โ† Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Newly Appointed Chief Justice Marston Gibson

On August 14, 2010, BU broke the story that our late Prime Minister David Thompson, after consultation with the Attorney General, Freundel Stuart, the present Prime Minister, and with the then Leader of the Opposition, Mia Mottley Q.C., had made the decision to appoint internationally acclaimed Bajan jurist, Marston Gibson, as Barbadosโ€™ new Chief Justice.

In making this appointment from outside the inner ring, the word of the late Prime Minister to Bajans has been kept from beyond the grave. The reason for reaching outside the ring has been fully discussed in this forum. A ring infested by incestuous relationships shaped by lodge and other fraternity ties. The course of events that followed are well known.

Many believe His Lordship should have been allowed to assume the CJ position without the hassle he has had to endure.ย  The Government, out of abundance of caution because it wanted to ensure that no nuisance legal challenges to the appointment could be made, amended the Supreme Court of Judicature Act to use the words โ€œcommon lawโ€ instead of โ€œCommonwealth”. Therefore any politically motivated time-wasting legal challenges to the appointment of an undoubted and eminently qualified son of our soil was effectively thwarted. A son of our soil who, as can be easily ascertained from the Internet, has never forgotten his roots and whose unrelenting promotion of Barbados is well documented.

Now, almost a year after it broke this story, BU is able to formally welcome Chief Justice Gibson back to the land where is navel string is buried to share with us his scholarship, energy and experience and to deliver back to Barbadians a justice system which has lost its way. Chief Justice Gibson inherits a comatose legal system that he must now raise from the dead. It is an gargantuan task, but one in which we are optimistic he will rise to the challenge.

To His Lordship the Chief Justice we say:

Dear Chief Justice,

Our most hearty and heartfelt welcome HOME!

You have a tremendous task before you and BU urge all Bajans to give you their unswerving support and a hearty welcome home. We realise the enormity of your task and we are encouraged by the number of senior counsel who have expressed their willingness to afford you their best efforts to accomplish this.

In this day and age of transparency through the social media, we offer, without really expecting you to do so, the forum to share your views with Bajans and residents of Barbados and Bajans around the World, as well as those who may have an interest in the justice system of Barbados.

We do not promise to always agree with you and you will see that our family have robust and outspoken opinions, but we have every confidence in your good-will, ability and determination.

Once again, welcome home, melud!

To the Prime Minister, our late Prime Minister Thompson, Miss Mia Mottley Q.C., and the Government of Barbados, we say well done! Pity it took a year, but better late than never.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


  1. Good luck to him.

    What do you reckon his three biggest challenges (or his three most urgent priorities) will be when he takes up the post, David?


  2. @vanhimist

    Good question and depending on who you talk to it will vary.

    There is the impossible backlog of case files which have to be addressed and a system to process efficiently going forward.

    Some bench strengthening is required.

    He will have to work with partners in government to address an inefficient Court Registry

    The list is long!


  3. Your article demonstrates a very mature, nationalistic approach to the filling of the appointment to one of our most important constitutional offices, in stark contrast to the attitude expressed on the other blog. A warm welcome to our Chief Justice; may he perform the duties of that high office with dignity, honour and JUSTICE. Welcome home your Lordship.


  4. Think the correct title is Welcome to The Honourable Mr Justice Marston Gibson Chief Justice of Barbados


  5. Another issue which can easily occupy His Lordship is the need for a properly constituted family court. Our system of justice must be configured to respond to the needs of our society.


  6. I just hope that Mr. Gibson has a mind of his own, he does what he believes is correct and do NOT be persuaded to keep business as usual, side tracked from his views or be caught up in the political wrangle that has been chocking us.

    I hope that in a few months to come we as Barbadians would have seen some form of change in our judicial system which is longggggggggg overdue.


  7. I exhort you to keep the discussion of this appointment at the level here set and eschew every attempt to allow partisan discussion to sully the importance of this high office. Your stated suggestion is very objective and certainly worthy of some consideration. A visit to the High Court on a Family Law day will certainly give support to your suggestion.


  8. @David: “Another issue which can easily occupy His Lordship is the need for a properly constituted family court. Our system of justice must be configured to respond to the needs of our society.

    Might you elaborate?

    Be clearer?

    Say what you mean?

    Just wondering…. (LOL)


  9. As the BU family welcomes the new CJ,my hope is that the ‘Bar’ will in fact be raised in more ways than one.His Lordship I am sure has his ear to the ground and his knowledge of the culture of the land of his birth both political and other is vast.Without knocking the former CJ, I hope it shall be a new dawn for Barbados.This choice is deep and lest we all forget it is a good time for all to dwell together in unity. Behold how good it is!


  10. Like a gust of fresh air, we welcome the new C.J, while I wish him well the rush to change the law to benefit his appointment, then the delay in announcing the appointment must leave some lingering doubts in many people’s minds. However i wish him a good stay in Barbados and he has much pressure on him to deliver.


  11. @ Guest | August 18, 2011 at 7:56 PM |
    “I just hope that Mr. Gibson has a mind of his own, … do NOT be persuaded to keep business as usual,

    @ Raymond | August 18, 2011 at 8:53 PM |
    “As the BU family welcomes the new CJ,my hope is that the โ€˜Barโ€™ will in fact be raised in more ways than one..”

    You idiots! A dubious offer was made to a man who otherwise would be considered honorable had he refused! This job could so easily have been offered to any other practicing member of the legal fraternity in the entire Commonwealth with equal relevance. Why him? Raise the bar my ass …


  12. Welcome indeed, My Lord. About time too. I am very pleased.

    @BAFBFP. โ€œRaise the bar my ass โ€ฆโ€. Since your comment always seem to come from your ass……


  13. had the law been changed before the appointment, then congratulations would have been in order for tose mentioned but not on hindsight to coreect govvt’ and the former leader of the opposition incompetence in exercising due diligence in such an important matter.any how, i wish the new chief justice good luck.


  14. The gentleman has been appointed, let us think blue yellow and support the man!


  15. Amused

    Dear dear, you could have said that my comments always seem to come from my Amused … Now that would really hurt!

    The man should have said NO, thank you very much, but NO. Davis Simmonds should have done the same. Bars are raised by men who understand this, not by people who can become Rhode Scholars… You like too many others, are too easily impressed!


  16. David;

    I cannot support a Blue Yellow when the Black thought it necessary to expose itself to severe and relevant criticism, disruption and in the process create doubt around its own competence in foreseeing consequences to actions. Any man that means that much to a political party should be scorned or at the very least, viewed with suspicion!


  17. @BAFPF. Surely it is the function of government to appoint the best person for the job, which I firmly believe it has done. If you have to fight for that person against pointless and frivolous political posturing, then you fight in the interest of the country. I also firmly believe that the objections to Mr Gibsonโ€™s appointment pre-amendment of the Supreme Court Act were nothing more than political posturings. Mr Gibson has held a license to practice law in Barbados for over 20 years and as such he met the criteria of the Act in the first place, in my view. All government has done is to pre-empt and remove the possibility of mindless legal action that would delay the resurrection of the justice system which would, in its turn, be detrimental to the country, not only from the point of view of the timely delivery of justice, but from the point of view of our off-shore investment sector, which has also been sadly affected by the moribund and inefficient justice system. The government and Mr Gibson deserve a hearty “well done”.

    But, of course, having read your views on the way government should operate in the past, I can hardly expect you to agree. If you did, God forbid, the day might actually come when you might be able to persuade the electorate that you have what it takes to let you run the country.


  18. Amused
    Let’s say you gained a driver’s licence in Barbados in the 80’s or 90’s but went to live in the USA where you drive on the other side of the road, would it be O.K to appoint you as chief licensing instructor in Barbados, just because you kept renewing your licence?
    The appointment was not right but it has happened already, all that is left to do is wish the gentleman a good stay in office but I can’t hail his appointment.


  19. Amused
    Just for the record, let me qalso state that the appointment of David Simmonds was also WRONG


  20. Welcome home to Chief Justice Gibson. His academic, scholarly and professional achievements serve as an inspiration to all young Barbadian lawyers and the young people of this nation.


  21. Amused

    I shudder to say that I completely agree with Scout…! Completely. Who the hell are you to be taken as an authority on who is the Best person for any position..? The man should have said NO full stop. Then and only then would it have been made clear that he would have been in line as a candidate for the “best” accolade.

    BTW, members of the Jack Ass community have been fooling with Bajan sentiments on their worth as effective leaders ’bout hey fah years. I can state with confidence that I could do better than them at making proper decisions with both eyes shut. The problem is of course that over the years the public has taken a shine to these Jack Asses … with respect.


  22. @BAFBFP
    If shit had wings your ass would be an airport! How’s that for an idiot! Keep your shirt on!!!!!


  23. Raymond;

    Who needs wings when just painting your name on anything will do just fine …!


  24. […] different takes on the appointment of Barbados' new Chief Justice, here and here. […]


  25. @Scout. I respect your honest opinion. However, I disagree with it. Also the driving license simile is not applicable on this occasion. Until the advent of the CCJ, Barbados’ final court of appeal was the Privy Council where English lord justices sat “in right of Barbados” and delivered judgments based on Barbados, not English, law. This did not prevent other countries whose laws are similar to Barbados law (like Canada) adopting these precedents. Indeed, many lawyers practicing in Barbados hold licenses to practice (and do sometimes practice) in other jurisdictions. Sometimes in Barbados courts, legal precedents from many common law jurisdictions are cited as authorities, including those, not only from Canadian federal courts, but from Canadian provincial courts – and from Australia and New Zealand and from the USA etc. I would point out that Canada and the USA drive on the wrong side of the road. So, with respect, your simile is very over-simplistic and I, respectfully, completely disagree with you.

    I notice with great amusement that a certain other blog, while originally acclaiming the stated intention of our dear late Prime Minister to appoint a CJ from outside the box, have, for reasons that only they know, now chosen to reverse themselves and decry that appointment of Chief Justice Gibson. My guess is that they are vexed as s**** because BU broke this story before anyone else and we all watched as the so-called press galloped to catch up with what is a major story. Also, if on a sunny day BU says it is a sunny day, they would try to tell you it is night.

    Bottom line. We have a new Chief Justice and he is Bajan and a great credit to the country of his birth and a sterling example to its young people as to what they can achieve, not only in Barbados, but in the international community. I intend to give him full support and encouragement to work to the benefit of Barbados and its justice system.


  26. […] different takes on the appointment of Barbados' new Chief Justice, here and […]


  27. Pity, I truly wished that the new Chief Justice would have been chosen from New Zealand or Zimbabwe, anywhere else but the Caribbean.


  28. @BAFBFP: “Pity, I truly wished that the new Chief Justice would have been chosen from New Zealand or Zimbabwe, anywhere else but the Caribbean.

    Why?


  29. No obvious ties Chris, know what I mean …?


  30. @BAFBFP: “No obvious ties Chris, know what I mean โ€ฆ?

    That is an assumption.

    And, as we know what happens when one assumes….

    It makes an ASS out of U and Me.


  31. Assumption based on likelihood … Good enough for me


  32. Amused
    The fact that the Barbados Government had to tinker with the law to appoint this gentleman, is enough reason why I am not quite satisfied with his appointment. Yes, we used the Privy Council before but our legislation is based on the British model, so the LAW will be the same, not so for the USA model; that’s what I meant by driving on the other side of the road. However, the gentleman is FINALLY appointed and I hope he lives up to his bidding. I hope I don’t hear some of you criticising him in the future.


  33. “We have a new Chief Justice and he is Bajan and a great credit to the country of his birth and a sterling example to its young people”

    Excellent!


  34. Hants
    I’m proud to know we have a bajan C.J, a product of the working class, it is the manner in which the appointment was made that bothers me. Why did the government have to bring a resolution at 10 p.m and rush it through parliament by after midnight almost four months ago, then for the final appointment to be delayed so long? This throws a shadow of doubt over what should have been a proud occasion. I always though it would have been better if the gentleman was appointed as a judge for a period of six to twelve months and then elevated to C.J but to throw him in at the deep end of the pool with a dark shadow over his head, is putting him under unnecessary pressure.


  35. Scout this is as simple as taking food from a baby.

    IF THE MAN WAS TRULY HONORABLE HE WOULD HAVE REFUSED THE OFFER …dwd


  36. BAFBFP
    My belief is, he was pressure by the government to accept the position for them to save face. I hope he does not regret his decision.


  37. Scout

    If you must be the boy scout, so be it …!


  38. @The Scout,

    Everytime I see a black Bajan rise to prominence I am pleased.
    Perhaps I suffer from the guilt of being a red Bajan underacheiver who has benefitted from the lightness of my skin.

    The one thing that upsets me about Bajans is that they will find any means necessary to tarnish a Black Bajan but willingly and wholeheartedly accept white underachievers as long as they have money.

    I hope Gibsons kicks ass (canadian lingo) and improve the somnambulent judicial system in Barbados.

    And I hope he is street smart enough to never write one shiite on any blog.

    Somebody should give him a cd of the late Carew’s song Snakes.


  39. Hants

    I truly hope that you were not in any war referring to me …


  40. @BAFBFP “I truly hope that you were not in any war (WAY) referring to me”

    No. Those to whom I am referring know who they are.


  41. AMUSED- was mr gibson the first bajan chief justice of barbados and if not were not all the other bajan chief justices credits to the country of their birth and sterling examples to bajan young children to what they can achieve. how condescending can we be- what the children might very take to heart is the doublestandards employed to appoint the chief justice and very well query if there is one set of standards for the medes and another for the persians.


  42. @balance. Just where do you see me say that the other CJs were not credits to their country? I have a serious problem with one of them, but that arises out of what I percieve as political opportunism. So on just what basis do you arrive at my having said that these CJs were not credits to their country? Douglas ran tight ship and so did Williams. Justice was timely in its delivery. I have no quarrel with that. As Gibson has distinguished himself as both law professor and jurist, the last in a far more competative and far larger forum than Barbados, he is a shining example to the Bajan youth of today. You might also note that the present US Attorney General Holder is of Bajan descent. He too is a shining example. I would be interested to know if, after serving as AG of the USA you would object to him claiming Bajan citizenship through ancestry and being appointed CJ or even preseident of the CCJ. I suppose it is all a matter of perception and I am a patriot who believes that you can take the Bajan out of Barbados, but you can NEVER take Barbados out of the Bajan. In fact, it takes generations of absence from Barbados to do that.


  43. Is it that our new C.J is being proclaimed as some-one special because he held high office in the USA? Are we still looking up to these countries as superior to us? To me Barbados is numero uno in the world, I think places like the USA and britain should thank Barbados for the many high level individuals we have produced to assist them in strtegic postions.


  44. @Scout. I have no argument with that. We have produced some wonderful people who have assisted Britain and the USA. So, the problem seems to be the perception that, having once supplied them, we ought not to take them back? Which is nonsense.


  45. BAFBFP
    I’ve tried to be as honest as possible in my blogs and life in general. This has caused me to be labelled a BLP supporter sometimes, a DLP supporter sometimes, even a racist sometimes, NONE of these comments really distrub me, one thing for sure, I’m honest to myself, and true to myself in anything I do or say. I’ll always be me, I’ve seen many individuals who belong to the PIP ( party in power) for personal gain, I belong to the NDP ( no dam party) so that I can say it as I see it without fear


  46. Scout I am not accusing you of being honest;overly optimistic maybe, but far too forgiving in this case. The man should have said NO. David Simmonds should have said NO. Frankly I wished that the present Chief of Police should have said NO as well, along with a good few others …


  47. Amused
    I have no problem with the new C.J, from listening to the budgetary debate I am convinced we need some more Gibsons to avail themselves to save Barbados from this crisis. My only problem with the appointment of the new C.J is the manner in which it was done, but then everything in Barbados seem to carry a political slant. We need to mature ourselves above this, we’re practising 19th cent politics in the 21st cent, we need to wake up and get with it.


  48. BAFBFP
    Agreed, it is this level of dishonesty and partisan politics that is stopping this country from maturing or even progressing. We follow a lot of American politics but representative for varied parties vote against their own party sometimes but still remain loyal to the party. I this country an MP dare not go against the party unless he’s ready to sign his/her political death warrant; this is immaturity. I remember Eric Williams insist that all his MP’s write their undated resignations and give to him, he will fill in the date if or when necessary. This is like bringing an illegal person to Barbados, holding their passport and pay little wages.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading