Today I intended to write about the functioning, or rather, the non-functioning of the system that was set up by the Employment Rights Act to settle disputes, particularly claims for unfair dismissal. I wanted to point out that it is at best amateurish and that it is failing miserably to meet expectations. But I felt a tug that forced me to weigh in on the furore caused by the reported attempt by the Minister of Finance to remove the Governor of the Central Bank from office.

In the fullness of time, the courts will settle the legal aspects of the matter and I will patiently await that eventuality. However, at this point, I am more concerned about the potential loss of any residual investor confidence that might still be remaining after the series of seventeen downgrades of this country’s credit rating.

As a Barbadian, no matter your political persuasion, no one should be happy to see this embarrassing saga being played out in the public domain. Not so long ago, it was being said internationally that Barbados was punching above its weight. Now I seems that this country is reeling from some head blows inflicted as a result of the poor performance of the Government over the last nine years, and now this? Can Barbados take anymore?

In 2008 the Democratic Labour Party took on the burden of the government of this country as neophytes for the most part. Unfortunately, after nine years in office, they have steadfastly maintained that neophyte quality as though their nine years in office has taught them nothing. They have presided over the affairs of this country with a reverse Midas touch that seem to destroy everything in their wake. Now it seems that they have set their deadly aim on the Central Bank as the next institution targeted for destruction.

So far, the Minister of Finance has quite rightly not made a public statement on the matter. Instead, some of his colleagues have intervened with unhelpful remarks that only goes to confirm that Cabinet is in total disarray.

The Barbados Today of Friday, February 17, 2017 reported that Minister of Housing, Denis Kellman, while addressing a gathering of party faithful earlier that same day, suggested that the decision to fire the Governor of the Central Bank was for the “greater good”. He went on to suggest that while Worrell may have been successful so far in blocking all attempts to remove him, the Freundel Stuart Administration was not backing down. That report suggest that Minister Kellman is privy to the inner workings of the Ministry of Finance on this issue.

On the other hand, Prime Minister Freundel Stuart, in his all too familiar nonchalant approach to the affairs of state, was reported to have said something markedly different in the Daily Nation of February 21, 2017. He was quoted as saying:

“I am not in any position to comment on whether the Government’s confidence in the Governor of the Central Bank underwent any change, because I preside over the Cabinet of Barbados and at no time has the issue of the Governor’s relationship with the Government come up for consideration”.

He went on to state that he has not made himself privy to all that has been happening, and I accept that as the Prime Minister is an honourable man. But I think that I must ask: since the Prime Minister did not make himself privy to the happenings, Did someone make him privy? If the answer is “no”, it would certainly seem that the Prime Minister is definitely not in control of his Cabinet and worse yet, Kellman is more informed than he is. Perish the thought, say it isn’t so!

131 responses to “The Caswell Franklyn Column – Prime Minister Come Clean on the Sacking of Governor Worrell”


  1. @Caswell

    Correct, resignations are in order all round.

    Note on our laundry list the BU HOUSEHOLD did not include the unprecedented and illegal dividend of 26 million dollars paid on the Housing Credit Fund (HCF) deemed illegal by the Solicitor General’s Office.


  2. Lawson
    Look what it has done to. We had a much better person in Lord (Adair) Turner.. His problem was that he could think for himself.


  3. If anyone can make head or tail of what Hal said at 12:41 PM…. please assist Bushie.
    Thanks…

  4. Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger Avatar
    Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger

    “Journalists, and would-be journalists, like to claim a special place in the democratic structure. It is fiction. Journalism has no truth-testing mechanisms.”

    I think this sums it up Bushman… maybe Hal is having an attack of conscience or something. ..lol

    And there is not a journalist alive or dead who could lie like trump, the swedes and french are egging him to stop telling lies on them. …no one distort reality like trump, he sees the edia as competition for his lying and distributing fake news…why he wants them gone, but he will be gone and they will still be around.

  5. Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger Avatar
    Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger

    And there is not a journalist alive or dead who could lie like trump, the swedes and french are BEGGING him to stop telling lies on them. …

  6. Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger Avatar
    Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger

    William. ..ya got it upside down…if Worrell does not give a press release so the government can be blasted for ruining the economy. …it’s Worrell will be blasted for still being in cahoots with the government. ..against the people.


  7. @ WW&COB
    Thanks but that did not help the Bushman…

    Is Hal saying that journalists have no role in a democracy?
    It he is … then how does he suggest that the requirements of COMMUNICATION and education could be achieved in a democracy… by the police? ..the government?

    …and what the hell does having a ‘truth-testing mechanism’ have to do with the moot…? Journalists have NO DUTY to be sure of the truth before publication…. else all we would ever get are high court judgements.

    Lotta shiite …. somewhat like the anonymity business…

    The role of the press is to provide a public platform for discussion, exposure and feedback.
    If a journalist publishes an article that is a lie, then the injured party should have the opportunity to correct the error ….AND to recover damages …if it can be shown that the lie was malicious and intentional.

    A good journalist therefore is one who can produce interesting, informative, revealing, educational, provocative and artistic work that exposes the underbelly of democracy.
    He has NO COMMITMENT to absolute truth, but has an ethical and professional requirement NOT to be malicious.

    Why the hell should the system default to having to prove that leaders are crooks? Those in leadership positions should always be willing to demonstrate that they are above board – and where they are not, should best declare their hands early… or buzz off.

    As Bushie explained to Hal before, his contributions here are excellent examples of good journalism …not because he has all (or even a lot) of the answers….. but because he raises lots of interesting and provocative QUESTIONS.
    Those with the CORRECT answers should then step forward and educate us all -or suffer the consequences of innuendo and gossip…

  8. Jeff Cumberbatch Avatar

    *Jeff/Caswell,

    I bow to your greater knowledge of local practice. In the UK, he would be entitled to his salary, but not perks. Perks are re- imbursements ie his car is for travel on official business; his home is for unofficial entertainment; etc.
    @ Jeff
    You quote, but there is no source.*

    @ Hal, my apologies…and English law is indeed the same:-

    See Lavarack v Woods of Colchester Ltd.[1966] 3 All ER 683- where Diplock LJ said: “The first task of the assessor of damages is to estimate as best he can what the plaintiff would have gained in money or money’s worth if the defendant had fulfilled his legal obligations and had done no more.”

  9. Caswell Franklyn Avatar

    Hal

    In Barbados there are no longer any perks for the most part. What was once a perk has been taxed in its entirety by Sinckler. The only perk that remains in the Governor’s contract is his residence since that is tax free in accordance with the Central Bank act. And even so the mansion is considered part of his entitlements that would have a value. You could not move him out immediately in any event.

    Sent from my iPad


  10. We have begin to hold these donkeys accountable. What reputations what!


  11. David February 26, 2017 at 4:20 PM #

    We have begin to hold these donkeys accountable. What reputations what!
    ………………………………..

    Agreed…..we have to become schooled in civil disobedience and we can start by staying home one day every week with a march stuck in to highlight what you are objecting about.


  12. @Caswell Franklyn February 26, 2017 at 10:11 AM “He was a central bank governor…entertainment allowance…”

    Since the entertainment allowance is to be used ONLY for entertaining guests on the Central Bank’s behalf, and since DeLisle is unlikely ever again to entertain the Central Bank’s guests, can you explain why we should use the taxpayers money to pay him an entertainment allowance?

    I mean we will be paying an entertainment allowance to the next governor won’t we?

    And can I claim an entertainment allowance too? Lolll!!!

    After like Delisle I am not entertaining the Central Bank’s guests either.


  13. And since the Mercedes was for running the Central Bank’s errands and since it is unlikely that Delisle will be running any errands for the Central Bank, can you explain to us the taxpayers why we should continue to pay his transportation allowance. After all he is free to remain inside his own house for the next 32 months. We are not asking him to run any Central Bank errands for us.

  14. Jeff Cumberbatch Avatar

    See Lavarack v Woods of Colchester Ltd.[1966] 3 All ER 683- where Diplock LJ said: “The first task of the assessor of damages is to estimate as best he can what the plaintiff would have gained in money or money’s worth if the defendant had fulfilled his legal obligations and had done no more.”

    Simple Simon, there is your answer. The Governor must be treated as if the contract had run its course since the termination was in breach of the contract of employment and he must be put in the position he would have been in had the contract been performed according to its terms!

    Robinson v Harman (1848) 154ER 363

    Damages for breach of contract should compensate the victim of the breach for the loss of his contractual bargain. Baron Parke said: ‘The next question is: What damages is the plaintiff entitled to recover? The rule of the common law is, that where a party sustains a loss by reason of a breach of contract, he is, so far as money can do it to be placed in the same situation, with regard to damages as if the contract had been performed.’


  15. What if he was showing signs of dementia and woudnt step down what would be owed.

  16. Jeff Cumberbatch Avatar

    What if he was showing signs of dementia and woudnt step down what would be owed.

    I trust that this ailment could be established on a balance of probabilities?


  17. comparing the barbados economy to a frugal postman was weird, but would a sane person take that job, in a country with no natural resources no real manufacturing, tourism being battered by seaweed,brexit cuba, and laissez faire attitude of the polticians and populace towards garbage, crime and renewal.

  18. Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger Avatar
    Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger

    Bushman….only certain journalist are aware that they are keepers of the gates for the country in which they are domiciled and are journalists….the US journalists are well aware of their roles, the reason why trump hates them and is so afraid of them……..I dont know if Hal was having a senior moment.

    Journalists in Barbados think their job is just be political pimps for whichever government is driving them…, Carl Moore comes to mind, just imagine him in the 70s,80s, 90s..

    I have no clue what journalists in the UK think, but judging from their dailies, they too know that they are keepers of their gates….ah cant speak for Hal….he threw everything out the window with that comment…lol

  19. Jeff Cumberbatch Avatar

    The ad that won an election!


  20. This time around the ad is being posted by the Bees with the question -dem lie?


  21. I saw a fella trying to fix the govt bus after it had broken down… do you want a screwdriver one of the female passengers asked…..no I am already 10 minutes late.


  22. Dale Medford Conman and Fraudster

    https://m.facebook.com/home.php?_rdr#!/profile.php?id=100007845182714&tsid=0.34405081541602256&source=typeahead

    This is a warning to all locals and foreigners to be aware of this Conman and thief
    .
    He is listed on his Facebook page as being employed by Barbados Transport Board

    Pathetic individual his wife left because of his conning ways

    Be on the lookout as he has defrauded many and has several people looking for him who don’t ness about

    He needs to change his lying and deceiving ways


  23. @Bush Tea

    I am so sorry for forgetting devil´s trident (Poseidon and Her Goddess Bim forgive me!) . I guess it is some kind of magical portal to summon the armies of hell. Like Warcraft or Doom.

    The whole project perfectly highlights the national crisis on foreign currency: cheap signs made in China, ALREADY weathered due to low quality, flag – I assume – made in Vietnam, steel made elsewhere, concrete made in T&T.


  24. @William Skinner February 26, 2017 at 10:52 AM “Dr. Worrell by modern standards is still a relatively young man. ”

    What modern standards are you talking about? What relatively young are you talking about? Dr. Worrell is an old man. According to the data he is in the departure lounge (and so am I, lolll!!!)

    The life expectancy of a Barbadian man is 73.1 years. Dr. Worrell is 72. Do the math.

    You can fool yourself all that you like. Whenever you are done the life expectancy of a Barbadian male is still 73.1. and for a man who has spent his whole life doing sedentary work the life expectancy is likely somewhat less. If either or both or his parents or any of his siblings died before 73.1, we have to assume that he will make it to 73.1 only if he is very, very lucky.

    First I went to the funerals of my grandparents generation.

    Then i went to the funerals of my parents generation.

    And now several times per year I go to the funerals of my school mates.


  25. Give me a break…………who in their right mind would be lining up to offer any consultancy or lecturing to Worrell after he presided over the destruction of the Barbados economy? The man is 72, I dont know if he has any children to work for……….it is time for him to go home and rest his old arrogant tail.

    Christine Lagarde with all her faults must be laughing at the economist!


  26. Dear David:

    Thanks for posting the old DLP election ad. I had heard of it, but since I don’t watch TV I’d never actually seen it.

    Do you know which advertising company created the ad? because it was very nicely done.


  27. The word about is that it was produced by the press secretary of late David Thompson.


  28. And I wonder how much they paid the ad company, and the old lady, and the cute bus driver.

    I think that they deserved a lot, since they won a whole election for the DLP.


  29. And we are now living with the results of the blatant lie!


  30. Well well/Bushman

    Yes. I am saying that journalists have as very minimum role to play in our democracy. Not the central role they believe they have.
    This comes from the misconstrued belief that freedom of speech the same as freedom of the press. Freedom for Fox to do as they like? For Rupert Murdoch to do as he likes?
    As I have said before, journalism has no truth-testing mechanism. If, for example, if a scientist says bush tea can cure cancer, journalism cannot put that to the test.
    Our role is to report what the scientist is saying and to give balance the opposing view. That is why we have news (reporting) and opinions (features).
    All reasonably educated people have opinions, but they are not all reporters. Just read Barbados Today.
    With respect, I do not intend taking any further part in this debate. There is nothing more I can contribute.
    By the way, American journalists are the best in the world, followed by the Bajan ones. Right.


  31. Struggling to follow you Hal. The fourth estate has always been recognized as one of society’s self checking organs. It is why media houses/practioners are perennially targeted by the establishment. It is why CNN for example has been targeted by Trump?

    >


  32. Thank you Mr Blogmaster. I thought I was the only person confused. The entire debate is disconcertingly misconstrued to create a bogey straw-man and thus the ensuing comments are personal screeds disabusing that straw…

    It was amazing to earlier read words to the effect that a journalist has no mandate to present the truth. But on reading @Hal remark that “journalism has no truth-testing mechanism” maybe that is what the Bushman was actually saying…deep down.

    As the former journalist also said everyone has an opinion….

    Incidentally, there are more excellent citizen reporters than @Hal would have us believe. Social media has given many people the ability to report excellent FACT based work.


  33. When does reporting stop and become activism, a good judge has to be estranged from his personal feelings and focus on the law the problems happen when outside influences make him think his opinion is more important than the law as written. Its the same with journalists they should be impartial report the facts and allow us flunkies to decide where we stand, leaving out facts or interjecting assumptions is not reporting and they should be held accountable whether right or left.


  34. The hollywood elites quick to attack trump cant even get a couple of cards right.LOL Big investigation by cnn maybe ? could Trump plant have shuffled the deck. Jimmy Kimmel the white Steve Harvy

  35. Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger Avatar
    Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger

    Hal Austin February 27, 2017 at 7:00 AM #
    Well well/Bushman

    “Yes. I am saying that journalists have as very minimum role to play in our democracy. Not the central role they believe they have.”

    Hal…you will have to identify the countries where journalists havr a minimal role to play in society.

    Here is the 1st Amendment to the US constitution. ……

    “Amendment I Essays » Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.”

    If you can show the UK journalists have no such protections under the UK constitution fine….but given how their dailies operate I belive they do, which would deem them borderline activists..at least.

    Jeff would have to tell us if the Journalists in Barbados are denied protection under the constitution.

  36. Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger Avatar
    Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger

    Barbados stands separate and distinct from both countries in regard to freedom of speech for journalists and citizens, the right to protest government bribery and corruption, the right to expose bribery, corruption and crimes committed by business people connected to both governments…….

    The leaders display all the hallmarks of wannabe dictators in a banana republic, but since none of them can impress trump, they may want to rethink that stance…the press in the US will deal with him.


  37. @ Hal
    With respect, I do not intend taking any further part in this debate. There is nothing more I can contribute.
    ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
    A fair position.

    The fact is that you have nothing really to contribute to this moot, but you would do well to listen with an open mind.
    Bushie keeps telling you that your strengths lay in the questions that you bring to the table… your attempted answers are largely flawed.

    The biggest trick used by authorities is to insist that any ‘news’ published is the unadulterated ‘truth’ – else the publisher is made to pay the piper. Noel Lynch got a whole plantation outa that shiite.
    Journalists have a duty to publish important information with a fair and balanced perspective.
    That means presenting all sides of an issue and where possible, any concrete evidence one way or the other.
    The only damn crime of a journalists (or blogger like BU David) is maliciousness. Indeed, it is Bushie’s position that there is a REAL place for the FOX news types of this world. All news sources should be treated with a ‘buyers beware’ attitude.

    @ Jeff
    Most of the ‘perks’ associated with the Governor’s job are not really ‘perks’ as such. Hal’s point is valid that allowances for entertainment, business travel, etc are really TOOLS needed for the position – not perks.
    Surely he now has no rights to a security pass, or access to the computer systems etc which he ‘enjoyed’ before….

    A COMPONENT of the car allowance may be deemed as personal benefit (thought he drove his own mini?), and perhaps the health plan, but in a REAL meritocratic society, there is no way he would benefit from much more than his basic salary.

    In Barbados any shiite flies….

  38. Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger Avatar
    Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger

    Hal..here is a private citizen in the UK…Gina Miller…. telling the government to grow a backbone…she successfully challenged the brexit move and had the government scrambling for a couple months in the high court…., do you see the government trying to muzzle her freedom of speech….that tells us that it is protected under the UK constitution for citizens and journalists.

    How many business people do you see challenging governments in Barbados on behalf of the people, the majority……unless it’s to steal taxpayer’s money.

    http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/letters/letters-brexit-gina-miller-tax-donald-trump-oscars-2017-moonlight-la-la-land-a7601801.html

    “To secure a prosperous nation after Brexit, we must act like grown-ups and pay more tax

    Send your letters to letters@independent.co.uk

    Letters 4 hours ago1 comme

    Anti-Brexit campaigner Gina Miller called on the Lords to show ‘backbone’ in the debate over the Brexit Bill this week AFP/Getty Images

    The phrase in your main editorial on Saturday that shrieked at me was “the voters looked to their wallets first”. How, I wonder, is any party expected to mount a credible opposition to the present Conservative austerity policies when most voters refuse to accept the truth that to have decent health and social services, education, roads, arts and local services, together with civilised support for the young, the disabled and those falling on hard times requires all of us to contribute realistically to the national coffers? This includes all individuals except the very poorest and both small and large businesses, commensurate with their ability to pay.”

    An intelligent father…who would want to meet with the incompetent illiterate who got his son and other innocent civilians killed, anyway.”

    http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/navy-seal-killed-yemen-father-refused-see-donald-trump-bills-owens-william-ryan-owens-a7600971.html


  39. Well well,
    have said that it is widely misconstrued, by lawyers and journalists, that free speech is the same as freedom of the press.


  40. de pedantic Dribbler February 27, 2017 at 7:51 AM #

    Incidentally, there are more excellent citizen reporters than @Hal would have us believe. Social media has given many people the ability to report excellent FACT based work.
    ………………………………………………………………

    Quite true and in Bim I rate BU very highly in its ability to ferret out the facts unfortunately we do have some contributors over time with fake news that the more discerning ones are able to ignore………..then we have the pitch fork in garrison theorists but thats another story…lol.

  41. Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger Avatar
    Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger

    Hall and I put it to you. …if there is no free speech…there is no freedom of the press…read Barbados…read the disgracefully muzzled CBC Barbados excuse for a tv station….alternately used by both governments to spread lies and propoganda…..read decades of Barbados Advocate and Nationnews and neuther of them can report on the government corruption and corrupt business people in 2017….the recent addition barbadostoday wont either.

    ……..keeping black bajans uninformed, backward and ignorant for their own selfish purposes.,.had not for the internet and the blogs…the situation would have remained even worse on the island…but that ship has sailed.

    You got my point, right.


  42. Jeff,

    I usually bow to your greater expertise, but as to the matter of salaries and benefits in England and Wales on the termination of contracts, you are wrong. Benefits are not salary.
    As they say, facts are specific to each case.

  43. NationBLPnewspaper Avatar
    NationBLPnewspaper

    I am once again calling out Caswell Franklyn as a fraud. Mr. Franklyn said on this blog that when he was first approached about writing in the Nation newspaper he was told by the Nation newspaper that he should NOT be writing on political matters.
    Now every week Caswell is singing the “Let us remove the DLP” tune.

    Can brother Caswell tell the blog when the Nation newspaper’s policy changed regarding allowing him to write solely on politics. Was the restriction not to write on politics only once Caswell toed the Nation newspaper’s political line.

    It is no coincidence that all the commentators on Fox news support Trump and it is no coincidence that all the persons employed as columnists by the Nation newspaper support the BLP.

    I also have a dare for Caswell- I dare him to write any column critical of Mottley and watch his contract at the Nation disappear. Caswell are you a man or a mouse ? Fearless or Coward?

    You are just the latest yard boy in the Nation’s arsenal to do their political bidding. You are now moving into the category of David Come-a-long(the BLP’s version of Tommy Tucker singing for his supper).


  44. The silly season is upon us.

  45. Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger Avatar
    Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger

    And that explains why journalists and newspaoers in Barbados cannot be trusted….they are political pimps for government ministers and politicians.

    For the ignorant and backward, Fox News is not toeing trumps line…..Rupert Murdoch is richer than trump and the Foxnews like all media is protected under the first amendment….none of them have to “toe a line”.,…unlike the mediocre Nationnews….watch and learn over the next year.


  46. “Benefits are not salary”

    @Hal, I never said that they were. They are part of the cpntractual entitlements of the employee and a breach of contract must be made good in the mannwer I suggested ealier in the English Authority that I cited.


  47. CONTRACTUAL


  48. Caswell just like Commissiong is seeking relevance.


  49. Poor you!

    >

Leave a Reply to lawsonCancel reply

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading