

    What do you suggest from a lowly blogmaster?

  15. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ Tron

    After hundreds of your submissions to BU I am at a loss as to what your real role is. Is it comic relief? Agent provocateur? Apologist for the far right? Or a relic of a past ideology that wants back your underpaid,subservient working underclass?


  16. @ John A February 6, 2020 8:26 AM
    “They were elected to bring change and address the above issues. If we wanted more of the same we could of left sinkler as MOF.”
    +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

    Agree! Barbados would have been on a more strategic trajectory towards genuine economic restructuring instead of the current tourniquet and window dressing to hide a hemorrhaging economy.

    It would have allowed the fool to complete the journey to ‘Paradise Lost’.

    A return of the Stuart administration would have opened the gates for the devaluation devil to enter.

    There would then have been a common denominator of challenges instead of the poor having to carrying so much a burden of sacrifice to allow the ‘big-life-loving’ Bajans to carry on with the conspicuous consumption habits without earning the forex to pay for their ‘sweet-life’.

    The Devaluation slogan would have been: ‘Earn forex or Die’.

    We shall soon see if the February 2020 start date for the Hyatt erection as promised by MoT will materialize or be rescheduled on the timetable marked (to use the doublespeak of Sinliar the former Master of Fibs (MoF) “Soon” aka in the fullness of time.


  17. @ Vincent Codrington February 6, 2020 9:00 AM

    You are confusing the republican right with globalist libertarianism. I have never preached a conservative family image, claimed that certain ethnic groups are inferior etc. pp. On the contrary, I am against a strong state in the sense of the US Republicans with a bloated military and a repressive police apparatus.

    Your statement is typical for all members of the leftist Barbadian establishment that defames all liberals who want to free citizens from the paternalism of a rotten social system. Without knowing it (maybe you know it secretly), you too are part of the so-called duopoly.

    I preach globalization, free migration, dismantling of statehood and social standards, dismantling of ethnic barriers, disarmament, privatization, deregulation and flexibilization. Freedom is the highest good.

    The state has failed, so it is time for civil society to take over. We need a second emancipation, we need to free people from their self-inflicted immaturity, which has degraded them to economic slaves.

    We must therefore knock the old idol Barrow off his pedestal and support the policy of our Most Honourable Prime Minister. The move to the IMF was the right one. The IMF will help us to dismantle the welfare state and reduce the bureaucracy in order to overcome economic slavery.


  18. @ Miller

    What I want to hear is what progress has been made in reducing the subsidies to the money pits over the last 2 years. Also what steps have been taken to reduce the loss of duty at the air and sea port? Don’t tell me about Asycuda world as that is a working program it does not replace the need for cameras at the air and sea port.

    In other words we know wunna raise nuff taxes but what has been done to fix the leaks in the revenue collection systems you found? You do realise there is a limit to how far you can tax us to maintain inefficiency don’t you?


  19. Who is the Minister of Finance ?


  20. “The banking system is reported to be awash with money”

    A lot of the money belongs to retirees who already own houses, receive a decent pension that covers all monthly needs and are risk averse and therefore have no interest in investment. They are quite content to leave the money on the bank and let their descendants have what is left when they die. The truth is there isn’t much for retirees to do in Barbados.

    A plan to re-engage retirees in the local economy is necessary. A combination of leisure sports, education, investment and community service is needed. BARP when it was led by Mrs. Drayton was heading in this direction, then she passed and the vultures (led by Billie Miller and her cronies) swooped in and took over, now the organisation is a shell of itself. The only thing BARP stands for now is discounts.

  21. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ Tron at 9:19 AM

    Thanks for your comprehensive response. It certainly assisted in my classification of your role.


  22. @ Redguard

    You are right. After a lifetime working and building up a decent occupational pension and a home, Barbadians living overseas would be mad to indulge in unregulated, or lightly regulated investment vehicles in Barbados, less than two years after the government defaulted on their debt obligations. They must think people are mad.
    First, there are much better investment opportunities in North America and the UK – ISAs, for example, are tax free – and there is always the Financial Services Compensation Scheme which guarantees your first £85000 in any bank of institution.
    Then, of course, there are tax implications for any UK resident investing overseas. Take good advice if you want to invest, but think again and have a drink and the silly thought will go away.
    Don’t let them gather on your savings.


  23. Don’t let them gather on your savings.
    DONT LET THEM GATHER YOUR SAVINGS EITHER!


  24. @John A

    You took note that the Chinese gifted 20 million to the government to restart the Sam Lords project.


  25. @ John A February 6, 2020 9:22 AM
    “In other words we know wunna raise nuff taxes but what has been done to fix the leaks in the revenue collection systems you found? You do realise there is a limit to how far you can tax us to maintain inefficiency don’t you?”
    ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

    And you are expecting such volte-face performance to come from the red half of the duopoly?

    Do you expect the current litter of political pigs with red stripes and feeding from the taxpayers’ trough to squeal on their Napoleon ‘blue friends’ whom they have replaced by employing all the gimmickry and comforting promises to voting fools which can be found in the bible of electioneering tactics?

    Do you really feel that any investigations have been conducted, yet, by the Barbados Revenue Avoidance agency to establish if the proceeds from the many ‘under-the-table’ contracts and consultancies given to ‘mutual’ friends under the previous administration have been properly declared and accounted for?

    Just look at what has taken place with the duty-free luxury vehicle which has been driven around Barbados with a spectre behind the wheel shouting:
    ‘I am the untouchable holy ghost employed as the Sales Director of an imaginary Lighthouse of a hotel in the Bay street pie-in-the-sky’.

    The Duopoly, in which ever incarnation, rules the roost!
    Poor preacher man William Skinner, he probably sees himself in the political mirror image to that of the old Jewish prophet Jeremiah.


  26. Miller,

    If the establishment doesn’t get its a** up, Barbados will be bankrupt again after the end of the current IMF programme after three additional years at the latest.

    The next IMF programme from 2026 on will include the devaluation of the Barbados dollar. We will then be dancing on the graves of the welfare state and singing the songs of the age of civil society without social security. The unemployed civil servants will chant laments to the dull sound of skull drums.

    The potential failure of the current IMF programme should not frighten us, but should be taken as a promise of a golden age of freedom.


  27. Those whom the gods seek to destroy they first make mad.


  28. Latest news: The cost of living is out of control because of a drought and the rising costs of carrots and vegetables. Dr. Clyde Mascoll Brasstacks today.
    And foolish me thought it was the NSRL


  29. Clyde the goat Mascoll trying his best to defend the indefensible bahh bahhh
    As incredible as it might be he told the last govt that taxing people was an exercise tantamount to be lynched at high noon in public square
    Now having no alternative he puts on his masked derssed in mascot style and blames the drought
    What a ting doah


  30. On February 6, 2020 6:24 AM, Mariposa posted the following comment re: “Now the gift of 40 million which was handed to Corporate would have to be financed by working bajans who are struggling daily to keep their head above ground. Trickle down economics or as some say vodoo economic only help the rich.”

    I’m trying to understand the context in which she is using the term “trickle down economics or as some say voodoo economics only helps the rich,” ….. a comment that was surprisingly “liked” by @ Vincent Codrington.

    If I’m not mistaken, reducing taxes on businesses alone does not conform to the trickle down theory.

    Trickle down economics assumes savers, investors and owners of companies initiate economic growth. Therefore, by reducing taxes on businesses, high income earners, dividends and capitals gains, there is an expectation business owners would use savings from the tax cuts to invest in the economy by expanding their businesses and create more employment and investment opportunities.

    An increase in employment should result in an increase in wages causing a multiplier effect re an increased demand for goods and services, which, in theory, should stimulate economic activity, leading to a rise in tax revenues. The excess tax revenue realized as a result, could be used to fund government spending, i.e. health care, grants to public institutions, welfare, education, etc.


  31. It is long past time that the Government examine the 4 non-austerity plans that were on the proverbial table. Dr Greenidge stated that he had not seen any of them when they were preparing BERT. He also said that he would not at any of them, in violation of the PMs directive that all ideas must contend.


  32. The reality is we have to accept BERT failed miserably as a growth generating plan. This their own minister has now confirmed. So if couple that to the “hint ” by the MOF that the IMF austerity plan may need topping up, in other words more taxes in we tail, pray tell where will the highest growth projection in 10 years come from in such an environment?

    I mean I ain t no koolaid drinker but Lord even some of them must got questions too.


  33. John A,

    More realism please! The Guyanese had to drink from the sewer for 40 years, we have only 12 years of decline. That leaves 28 years until around 2050.

    As long as no one is willing to devalue the damn Barbados dollar with this dream dancer on the 50 dollar bill, we will not grow. The same goes, of course, for the far too many whiny sleepers in the civil service. Here, too, someone finally has to cut the tableau in half with a chainsaw.

    But the men on the island are too weak to finally blow up the welfare state with dynamite. Only a female prime minister could do that.


  34. @John A

    Plse do a search on BERT and see the comments. I have been saying BERT will fail from day one. It is economic nonsense. You get this when there is no proper debate – in the media, in parliament or on the blogs.
    This is the intellectual arrogance of neo-Monetarists, believing nothing could be wrong with their all-embracing theories. In truth, economic orthodoxy has no answers to the crisis faced by late stage capitalism. It emphasises market efficiency, asset price inflation, the notion of equilibrium and so on.
    Neo-Monetarists’ secular gospel of austerity is betraying the faithful. Unfortunately we have a minister of finance who is not familiar with comic theory who bluffs her way out with flamboyant speeches. But stability is only a contingent state, it is not a definitive answer to economic crisis. It is a holding operation. There is a public cost to neglect: infrastructure, education, health, housing, read safety, etc.. But the neo-Monetarists still preach, like an autistic adult, of too much government.
    BERT has never sought to explain the mantra of growth, because it cannot. First it will have to explain how reductions in public spending could get them out of an economic crisis. Instead, what we are seeing is the private sector hoarding cash and pressuring the government for even more cash, through the flawed and perverse so-called social partnership. Even the simple objective of exporting more and importing less cannot work.
    Look at Massy’s supermarkets, importing carrots from the US and Canada – and ordinary Bajans are going in to these exploitative stores and spending their money.
    In Barbados we have never had a moment of discovery, a moment in time when innovation, change, gripped the nation’s attention. How many patents have been registered in Barbados since November 1966? That should tells us something about the real future of our nation.
    Watch out for social tension. It will end in tears.


  35. @Hal Austin February 6, 2020 3:35 PM

    It was always clear that BERT is only the beginning. Now it’s time to get down to business. We have to get rid of all the ballast in the bureaucracy and the state-run businesses. To cushion the impact, we should finance a container for people to transport their belongings to Guyana.


  36. @ Hal Austin
    @ John A

    Don’t you get tired of casting pearls among swine?


  37. @ Baje

    The joys of retirement.

  38. William Skinner Avatar

    @ Hal @ John A

    I asked twenty years ago how can we restructure an economy without reforming the educational system.
    There is no depth to our economic policy because we have failed miserably to connect the dots and lack the philosophical or ideological anchors to inspire the populace.
    You are broke. You borrow a few grand and convince yourself that you have solved all your problems. You go home and tell your family everything is now okay. One month later you can’t afford to feed them. You are broke again.
    Masturbation is fleeting but not sex. What we have now by the Duopoly is nothing more than economic masturbation. Simple as that!
    Enjoy.


  39. @ William

    We have had 14 years of Arthur, ten years of Thompson/Stuart and nearly two years of Mottley, a total nearly 26 years. With educational reforms, anyone under the age of 30 in Barbados would have had a world class (genuinely) education.
    Pls remind me, was the prime minister and minister of finance once education minister? Is education reform part of BERT?

  40. Piece the Legend Avatar
    Piece the Legend

    @ Mr Vincent Codrington

    You addressed the Minister of Disinformation with thus statement.

    “…I understand the pressure to get answers but you have to change tactics…”

    You note that every single week he comes with the same style

    1.A catchy title

    2.a comment from a blogger SEEMINGLY ASCRIBING THE BLOG TO ANOTHER FROM THE BU FAMILY.

    Generally it is a non controversial blogger

    3.Said comment MIGHT BE supplemented by something in a newspaper to emote responses

    4.Followed by his own vacuous comments

    And with that THEY ( The Blogmaster and his Boss) hope that the bloggers will give them the clue and Magic Bullet to solve their problems.

    But you Mr Vincent Codrington are proving to be a burr in their coat.

    Like Mr William Skinner and Wily E Coyote with your pointed observations that deflate their idiotic chants of GATHER ROUND THE FLAG!

    You going get ban soon heheheheh

  41. William Skinner Avatar

    @ Hal
    Mottley’s stint as education minister was not stellar by any standards. Edutech was a monumental failure.
    Jones was the same thing.


  42. @ William

    You mean like her stint as finance minister and president? She is world class and punches above her weight.

  43. NorthernObserver Avatar
    NorthernObserver

    ““At this point in time, this Government, and the last one [is] trying to make sure the National Insurance doesn’t pay out any money. Nobody in Barbados can tell me the National Insurance know how much money [it] got. I don’t believe the audited financial statements,” he [Sen Franklyn] declared, prompting Government Senator Jerome Walcott to ask that it be withdrawn since audited statements were presented to both the Upper and Lower Houses annually.[Quote Nation]

    Why were audited NIS statements presented to both Houses annually, and NOT to the public? Or are they confusing audited with internal?


  44. Risky business. black gold and white sands doan mix.

    ” The Ministry of Energy and Water Resources has issued effective offshore exploration licences for the Carlisle Bay and Bimshire blocks to BHP Petroleum.

    Minister of Energy and Water Resources, Wilfred Abrahams, stated: “While the Government of Barbados is aggressively pursuing renewable and alternative energy initiatives, it also recognises the importance of diversifying the island’s energy portfolio to include offshore oil and gas development.”

    https://www.nationnews.com/nationnews/news/243789/government-issues-oil-exploration-licences


  45. @ Hal

    I agree with you in that we need to rethink our entire plan and approach when it comes to our economy. The betting the house on tourism is a dangerous move. Those in the industry are already talking about soft bookings as a result of the UK and EU issue.


  46. @ Hal

    As far as Bert goes we both took criticism for being negative on BERT when the party claimed it would bring growth. We asked time and again for a clear growth plan to be implemented and all we were told is we were negative and anti government. Well 2 years later minister Straughn has come out and basically admitted that BERT has failed as a growth tool.

    I wait to See now what will be introduced that will bring growth. If what Straughn says is true and growth will take another 2 years, that will put us on the door of elections. What will be the plan then? Will the year of elections be a give away year then for all?

    I really am waiting to see where we go from here.

  47. NorthernObserver Avatar
    NorthernObserver

    @HA
    “Watch out for social tension”
    you better be careful, social tension/unrest is according to a former PM, what your archenemy Charles H, warned him about. It didn’t end well.

  48. NorthernObserver Avatar
    NorthernObserver

    @Blogmaster
    nice, apropos pic…Mia and BERT.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading