Auditor General, Leigh Trotman

“2.81 Monthly reports from the Barbados Turf Club should be submitted to the Accountant General’s Department to substantiate the payment of taxes arising from its betting activities. It was however observed that no monthly reports have been submitted, nor have payments been received on behalf of the Turf Club in relation to taxes due from betting, since May 2010. A reminder letter was forwarded to the Turf Club asking that this information be submitted on July 11, 2012. However no further follow up action has been taken.

The relevant information needs to be submitted to ensure that the correct amounts of revenue and receivables are recorded in this regard.”

2016 Auditor General Report

______________________________________________________________________________________

A lack of financial discipline continues to afflict the public service as annually detailed in the Auditor General’s reports (AG), 2016 being no exception. To quote the AG:-

There are twenty-four (24) heads of ministries required to submit appropriation statements to the Auditor General’s Office as mandated by the Financial Management and Audit Act section 22. However, only nine (9) ministries submitted statements as at October 30, 2016.

Further, financial statements for almost all of the government agencies are not current. The AG had further reason to note that the Accountant General presented its financial statement for 2016 49 days after the statutory requirement of 4 months after government’s yearend of 31 March.

Of interest to BU is the story highlighted in the press on the weekend about the failure of the Barbados Turf Club (BTC) to pay 20% taxes. Surely an active citizenry should be naturally curious that there is something  suspicious about a situation where, due to slipups and a slapdash approach by manager, millions of dollars in revenue to the treasury continue to be unpaid? You will recall that 19 million in taxes were waived by the David Thompson administration as one of his first acts on attaining the office of government.

  1. Do the authorities need to place the lottery and gaming sector under national scrutiny anyhow given the millions of dollars collected and allegedly distributed to several bodies?
  2. Who audits and controls how such funds are expended?
  3. Where are the annual reports that account for the PROPER use of such low taxed funds?

Without proper accounting and audits it is easy for certain person (s) to channel money to personal or non authorized sources rather than to the parties that were declared.

Even with the ‘easy’ monies received from the BTC note how shabby the Garrison Savannah area remains. Include the other beneficiaries of the lottery, our sports facilities after years of millions of lottery dollars being channelled in that direction. Only the Barbados Cricket Association seems to putting the funds to some use although there is room for inquiry as well.

WHO is responsible for verifying that such funds are being properly utilised for the purposes intended?

67 responses to “Lottery Monies Being Used for Personal Aggrandizement | No Accounting by the Barbados Turf Club Says the Auditor General”


  1. @ William Skinner

    I cannot find any information relative to annual reports or audited financial statements for the Barbados Turf Club or who are their accountants/auditors.


  2. ” BMW X5; Dr. David Estwick’s Jaguar F-Pace SUV; Sinckler’s Range Rover and Dr. Denis Lowe’s BMW SUV”

    Those vehicles are required to “navigate” lol the pot holes.


  3. William Skinner November 14, 2017 at 12:57 PM #

    Once more, this is regulatory failure. The Companies Act should stipulate the timeframe for submitting annual reports. The Inland Revenue should be strict in interpreting the laws on the payment of taxes. We cannot continue to bla.me political interference. Workers must do their jobs with integrity. Where is union power when you need it?

  4. Well Well & Cut N' Paste At Your Service Avatar
    Well Well & Cut N’ Paste At Your Service

    Lol…..most of the ministers got more than one expensive, foreign exchange draining high end vehicles Art…even if they did not pay duties at the port for them, robbing the island of duties… purchasing them still drained the foreign exchange reserves….

    And Fruendel will take his lying ass and blame the population, when the refuse to restrict these purchases….glad he did it, he is gone now for sure.


  5. Dr. Simple Simon Phd November 13, 2017 at 10:25 PM #

    Lots of Italian names. Are they Sicilian?

    Lol.

  6. Theophilius Gazerts 121 Avatar
    Theophilius Gazerts 121

    seems as if transparency is a function of size.
    Jamaica followed by Trinidad and then Barbados.
    You have to search hard to get any information

  7. Dr. Simple Simon Phd Avatar
    Dr. Simple Simon Phd

    @Artax November 14, 2017 at 4:01 PM “the PM’s new Mercedes; Michael Lashley’s BMW X5; Dr. David Estwick’s Jaguar F-Pace SUV; Sinckler’s Range Rover and Dr. Denis Lowe’s BMW SUV…all expensive European manufactured vehicles.”

    I don’t begrudge anybody their fancy ride, because today my blood pressure is 109/75 and I am older by far than most of the above mentioned gentlemen with the fancy vehicles. It would be interesting to see their BP’s, and to find out whether driving a Mercedes, BMW, Jaguar or Range Rover helps to lower or helps to raise ones blood pressure.

    http://circ.ahajournals.org/content/early/2013/11/11/01.cir.0000437741.48606.98
    2013 ACC/AHA Guideline on the Assessment of Cardiovascular Risk

  8. Dr. Simple Simon Phd Avatar
    Dr. Simple Simon Phd

    @Crusoe November 14, 2017 at 6:53 PM “Lots of Italian names. Are they Sicilian? Lol.”

    Now how would I know? You would have to ask the UNKNOWN people who run the Barbados Lottery–in our names.

    Maybe Italians are not just good at fashion and food.

    Maybe they are also good at numbers.

    Isn’t the Italian economy in great shape?


  9. Artax November 14, 2017 at 4:04 PM #
    @ William Skinner

    I cannot find any information relative to annual reports or audited financial statements for the Barbados Turf Club or who are their accountants/auditors.

    Hal Austin November 14, 2017 at 4:58 PM #
    William Skinner November 14, 2017 at 12:57 PM #

    Once more, this is regulatory failure. The Companies Act should stipulate the timeframe for submitting annual reports. The Inland Revenue should be strict in interpreting the laws on the payment of taxes. We cannot continue to bla.me political interference. Workers must do their jobs with integrity. Where is union power when you need it?

    @ Artax
    I maintain we are experts at beating up the black political class but corporate Barbados gets a free pass. The Barbados Turf Club (BTC) seems to be a law unto itself. If they wanted to develop the racing industry they have the finances. They were importing horses that cost $100 000 almost forty years ago. Go figure. Millions of dollars in yachts outside the yacht club. They can build marinas and golf courses but somehow they can’t put money in racing.

    @ Hal
    There are laws and regulations governing almost everything in Bimshire. Corporate Barbados is not known for being nationalistic, so they find the loop holes. That is what caused the CLICO mess but we swept the real issue under the carpet because it was politically convenient to do so. You are talking about people who refuse to do such basic things as pay in workers’ deductions for national insurance. You are talking about people who built golf courses with million dollar houses and then expect governments to pay for the construction of the club house !!!!
    You are talking about people who abandoned agriculture rather than invest or diversify the industry.
    The popular thing is to blame workers for being non-productive. However, the ones who used to hang out at the Brifgetown Club all day just buying and selling and fighting the BWU are deemed to be productive. Like I said they get a free pass every time. But one day coming soon…it long in coming but it will come !!
    Man, it is pure greed and exploitation of the country.


  10. Here is the elephant in the room.
    These people have been screwing Bajans for centuries, so this is no real surprise to Bushie.

    But when they develop the temerity to be arguing that they should be EXEMPTED from paying BASIC TAXES, which every other brass bowl who owns a small lot of land, or makes a little income is expected to pay …. AND CAN GET AWAY WITH IT, ….then it becomes clear that the government – BOTH BLP and DLP, are complicit in the screwing of Bajans.

    First Arthur allows them to accumulate $19M in tax arrears.
    Then Thompson writes to off…
    Then Froon and Stinkliar has allowed then to continue NOT PAYING on some triviality…
    Note that the BLP has not had a SINGLE word to say about this shiite..

    Thank GOD for the Auditor General.


  11. @William

    Yours is a simple conclusion/observation. In our system of governance the political class is a creature of the corporate elite.


  12. William Skinner November 15, 2017 at 6:31 AM #

    “There are laws and regulations governing almost everything in Bimshire. Corporate Barbados is not known for being nationalistic, so they find the loop holes.”

    @ William

    We must first ascertain if the Barbados Turf Club is registered as a COMPANY or CLUB.

    Unfortunately, there isn’t any information on BTC’s website relative to the category under which the club has been registered or audited financial statements, which suggest it may be registered as a club.

    However, if the BTC is a CLUB, then the preparation of financial statements and regulatory requirements would be different…………. and financial statements distributed to members.

    But this does not mean certain aspects of the club’s operations are not subject to taxation.

    The BTC’s receivables are listed as $201,927, in the Accountant General’s Annual Report & Financial Statements for the financial years 2013-2014, 2014-2015 and 2015-2016, respectively.


  13. David November 15, 2017 at 8:14 AM #
    @William

    Yours is a simple conclusion/observation. In our system of governance the political class is a creature of the corporate elite.

    What I am saying is neither a “simple” conclusion nor observation. It is a FACT.
    The Black political class is a creature if its own making as exemplified by the so-called Father of Independence , who engineered the nefarious Public Order Act of 1974 to protect white corporate Barbados and to destroy the Black progressive nationalist movement.

    Bush Tea November 15, 2017 at 7:12 AM #
    Here is the elephant in the room.
    These people have been screwing Bajans for centuries, so this is no real surprise to Bushie.

    But when they develop the temerity to be arguing that they should be EXEMPTED from paying BASIC TAXES, which every other brass bowl who owns a small lot of land, or makes a little income is expected to pay …. AND CAN GET AWAY WITH IT, ….then it becomes clear that the government – BOTH BLP and DLP, are complicit in the screwing of Bajans.

    First Arthur allows them to accumulate $19M in tax arrears.
    Then Thompson writes to off…
    Then Froon and Stinkliar has allowed then to continue NOT PAYING on some triviality…
    Note that the BLP has not had a SINGLE word to say about this shiite..

    Thank GOD for the Auditor General.

    @ Bush Tea

    You are spot on. However when you read the post by David, we immediately recognize why they have been allowed to do it. Those like David whose mission is to protect the status quo at all costs, cannot understand that the broken, corrupt BLPDLP is a major source of our problems.He can never see past anything therefore he defends the system.


  14. What is all this hullabaloo about

    Firstly, the government has already given certain entities the status of super citizen

    Meaning a number of entities were exempted from a range of taxes, as law – Sandals for example.

    Secondly, the country has long cultivated a narrow range of people (entities) who could make millions from legal gambling, running lotteries.

    We doubt these lotteries/gamblers were ever properly monitored.

    There is also private gambling going on amongst some elites where winnings are never subjected to taxes, some public as well. These have been going on for decades.

    There was even a man who left a medical career to operate a lottery, ask Joey Harper, if he still alive.


  15. William Skinner November 15, 2017 at 6:31 AM #

    @William,
    Barbados is a failed state. Not only the so-called university-educated politicians (an example of the devaluation of higher education since most of them are ill equipped to function in a competitive environment), but the white business class has also fai.led. That is why the Trinidadians have moved in and taken our corporate Barbados.
    The real test will come when the New Barbadians feel confident to make a move for control of the country – political and corporate. Barbadians may be intimidated by the white plantocracy, but the New Barbadians are not.
    In the long-term, black and white Barbadians must put aside their mutual suspicions and fight together, or be enslaved by the invading forces.. Divided they will fall.


  16. @ Hal

    I cannot agree that Barbados is a failed state. It is a badly managed state but it shows no symptoms of a failed state. The economy is in a serious downfall but the government has not collapsed. Failure to address the education system; land reform and refusing to have progressive economic reforms/restructuring are all indications of a bankrupt BLPDLP.
    Quite frankly with a dynamic political leadership and more innovative private sector, we can easily turn around the economy in ten years and put our country on the path of sustainable development for the next century.


  17. @William,
    You are optimistic. Maybe you are too close to the fire.

Leave a Reply to CrusoeCancel reply

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading