โ† Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

akanni
Akanni McDowall, President of the National Union of Public Workers

A Nazi era pastor, Martin Niemoller is credited with having said of the German authorities,

First they came for the Socialists, and I did not speak out – Because I was not a Socialist.

Then they came for the Trade Unionists, and I did not speak out – Because I was not a Trade Unionist.

Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out – Because I was not a Jew.

Then they came for me – and there was no one left to speak for me.

Now in Barbados, they have come for Akanni McDowall, President of the National Union of Public Workers and I won’t let history repeat itself. I am therefore forced to speak out because I am a trade unionist.

When I first heard the rumour of Akanni’s impending reversion to his substantive post, I called his head of department, who happens to be a good friend of mine, to ask what they were doing with Akanni. I warned my friend that it was a criminal offence, under section 40A of the Trade Union Act, to dismiss a workman or adversely affect his employment or alter his position to his prejudice because that workman engaged in trade union activity. Mind you, the penalty is only a small fine not exceeding $1,000 or a term of imprisonment not exceeding six months or both.

My friend insisted that my sources would have misled me since, as head of department, he would be required to write a report on Akanni’s performance before any action is taken and so far no one had even mentioned the topic.

After that interaction with my friend and now that Akanni has been reverted to his substantive post, I could be wrong but I am convinced of three things until the contrary is proven. Firstly, that my sources are unimpeachable; secondly, that his demise is as a direct result of his trade union activity; and thirdly, that his demotion was ordered from a very high level.

My understanding is that Mr. McDowall was acting continuously on a series of short term contracts for over two years in senior established posts. Further, his latest one was due to expire on October 31, 2016, however before its expiration, he was abruptly reverted. It would appear that they, whoever they are, couldn’t wait to take him out.

The original 2007 Public Service Act required the Public Service Commission to fill vacant posts within three months but they never met that standard. The Personnel Administration Division (PAD) argued that the period was too short and Government responded by amending the act in 2010 to extend the time to one year. Even with that extension, PAD continued to give workers successive three-month contracts some of which have been extended for years, despite the upper limit of one year that is mandated by the Recruitment and Employment Code.

The sinister thing about the authorities’ refusal to follow the law and make the appointments when due is that they revert officers, who are acting in higher posts, and terminate temporary officers without going through the disciplinary procedure. To my mind, their behaviour amounts to an abuse of power since temporary officers who are acting in established posts; and appointed officers, who are acting in higher posts, have the same rights as the substantive holders for the duration of the acting or temporary appointment in accordance with section 94 of the Constitution.

When I was growing up and suffered a stroke of bad luck, my grandmother would say that all things come together for good to those that love God. I thought that it was one of hers but subsequently found out that she was quoting the Bible. Therefore, I can only hope that some good can come of this martyrdom of a young trade union leader. The heavy handed action against him is nothing new. Countless other public workers have suffered similar fates. It is just that he is the most high profile victim to date. Maybe his celebrity might bring attention to the wide scale avoidance of proper procedures in the Public Service.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

109 responses to “The Caswell Franklyn Column – Akanni McDowall Kicked to the Kerb”

  1. Well Well & Consequences Avatar
    Well Well & Consequences

    They cannot seem to rise above the crab in the barrel mentality, dont care the level of education, a serious indictment on adults, how do they expect young adults and children who watch their every move to act…after all, they are supposed to be managing the country.

    None of them in the governmet departments seem to be good role models for the younger generations, they cannot seem to rise above themselves.


  2. You got to love Caswell Franklyn though because he talks about speaking out against the wrongdoing that is perpetrated against the common working man, which he has done here on BU for quite successfully for a number of years.

    But one sees a distinctive pattern in his discourse because although her pretends to champion the causes of the working man, his true vendetta is directed at DLP administration.

    So here is my pronouncement regarding Mr. Franklyn, I unequivocally and categorically prognosticate that if and when the BLP regain power, that Mr. Franklyn time here on BU would have been well spent, because he came to BU with a personal vendetta against the DLP, and not to advocate for the rights of the working man.


  3. Well Well

    So you’re in essence saying that Ronald Jones the Minister of Education and Human Resources Development, doesn’t stand as a good role model for the young people to emulate? Wasn’t Jones advocating for the rights of the young people earlier this year, when he challenged principals not forced parents to have to pay for their children graduation? Why wouldn’t Jones be the kind of role model a parent would want a son or daughter to emulate?

  4. Well Well & Consequences Avatar
    Well Well & Consequences

    Dompey…would you want Ronald Jones to be a role model for your children, young family members, especially your sons.

    It’s a simple question, a yes or no question…..a simple answer will do.


  5. In the meantime the streets of Barbados are being made clean while the trade Unionist continue to spread lies and propaganda about the govt efforts

    Put country first


  6. Well Well

    To answer your question yes! What is it in his character that makes him unfit to be a role model for my son or daughter?
    Listen! My Bible tells me that all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God. Now would you want Caswell Franklyn to be a role model for your grandchildren? And do you know enough of the man to determine whether or not he is a pedophile, or man of high morals and character?


  7. Some of you must be illiterate. Caswell composed an article about an issue which should concern any civic minded Barbadian but instead we have to observe this idiocy. This government will reap the whirlwind. All it has promised about transparency has come to nought. Is the former president of the NUPW still sitting on the NIS board is it? Is he still in his role at the NHC?


  8. David

    Several months ago Barbados Today wrote an article on the very man Caswell Franklyn is trying to defend because the majority of his union membership were dissatisfied with his performance.


  9. The pertinent question to be asked Caswell is what recourse does McDowall have if your position on the atter is accurate.

  10. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    David

    The yardfowl imbeciles are at it again. Their role is to divert attention away from issues that appear to be critical of the current administration. It would be much better if other commenters would simply ignore them, as I do.

  11. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    David

    The more important question is: What would NUPW do to defend its president? If they can’t take action to defend the president, then they should not be in business as a trade union. Remember BWU and the David Giles issue against the telephone company.

    The major problem is that NUPW is politically compromised and does not have the heart to fight the DLP. Another problem is that Akanni is a son who step out of the DLP household and the Dems are inflicting what they see as a suitable punishment. The DLP does not tolerate dissent.


  12. David

    I’ve been in an union for over three-decades now and I am cognizant of a union leaders who are genuinely concerned about the affairs of the membership, and those who are and have been there with ulterior motives and hidden agendas. And an imbecile can look at Caswell Franklyn discourse throughout the years and see that this man has a personal vendetta again the DLP administration coupled with his self-serving agenda.


  13. @Caswell

    That is a good question also. From a distance it appears Akanni has not always been on good terms with his management team. The signing of cheques comes to mind and the tension dealing with the matter at the airport.

  14. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    David

    I won’t be surprised if part of his team is not behind his ouster.


  15. Caswell Franklyn

    You have proven my point by asking the readership here on BU to ignore an opinion whether intelligible or unintelligible because it does not coincide with the prevailing orthodoxy. And you claim to be a man who defend the rights of the worker, but fall short of recognizing that those rights are intricately interlaced with the right of freedom of expression, and ideal upon on which our democratic system of governance has been erected.


  16. Caswell wrote a one sided article to make an argument without having all the facts, How then can Caswell be portrayed as being evenhanded , He says he goes to a friend for information , The information he received does not satisfy his perceptions so he takes pen to paper and writes an article derived from sheer speculation which reminds me of the ongoing feud in the american election and so called outside sources to influence
    Unless Caswell can document both sides providing detail information as to how the decision to revert was made he is liken to a blind man throwing darts at a bulls eye

    Now in the public interest an issue which has brought to table the govt efforts to Keep Barbados Clean, This was no secret as the Unions has stated! as memory serves to remember that MOF in his budgetary statement stated on the floor of Parliament that EVERY effort would be made to clean up Barbados! now such effort is being made the Unions have become agitators and bitter but who knows what alternative plans the Unions might have had to give such cause to such bitterness one is led to believe that govt decision was a testing of waters towards a bigger game plan , However i am lead to believe the the NUPW outrage might have given reason to a bigger game plan of their own one which was thwarted a plan which could have embarrassed govt during the 50th anniversary with another SSA strike
    There are many things govt have to be wise and concern taking no chances after seeing the force and level of actions Unions would take against the nations best interest to satisfy its membership
    Most notably the govt has the majority of Barbadians on its side with this new initiative to clean up Barbados in the meanwhile Mcdowall spins the political wheel across the length and breath of barbados looking for foot soldiers to do his dirty work which poll revealed would be few and far in between


  17. @Caswell

    Time will tell, time will tell.

    What is the status of the Buyers Club touted during the old dispensation?

    There is the bastardized saying, a membership will get the leadership it deserves.


  18. @ac, and who is the government putting first? Certainly not Barbados.

  19. HAMILTON A HILL Avatar

    When this story first broke the David Giles saga came straight to mind. I remember when a manager sought to make an example of yours truly, a young and enthusiastic Shop Steward and the late Billy Straughn made it clear to that institution that in the eyes of the union it matched and merited the same response the police make to a crime against a police officer.
    I kept waiting to hear of a plan of action from the NUPW, instead all I heard was how please it was with the direction the talks with GAIA were going. The Freundel Stuart administration does not expect to be returned to office, and are driven to accomplish whatever they deem important to them, without regard for what is said about them. There needs to be a sit down between every trade union in Barbados. That is the first step at exposing the George Street yard fowls embedded within the movement. Restoration of confidence in Trade Unionism must be made a priority. The erosion of progress made over the years needs to be halted immediately. That progress must no longer be traded for duty free concessions.

  20. Jeff Cumberbatch Avatar
    Jeff Cumberbatch

    International Labour Law regards it as A Very Bad Thing to interfere with the working conditions of workers’ organizations. I suppose the argument would be that Mc Dowell has not been demoted but has merely been returned to his substantive post. The burden of proving anti-union discrimination would then be on him and the NUPW.

    -Can an employer fire a workerโ€™s representative?

    “A worker cannot be fired for his or her trade union or worker representative activities carried out in accordance with the law or in conformity with collective agreements or other jointly agreed arrangements. However a workerโ€™s representative may be fired on other grounds, where justified, provided procedural safeguards are in place to protect against wrongful dismissal based on trade union activities. In some countries, it is necessary to get permission from the labour ministry before dismissing union leaders or candidates for union leadership”.


  21. Heather October 23, 2016 at 8:15 AM #

    @ac, and who is the government putting first? Certainly not Barbados.

    steupse


  22. A nice to now the status of Dereck Alleyne. Is he still on secondment to Urban and if yes why?


  23. The NUPW is a spent force.
    It has suffered the folly of too many political lackies who were in position of authority because they wanted to serve themselves firstly, and their political parties secondly…
    That the numerous members sat back and allowed this to continue speaks to the QUALITY of the membership – and as we all must now know, the membership gets what the membership deserves….
    Once Government is able to vindictively embarrass the president like this, then the Union could as well close shop.
    In a REAL union, not even a lowly assistant shop steward could be treated like that without SERIOUS NATIONAL repercussions…. far less a president.

    But then again, the NUPW is just a microcosm of Barbados …. with such a large majority of people of the mental capacity of Dompey and AC, (who are so idiotic that they could not see the point on a pencil) that the jackasses in charge can do anything they wish…


  24. On a peripheral note can Caswell whisper to his friend at NCC (Keith Neblett) that plausible deniability does not cut it.

    Ref: Sunday Sun p.13A


  25. Bush S hit. You have the solution/s to every dam thing .why dont you take time out of your comfort zone and solve or repair all damages. At this point your are sounding like the bombastic egostitical dunderhead running for the president of USA long on bombas and lacking in solutions. The only difference between you and him is that he had the balls to test the waters while you sit with you tail stuck between both legs talking sh.it

    #old gas bag.

  26. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    David

    Neblett seems not to know much. You remember that he was in a similar position when it came to changed the list of persons who were sent home by NCC.

    Sent from my iPad


  27. Bush Tea

    Yap I got it Bushie, i mean wat you tryin tah sah, dah de hole of de BU household is smarter dan de rest aa Barbados because dem don’t listen tah wunna.

    Bush Tea, the entire lot here on BU, have failed miserably in its endeavour to aroused the collective conscience of the Barbadian people and rally them to stand up and fight against the improprieties of the ruling government. And when yall failed to accomplished this objective, yall pulled a Donald Trump, by turning around and denigrated the collective intellect of the Barbadian people.


  28. Dompey October 23, 2016 at 6:52 AM #
    “Several months ago Barbados Today wrote an article on the very man Caswell Franklyn is trying to defend because the majority of his union membership were dissatisfied with his performance.”

    So if it really was a fact that a majority were “dissatisfied with his performance” why wasn’t he removed?


  29. @Nostradamus

    To assist in dispelling nonsense not only did he win, he won going away to use a horse racing analogy.

    http://www.loopnewsbarbados.com/content/nupw-staying-akanni-mcdowall


  30. The trade union should make up any loss of wages.


  31. Nostradamus

    Go to the Barbados Today blog and ask my good friend Wade Gibbons the journalists why because he might have written the piece.


  32. Wade Gibbons is the Sports Editor.


  33. Hal Austin

    The some unions do it in this part of the world, and it is called the Rainy Day Fund. And this fund is also distributed to members who actively picket on the strike line for an extended period of time.


  34. After a second try he won. But so far Mcdowall only influence has been those driven through political lenses. He has yet to stand on those grievances that has merited overall popular opinion.
    Again on the issue of the SSA he used perrogative jestures absence of truth to whip up unwarranted frenzy to cause division and confusing.


  35. Not in this part of the world though. We do not wish to assume any risks for our convictions. We expect the employer to pay whether we work or strike.


  36. Trying to understand the practice in Bim, if you are a Trade Union leader do you still work in your substantive position? If the answer is the affirmative I can see where Govโ€™t might have an issue with a leader occupying a sensitive post.

    My nickels worth.


  37. I recall Donville Inniss calling Brasstacks and making some caustic observations of what he thought McDowell should be doing during working hours,the tenor of his message being that the man should get off the radio and for once go and do the work for which he is paid in the ministry of health,instead of wasting time on union matters.
    One is therefore not surprised that the mantra…….The lord giveth and the lord taketh away…. is still the rule of thumb of this PM.
    The gloves are off but going forward,the man must protect his ass from the quislings of the DLP.


  38. David

    I know the brother is into sports. I was just kidding, but an article was written regarding the ousted of this young man.


  39. Sergeant

    In this part of the world and I am quite sure you are acquainted with the title union president rather than union leader? And I know of no such person occupying such a position being actively employed in the private or governmental sector, and I have been in the union some three decades.


  40. The President holds a post in government Cedric Murrell, Maloney, McDowall etc.

  41. Jeff Cumberbatch Avatar
    Jeff Cumberbatch

    It is the General Secretary who traditionally occupies a full-time Union position.


  42. Caswell Franklyn

    Your members pay union dues every week, biweekly or monthly, so you can use of of those dues to establish a fund for striking workers who have been on the picket line for a minute.


  43. The General Secretary is probably the union president here and union leader is probably the foot soldier the union delegate here.


  44. “Dompey

    Do us a favour, shut the hell up, read and learn.


  45. “The trade union should make up any loss of wages.”
    ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
    This would be the most cowardly and idiotic approach to be taken by the union, but at the same time, it is the most plausible …for brass bowls.

    The whole philosophical purpose of an organisation like a union should be to stand up for RIGHT ….. and to fight against SHIITE.

    What the union SHOULD do, is give the government one week to reinstate the man to the previous acting position, …failing which, various government agencies would begin strike action ….with a new agency joining every day.
    SIMPLE … this is how one deals with SHIITE.
    Making up the loss to McDowel would be like wiping the DLP’s ass with your handkerchief.

    When a set of people lose focus on righteousness, then all kinds of folly creep into their agenda, and when we have ‘intellects’ of the order of AC and Dompey in leadership positions, it is no point bringing logic and reason to the table …. no one reasons with a donkey – it takes a whip to his ass to get results.


  46. David

    There isn’t anything a small island like Barbados can teach a man who lives internationally, and I am not trying to be disrespectful. David, you need to get your hands on Mark Twain’s quote: ” Travel is fatal to prejudice, bigotry and narrow mindedness…!”


  47. Bush Tea

    Your disasterous suggestion would break the back of union because what if the government replace striking workers with the thousands that have already been layoff. I have seen it happened in the 1990s, where the union called a strike and the governor brought in workers from neighboringt states to take the place of striking workers and the strike lasted about five months, and almost break back of the union because the governor was determining not to giving to union demands. Plus his strategy was to break the back of union by holding out as long as possible.


  48. Btw word on the ground is that in the matter of the Pension Rights for clergy of the Anglican Church, Chancellor Leacock and Bishop Holder were handed a defeat in the High Court last week.


  49. Bush Tea

    So you think that the government is as dumb as you not to put contingency plans in place, in view of an impending strike?


  50. David

    Listen and learn from a man who had been on the picket line for more than five months and who watched many of his coworkers being hauled off to jail because their resorted to violence because of the governor’s reluctance to give to union demands. And many my my coworkers during the 1990s, lose they homes, apartments, cars, and hope because of the governor’s determination to break the back of union. So union President Jerry Brown at the time brought in Jess Jackson to speak on the union behaft, and unfortunately, Jackson national acclaim did little to sway an ever determining governor.

The blogmaster invites you to join and add value to the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading