The following blogs authored by a young Barbadian Economist Simon Naitram who is currently an assistant lecturer at the University of the West Indies while pursuing a PhD from the University of Glasgow (featured image: Simon Naitram)

  • David, Barbados Underground

Life, debt, and now default. Barbados has reached the final stage of its illness. This isn’t our sob story. This is the tale of how we got here. This post isn’t a eulogy—it’s a lesson, a warning to our future selves.

The reason the government has defaulted on the country’s public debt is simple: the government just doesn’t have enough money to both keep paying back its loans and keep the country’s services running. The government chose to keep the country running.

How did the government reach this breaking point? Did the government simply borrow more than it could repay? The economics of government debt aren’t that simple. The government might have borrowed too much—it certainly made some bad financial decisions—but that’s not the real economic story.

The underlying economic mistake leading to default is that our government did not invest. It’s not that we spent too much money. Instead it’s that we spent our money on the wrong things. For a decade we did not invest in a brighter future. Nodebtw that we’ve reached that future, it’s a dark and miserable place.

A government’s debt is measured relative to how rich its people are. Bill Gates borrowing a million dollars isn’t the same as me borrowing a million dollars. The richer we the people are, the more money the government gets from taxing us. A 20% tax on $100 gives the government way more revenue than a 20% tax on $20.

Read full textLife, Debt, and Default


Barbados’ giant economic hole is entirely of our own making. Our distress stems from one fatal flaw: we do not invest.

Let me make it plain. Investment in new businesses, new technologies, and new ideas is the only way to generate sustainable economic growth. Economic growth is not just an economist’s foolish cravings. Economic growth is the only path to prosperity. Investment is needed for economic growth, and without economic growth, we perish.

Why is it that we don’t invest? What can we do to fix this fatal flaw?

The first problem is that we save only 13.6% of our income. The rest of the world saves 23.1% of its income. Our savings are paltry in comparison to the investment hole we need to fill. We simply don’t put aside enough money for our businesses to invest.

And yet, commercial banks don’t want our cash. They offer us a ridiculous 0.05% interest rate on our savings. Why? In 1990, the banks lent 68% of our savings to businesses. Lending to businesses is risky, but it is productive investment that generates high returns and grows the economy. In 2018, the banks have lent only 28% of our savings to businesses! Banks have stopped channeling our funds into productive economic activity—which is in fact their one job.

Read full textFailure to Invest

339 responses to “Fault Lines: Life, Debt, Default and a Failure to Invest”


  1. PLT
    YOU ARE WASTING YOUR TIME TRYING TO CAST YOUR PEARLS OF WISDOM TO THE SWINE AND BU ILLITERATI
    GIVE IT UP MAN


  2. LET THE BU ILLITERATI BURY THEIR DEAD…………AS IS COMING SOON

  3. peterlawrencethompson Avatar
    peterlawrencethompson

    Hal Austin November 24, 2018 2:34 PM
    Anyone cal look up the statistics Hal. What was the buying power of Bajans in 1966, in 1976, in 1996, in 2006? The answer is growth in buying power and prosperity. The numbers do not lie. Then take a look at the last decade. Those numbers do not lie either.

    Your statement that “Barbados has underperformed the global and regional economies since November 30, 1966” is a complete falsehood. Show us the numbers.


  4. @PLT,
    Clearly you do not know what you are talking about. You appear not to have even read Economics 101. Had you been a sixth former writing this nonsense I would seriously discuss your future on the course.


  5. Are these “idiots” of EVERY colour?

  6. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ PLT at 2:05 PM

    Quite true . Major infrastructural investments were implemented by Go B. But since they were financed by Loan Capital rather than Primary Surpluses the repayments of debts and interests on loans need to be paid. Were adequate user fees collected? Were the taxes for usage collected? Were these infrastructural investments yielding revenues to cover maintenance? My conclusion is very poor post project financial management. The Business Plans that ensured the Loans were not monitored/ managed post project. We are good project managers but poor business managers.
    There is also a limit to Economic growth and employment by building real estate. I fear that we may have reached that plateau. We cannot depend on construction to provide jobs indefinitely. We will run out of land space. Of course maintenance should absorb these. But do we maintain roads and buildings?


  7. @Peter

    To paint a more vivid picture Barbados has been borrowing to support reserves for many years even in the boom years. We have not been earning our way for a long time.

  8. peterlawrencethompson Avatar
    peterlawrencethompson

    @Hal Austin
    I took Economics 205 (microeconomics), Economics 206 (macroeconomics), and Economics 230 (theory) many decades ago at McGill University, but my understanding of the field has made giant progress since then.


  9. “Donna November 24, 2018 2:51 PM

    Are these “idiots” of EVERY colour?”

    yep..all different shades, shapes and flavours..


  10. Ah mean…common sense tells us if the Owing Arthur government left a 6 billion dollar deficit in 2008..they had to be borrowing HEAVILY…to leave such a huge debt on such a small island…while pretending to be the smartest people alive…pure fantasy..

    …similarly, when the exiled DLP were never able to erase that 6 billion dollar OWING deficit AND added a 9 billion dollar deficit of THEIR OWN which now has Mia BORROWING left and right…it tells us they are all bullshit artists with not even a gram of intelligence let alone common sense among any of them…

    So all that Mia Borrows will end up doing, won’t hold my breath for anything else, is adding her own billion dollar deficit to the mix by BORROWING…BORROWING, BORROWING ..for the next 4 years 6 months.

    ….they ARE ALL BANKRUPT of new ideas to drive the economy to growth, jobs and progress in the majority population…even though the medical marijuana trade is just sitting there BEGGING to be STARTED…the nuisance government prefers instead that they people go and work in marijuana farms in Canada while they sit their lazy asses in cabinet debating a nonissue on whether to allow marijuana farmers to remit their salaries to Barbados without being arrested …a goddamn nonissue….that should never even be an issue..

    BTW….this is being debated elsewhere..we know how useless weak, small island governments are….. now that it has been brought to people’s attention that islands like St. Lucia (one person said it already happened there) have already practically been taken over and are now controlled by foreign entities…

    Barbados am sure because of their 53 year old WEAK LEADERSHIP is in the same boat and don’t even know it.

  11. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ David at 2:55 PM

    The statement that we have been borrowing for many years to support reserves is an exaggeration. An untruth repeated very often becomes the truth. A country that is export oriented must earn foreign currencies. Exports + Foreign Direct Investments + Remittances should not exceed Imports during the boom years.


  12. @PLT,

    I am not going to repeat myself every time someone comes on with a nonsense. Mine my posts to BU over the last few years for the evidence.
    I say again, the alleged growth during the Arthur years were based on debt. If you did economics at McGill, it certainly was not as a major subject. Maybe you attended lectures. You just do not understand economic theory.
    I am keen on debt for infrastructural development, but the challenge is to admit this and not pretend it was based on ‘growth’. That is why the economy is now in a mess; it was not all Sinckler/Stuart’s doing.

  13. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ David BU

    I was hoping that in his exposition on the Financialisation of modern economies , debt finances growth and employment. Most economies will go through periods of bust and booms. It comes with the territory.

  14. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    Something went awrie in the transmission. I hope bloggers picked up the drift.

  15. peterlawrencethompson Avatar
    peterlawrencethompson

    @Hal Austin
    My major at McGill was engineering… I did only those 3 courses in economics. You are correct that “growth during the Arthur years were based on debt…” but it was growth. There has been no growth since 2008.


  16. @Vincent

    How is it an exaggeration if the CCEntral Bank numbers support?


  17. @PLT

    Oh please. Let us make this simple: if you have a credit card and go on a spending spree, it looks as if you are prosperous; but at some point you have to start repaying that debt – or go bankrupt.
    You can incur debt to repay debt – just think of the people who repay their mortgages with their credit cards.
    @PLT I owe you a sincere apology. I was under the impression you had formally studied economics rather than sat in on three lectures. I was not aware you had no formal training in the subject. It explains a lot.

  18. peterlawrencethompson Avatar
    peterlawrencethompson

    @Hal Austin
    I don’t recommend debt for governments, businesses or individuals.

    Most of the discipline of economics is bogus. I have read widely in the field and combined that with four decades of entrepreneurship. Homo economicus, upon which most conventional economics is based, is a crude fiction which leads to profound errors in the real world. Economics is not a science, it is a loosely cobbled together hodgepodge of mathematical models that do not parallel the real world, and old wives tales which have no basis in mathematics at all. Does it not strike you as weird that economists have an almost perfect record of being unable to predict the process of ANY actual economy?

    I regret that you mind is still a captive of this outmoded mythology. If you wish to update your understanding I recommend you read Terry Burnham, Robert H. Frank, Shabnam Mousavi, Julie Matthaei, and Robert Reich.

    But I digress… I will leave you to your outmoded and failed economic theories while I will be content to build actual jobs and foreign exchange earning power in Barbados. Thanks for the diversion.


  19. All of this talk about how well we were doing is now being debunked! I recently read that when Koffi Annan spoke about Barbados “ punching above its weight” he was actually referring to the area of foreign affairs and not economic management.
    No wonder there is now confusion. Everybody thought we would have just gone to the IMF and that was the magic wand .
    Long way to go 2033.
    Not a failed state yet but………….

  20. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ David BU

    I think you will have to point out the document and the table that supports that asertion. Even then I will have to be sure we are speaking of the same thing.


  21. @PLT,

    You again show that you shoot from the lip. ” I will leave you to your outmoded and failed economic theories while I will be content to build actual jobs and foreign exchange earning power in Barbados. Thanks for the diversion.”(Quote)
    Have you ever read any of my posts on BU? You are making a fool of yourself. What are my failed economic theories?


  22. “Economics is not a science, it is a loosely cobbled together hodgepodge of mathematical models that do not parallel the real world, and old wives tales which have no basis in mathematics at all. Does it not strike you as weird that economists have an almost perfect record of being unable to predict the process of ANY actual economy?”

    And they NEVER have solutions that actually WORK..that is one course study AND degree that should be abolished, it is absolutely useless….when anyone tells me they are an economist, my very fist reaction before I could control my tongue is…what the hell is that.

  23. peterlawrencethompson Avatar
    peterlawrencethompson

    @Hal Austin November 24, 2018 4:36 PM
    “What are my failed economic theories?”
    +++++++++++++

    Savings are congruent to investments.


  24. “I recently read that when Koffi Annan spoke about Barbados “ punching above its weight” he was actually referring to the area of foreign affairs and not economic management.”

    Ah told them they misinterpreted the man, in those years he was still head of the UN and that phase held a much different meaning, most of us who were in NYC at the time understood what he was. trying to convey, but these refused to listen so I let them run with it just to make them happy, although I could never grasp why they saw it as some compliment….


  25. @PLT

    So that constitutes an economic theory?


  26. Only you lot have the right to say what you feel???????????

    #alternativefacts.

  27. peterlawrencethompson Avatar
    peterlawrencethompson

    @Hal Austin
    But if you’d prefer an actual economist to explain it to you because I have failed completely, try Finance is Not the Economy by Dirk Bezemer and Michael Hudson in the JOURNAL OF ECONOMIC ISSUES Vol. L No. 3 September 2016
    http://www.economicsofcreditanddebt.org/media/research/745-768_Bezemer.Hudson.pdf


  28. Sorry. wrong thread.


  29. @PLT,
    No. The question is: does that constitute an economic theory? If yes, plse explain. I want YOU to explain.


  30. And that is why I don’t pay any attention to so-called economic theory – because their mathematical equations cannot factor in the most important variable – the behaviour of PEOPLE.


  31. that PHRASE back then held a much different meaning…

    Still trying to wrap my head around the marijuana remittances nonissue that the soft in the head government ministers, as people are pointing out, who are the same jackasses WHO APPROVED the same Caribbean workers going to work on marijuana farms in Canada and elsewhere…MONTHS AGO…but who did not see it necessary to tweak the laws to accommodate remittances from marijuana farmers outside of Barbados immediately they left the island….but got the nerve to talk about they are discussing it in parliament..these people are WORKING TO SEND FOREX to Barbados.

    what are they waiting for in cabinet… A BRIBE.???.


  32. There is a reason economics is referred to as the “dismal science”, if you put four economists in a room and ask them to solve a problem you would probably get eight different solutions. My exposure to Economics was very minor that could be due to the class that I attended which was oversubscribed and I quickly lost interest although I kept a couple of the books these past 40 years and counting……

    I remember at the height of the economic crisis circa 2007-2008 it was pointed out that the head of one of the leading rating agencies (Standard and Poors) I think had a degree in English

    The PM’s office is chock full of economists itching to solve the country’s problems, let’s see if that combined brain power is going to be of any use but the ongoing argument has now been reduced to a battle of egos……


  33. @Waru
    Please share a link to the story as one wonder if such a story can possible be true.

    But if true, it gives insight into the minds of those who are in power in these islands. What segment of society would you expect those who go and work on farm in the US to be from? The political class? The business class? Upper class or just ‘ordinary Joes’? A continuous war on one segment of the society. I am quite certain that with an arrest would come an attempt to seize the money that was earned there.

    I hope these gentlemen/women are able to funnel their money to their families through some other conduit; perhaps a relative in the US or Canada or that they can find some way to keep their money over here.

    Our politicians are devoid of ideas and must hide behind laws that are nothing more than thievery. They focus their attention on issues like attire and sex between consenting adults.On weightier matters, there is silence.

    Is it even legal? It was not a crime in Canada? It was not done in the islands?


  34. David
    November 24, 2018 2:16 PM

    @John
    Is there a correlation between a growing middle class and decline in population growth?
    There is the line being pushed by Dr. Mascoll that we need to encourage immigration to expand the tax base.

    ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

    I think people in Barbados long recognized that this is no place to raise children!!!

    No opportunities and crooked leaders who could not create those opportunities if they tried as they are too busy stealing.

    I got to that realization by watching the Closed Brethren,

    There are still some here but I see less and less of young Brethren families!!!

    I used them as an example because they stand out and because they usually travel as a family.

    Many of the younger Brethren generation have emigrated, US and Argentina seems like … if my info is correct.

    No Bajan can speak Bajan like a Closed Brethren!!

    Regarding immigration, you see what the Hildebeast is advocating for Europe?

    STOP IMMIGRATION!!!!

    Her logic is all screwy but she now is against immigration.

    I’ll hear Rush Limbaugh’s take on it next week, I have my own theories at the moment.


  35. You are entitled to an opinion.


  36. There is the line being pushed by Dr. Mascoll that we need to encourage immigration to expand the tax base.

    +++++++++++++++++++++++

    My guess is he wants people like Doc Morley, Donville’s buddy … anybody with money, clean or dirty!!

    Why would any young person looking to raise a family come to Barbados?

    What opportunities exist?


  37. “What opportunities exist?”

    Louder John…LOUDER.

    That is whee the CREATING OPPORTUNITIES part comes in.


  38. http://www.loopslu.com/content/remittances-lucians-working-canadian-ganja-farms-crime?fbclid=IwAR16CO9AZoKcOndd3zDy-nqxakUjfHL3fDALcnMhnjx6GQvNMcsdxvCd9iQ#.W_k_WT7nA5w.facebook

    Theo…here is the link…not even I believe that these donkeys would be so dumb as to let this turn into some human rights violations of these workers…I am willing to give them the benefit of the doubt that they are just blowing their usual bullshit hotair…and wasting time as usual.


  39. In running parallels …see how quickly they changed the constitution to accommodate the Bitt mMoney scam…watch how many games they will attempt to play with the marijuana farm workers.


  40. Have they invented an issue and now have to find a solution for it?
    Kinda silly..


  41. WARU
    November 24, 2018 6:00 PM

    “What opportunities exist?”
    Louder John…LOUDER.
    That is whee the CREATING OPPORTUNITIES part comes in.

    ++++++++++++++++++++++++++

    Strip Clubs I am told are flourishing


  42. Between (1996-2008), we had an annual public investment rate of 14.5% of government spending. REALLY ! How legit is this number? Where are all the infrastructures and other intangibles to show for it? We should have been reaping all the benefits post 2008 from from all of this prior investment.


  43. @WARU November 24, 2018 6:05 PM “Theo…here is the link.”

    Well I had a friend, may he rest inpeace. he was a Badventist, who used to bless his Christmas ham and then call it roast beef.

    The St. Lucian farm workers can turn their marijuana wages into carrot wages using the same technique as my late, much lamented, much beloved friend.


  44. The over- generous corporate tax break(2-5%) that is coming soon, who is going to pay for for it? The government says it is revenue neutral. That’s a revenue loss of at least Bd$240 million.


  45. @Vincent

    Have a read of this 2007 document first to provide some background.

    https://www.barbadosparliament.com/uploads/document/ddfd976f0200ee092a9ad8149798f134.pdf

  46. peterlawrencethompson Avatar
    peterlawrencethompson

    @fortyacresandamule
    $240 million was the tax revenue from both offshore and domestic companies in 2016. The offshore companies were paying 2% or less so they will now pay a bit more. Mia says that the new regime will be revenue neutral, but I will believe that only after it is proven.


  47. Waru the problem is not that locals are sending back dollars…….it is that they are sending back pounds.


  48. @PLT. Okay, but the offshore contribution, I would hazard a guess and say it constitute a maximum of about Bd$40 million of the Bd$240 million. It seems we have now joined the corporate tax race to the bottom with other jurisdiction in the region.


  49. “Have they invented an issue and now have to find a solution for it?
    Kinda silly..”

    That’s how those clowns are, they will now work overtime to create a human rights violation against these workers, just because they look like them….there is something mentally wrong with these asses with titles that the word silly does not even begin to describe.

    John…limited imagination much…can’t you think of anything better, lucrative and more respectable for the majority population in Barbados…must you always ty to demoralize and denigrate those you cannot bully.


  50. The St. Lucian farm workers can turn their marijuana wages into carrot wages ”

    And what will the Bajan farm workers do, ya dealing with a different breed of clowns in ya Barbados parliament,

Leave a Reply to Georgie PorgieCancel reply

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading