Sir Neville Nicholls – Chairman of the FTC and SEC

(6) The Commission (FTC) may on its own initiative or on the request of any person carry out any investigation that it considers necessary or desirable in connection with matters falling within the provisions of this Act, the Utilities Regulation Act, and any laws relating to consumer protection and fair competition which the Commission has jurisdiction to administerFair Trading Commission Act

When the Fair Trading Commission (FTC) was established in 2001 so much was promised by the previous government of the leadership it was expected to exert on  how Utilities  were regulated in Barbados. For many years before that it had been the public’s perception that Utilities operated to the beat of their own drums. Since the establishment of the FTC in  2001 nothing has changed to reshape that perception. The Utility which has attracted the greatest ire from Barbadians has been LIME formerly Cable and Wireless. Perhaps what has stung Barbadians the most is the fact jobs have been relocated to St. Lucia and other low cost based islands. This is after decades of Barbados being the cash-cow for Cables & Wireless in the hemisphere. Even if Barbadians were persuaded to finally accept LIME’s, formerly Cable & Wireless restructure, the promise of enhanced customer service as a result of the changes has been elusive.

Barbados Today carried a funny piece last week which poked some fun at the online customer support which kept advising users to visit LIME’s Windsor Lodge Office to seek resolution.


Barbadians are still pissed at LIME’s decision to sever employees at the beginning of the global recession. A great betrayal to the tripartite/social partnership and Prime Minister David Thompson’s request to hold strain. Yes LIME had no regulatory obligation to be sensitive to the request of the Prime Minister or the social partnership but was there the hint of a moral obligation?

The great disappointment to date has been the lack of a proactive stance by the FTC on behalf of Barbadian consumers. Is it correct to say that all of the times the Utilities have approached the FTC they have walked away with close to what they applied for? Have you sensed the same diligence coming from the FTC regarding measures to protect Barbadian consumers?

Of interest to BU has been the action of Ofcom in the United Kingdom; the independent regulator and competition authority for the UK communications industries.  Ofcom unlike its counterpart in Barbados proactively undertook a market survey to determine the average residential broadband speed. In Barbados we have heard many complaints from consumers about sluggish upload/download ADSL speeds. The current system makes it very difficult if not tedious for consumers to build a good case against LIME to prove  poor ADSL service. What we know is a lot of the copper network in Barbados is old plant and must* be contributing to degradation of broadband service in Barbados. The Barbadian telecommunication consumer needs help from an entity with the clout and resources to scope the problem in Barbados and insist on corrective action by LIME. The FTC needs to get up off their lazy overpaid asses and protect LIME consumers. A visit to Ofcom to eyeball what they have been doing is in order if the FTC is ignorant about next steps.

Sir Neville for godsake do something to help consumers!

In an attempt to improve how broadband is sold, Ofcom has been pushing ISPs to adopt a new code of practice, which will mean consumers get more information about speed as they sign up for a new provider. The code is due to come in over the next 12 months and all the UK’s larger ISPs have signed up for it.

Few Britons get the broadband speeds being advertised suggests research. It will mean that, instead of being given a single figure, consumers will get an idea of the range of speeds their line can support. This will be provided as a “durable record” so there can be no dispute if reaching an estimated speed proves elusive.

BU has always been wary of the MOU arrangement between then C&W and the government which occurred at the onset of telecommunications deregulation in Barbados. There was a good relationship which many Barbadians know existed between former C&W CEO Trevor Clarke, COO Vince Yearwood and Human Resource Manager John Williams. Was there a backroom deal?

Facebook users should feel free to subscribe to the LIMES SUCKS page to record their concerns. There is always strength in numbers.

If telecommunications can agree to Codes of Practice in the UK and other markets why not Barbados.

59 responses to “Clarity Needed In Broadband Speed Sold By LIME In Barbados”


  1. @David
    “Must confess Telebarbados has been a big disappointment.”

    AGREED!


  2. @Chris

    Who would normally be responsible for supporting the co-ax video delivery infrastructure?


  3. @David: “Who would normally be responsible for supporting the co-ax video delivery infrastructure?

    I feel like I’m under cross-examination. (That’s a joke — please bring it on…)

    Normally the wired video delivery (normally occupying the third pole position) is controlled by the local Television Provider. In the case in Bim, CBC.

    Please do note that I was able to get BL&P to admit during the Rate Hearing that CBC (and others) had requested access to BL&P’s pole network’s third position before TBB became operational….


  4. @Chris

    See the following statements for comment:

    Given the ‘interest’ which BL&P has in TeleBarbados would it be correct to opine that true competition is being denied? Isn’t there a role the FTC here?

    Can you confirm if the recent transaction by the BL&P parent has not changed the ownership by BL&P parent in TeleBarbados? If it has would this not change the business outlook by BL&P to treating with others by not remaining loyal to TeleBarbados?

    Finally if it is CBC was able to procure an arrangement with TeleBarbados to stream MCTV to compete with the E in LIME what would be your comment?


  5. See comment received via email:

    Can LIME explain why it’s advertisement for its AllTalk Plus offer does not explain to customers that there’s more in the mortar than the pestle.

    Check last Sunday Sun’s page 2 and you will see the advertisement telling you that it’s the “same price but more stuff” and breaking down what you get for how much money if you are a prepaid or postpaid customer.

    What it does not tell you, which is especially misleading for potential customers who are attracted by the offer, is that if you sign up for AllTalk Plus all the talking you can do is only with other LIME customers’. So whoever thinks that you will enjoy the plus of being able to talk to friends on Digicel at the cheap rates quoted, that ain’t happening.

    As a result, I want to suggest to LIME that they include this pertinent information in their advertisement so that other persons won’t be misled like I was until somebody alerted me to the hole i was about to fall into.


  6. The point about the role of OFCOM in requiring ISPs to indicate speed and quality of service to help consumers is noteworthy. I have suggested in the past that we need a pro active regulator. An area of personal research right now is whether the FTC erred in its decision on termination rates which may have the consequence of keeping mobile rates higher than they could be. But I would argue that under Sir Neville there has been a shift in how the Commission undertakes some roles and its decision on electricity rates certainly raised concerns for now and the future. I still find it somewhat hilarious that the electricity company could have presented a perfect case for its depreciation rates. When a regulator can find absolutely nothing wrong it raises serious question marks, either about its capability or professional intent.


  7. Recently LIME has been running ads urging people to lock down their wireless as a cure for the slow speeds they might be experiencing.

    Those customers should be aware that other customers who
    had secured their wireless routers from day one, and those who currently only have wired access, are experiencing the same slow speeds.

    Do not expect any real increases in speed after you “lock it down”.

    IMHO, LIME is only trying to get more people to sign up for service forcing existing customers to upgrade to escape the congestion of the lower packages.

    LIME can keep their 8MB package, I tired now.
    I ain’t playing that xhit no more.


  8. What is the role of the Commission and are they fulfilling their role. Surely this can be measured. This formation of Commissions through out the regions should be noted. In wihch country has the commission worked.


  9. LIME’s biggest problem is that they simply do not have the bandwidth available to share among it’s current subscriber base. When they first introduced ADSL their customers actually got what they were paying for. Now, the network is so congested that everyone has to fight for a piece, and this problem is especially bad in heavily populated areas where one or two fibre links have to serve a single exchange from which thousands of phone lines are served. To their defense however, they have been constantly upgrading and installing mini exchanges all over the island to circumvent this problem, but it’s not enough. And what’s more is that they’ve increased contention ratio which only compounds the problem. I’m speaking subject to correction here but the last I heard is that it’s set at 50:1, which means that if you’re paying for 8Mb/s, then you have to share that between 8Mb/s of bandwidth with 49 other users… I don’t know about you, but that’s unacceptable considering the rates that they’re charging when we see what they’re offering in other islands like Grenada. If they charge the same rates here that do in Grenada, then an 8Mb/s connection would be $120.66 BDS Incl VAT! A 2Mb/s connection would be $59.90 BDS incl VAT!

    Haven’t you ever noticed that the internet is slower during the day (business hours) than it is at night?

    I can’t wait for Digicel to start offering their WiMax service for residential use…

    Nuff said!

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading