Sir Allan Fields presided over the disposal of Barbados only conglomerate BS&T to T&T interest

The recent uproar created by Sir Roy Trotman  calling out of Diamond’s International Managing Director Jacob Hassid as the Egyptian Jew, has pierced the veneer which cloaks a simmering racial tension in Barbados. What we have is a dominant Black host population which has tolerated a relationship with the White population for years, the dominant minority group. It must be recognised that Whites enjoy a disproportionate economic influence which many readily admit extends to the political sphere in the form of White Shadows. The other ethnic groups have respected their minority roles.

In recent years BU has painted a concern about the affect the dismantling of the Barbados Model continues to impact our society. In the last decade another variable has had to be factored, the hegemony of Trinidad business. The unwillingness of successive governments and Barbadians to react to the aggressive acquisition of Barbados Assets does not augur well for a once proud people who exuded pride by being firm craftsmen of their fate.

It is no secret that the cash poor and now defunct Plantations Holdings Limited was gobbled up by CLICO to be asset-stripped.  Unfortunately the trend has continued and many of Barbados highly regarded companies have been acquired by T&T capital. The tentacles of T&T interest now choke financial services, food, beverage and drug importation and distribution, key manufacturing concerns along with real estate. Coincidentally large numbers of Barbadians are employed in the the lines of business mentioned.

Barbadians seen through the eyes of others are regarded as a passive lot. A good example of it is the respectful demeanor shown in the face of changing and transferring ownership to foreigners – of late Trinidadians – of some of our most prized possessions including land. A reality however is that it is very difficult to control how private interest should dispose of their assets. Of interest is that historically many of the high valued local companies have been owned by the White minority group yet when the decision was made to sell there has been a haste to sell-out to non Barbadians.  If it is a characteristic of Barbados that we have enjoyed a stable social and political climate despite known tension between the two groups, why rock the boat by casually allowing a shift of influence to Port of Spain, or is it deliberate?

Some may suggest that BU was gripped by a fit of paranoia at the time of writing.   Have you (Black Barbadians) not wondered at any time if local Whites and cohorts have conspired to control the economic power on the island through the years? It appears when disposing assets this group prefers to sellout to non Barbadians. A careful analysis will show that mainly non Barbados groups now own or control critical tributaries in the local economy: financial services, manufacturing, food, beverage,drug importation and distribution.

It seems evident that Whites especially have decided NOT to fully integrate their businesses. The Williams Group comes to mind. In the last 20 years Whites have migrated their interest from the distributive trade to financial services and manufacturing. We have seen it with the Caves. We have seen it with the Seales. We have seen it with the Goddards. Indeed citizens are free to mobilize and invest their resources as they see fit but it will not prevent those with even a mild sense of discernment from making obvious conclusions.

Of interest is the Barbados labour Party (BLP) platform message in the coming election campaign. Many believe when Owen Arthur was Prime Minister his pro-CSME stance  as the lead for CSME matters in Caricom precipitated the aggressive flow of capital from Port of Spain to Bridgetown.


  1. @robert

    Why do you and others believe that Barbados gets a pass when the issues of race and power raise its head? Even the most developed and multicultural societies continue to battle these issues.


  2. @ David

    Despite your best efforts, it is clear that we have two strains of thought – one represented by Moneybrain, Newbie, John (just about). Islandgal (I think) and, from all that has gone before, RR – and the other strain of which you are the arch protagonist for present purposes.

    I don’t think anyone would say it was wrong to think about Bim in ten years. My view is that it is right we should. Well then, would you like to tell us what your vision is – or, if not you, someone? What is it we really want? See, I just wonder whether there isn’t common ground here if only colour questions were left out of the equation.

    Let me give one example which I think is well known. Brudah Bim once explored with us his ideas about our cultural riches and local industry. For me, he spoiled it by wrapping it all up in questions of colour – but the ideas themselves were good, at least I thought so. So maybe, just maybe, there is more common ground than we suppose; well, unless we’re all fundamentalists masquerading as serious commentators.


  3. @robert

    It is not so simple, we have to dismantle the economic empires built on familial and racial considerations. We can’t move forward until we face up to it. It is obvious those who are White or have a vested interest in the status quo will take positions accordingly.


  4. @ David

    Our posts crossed. I see nothing wrong in talking about questions of race so long as it is understood it all works both ways. But I do not think the future of Barbados in practical terms depends on who is white or black or any other. If you say ‘support local industry’ – great – why should that depend on whether the ‘industrialist’ is black or white?


  5. @robert

    You and others stick on race but it the focus should have been how decisions are being made by the race which owns the wealth and how it continues to impact Barbados. It is a reality and BU will not be muzzled by anyone who feels threatened by race talk. BU is on record stating Sir Roy was wrong with his Egyptian Jew remark. We will call a spade a spade. For too long Black people in Barbados have sat passively and allow our pride and industry to be beaten into submission. We have to fight back. A good place to begin is dismantling the Cattlewash club.


  6. @ David

    For me, it’s not about ‘dismantling’ – destroying – it’s about building, that’s all.


  7. Well robert maybe you are not aware but sometimes to rebuild you have to destroy.

    On another note:

    CL Financial, CLICO try to recover

    Story Created: May 26, 2012 at 10:55 PM ECT

    (Story Updated: May 26, 2012 at 10:55 PM ECT )

    Both CL Financial and subsidiary CLICO have issued pre-action protocol letters to Barbados-registered Proman Holdings Ltd as the companies seek to recover 51 per cent of CLICO Energy Ltd (CEL).

    CLICO is seeking to recover its 17 per cent interest while CL Financial is seeking to recover its 34 per cent interest in CEL.

    The Sunday Express understands the pre-action letters were sent last week.

    CLICO Energy was sold to Proman on February 4, 2009, just three days after the then-People’s National Movement (PNM) government signed a Memorandum of Agreement with former chairman Lawrence Duprey on January 30 to provide an initial $5 billion to rescue CLICO, CLICO Investment Bank and other financially troubled subsidiaries.

    The German company issued a cheque for CLICO Energy for US$47 million but the government objected to the quick sale, initiated court proceedings and instructed that the transaction be reversed.

    The reversal of the sale was itemised in the Shareholders Agreement signed on June 12, 2009 between CLF shareholders and the Government.

    Under item 6 titled ‘Proman/Clico Energy’ it stated: “The present directors shall use their best endeavours to procure the reversal of the sale.”

    The government agreed that, if the sale was reversed, it would “use its best efforts” to stop the court action it had initiated.

    After almost three years and just two weeks short of the expiration of the Agreement, the CLICO Energy sale has not been reversed.

    The evaluation of CLICO Energy and its sale has been featured extensively in Sir Anthony Colman Commission of Enquiry into the collapse of the companies.

    Former finance director Michael Carballo had told the commission that CLICO Energy was valued at over US$200 million, had been sold for a paltry US$46.5 million, with the knowledge of three CLF directors-Gita Sakal, Rampersad Motilal and Duprey.

    CEL, Carballo had explained, was one of three assets, the other two being MHTL and Republic Bank Ltd owned by CLICO, which CLF’s 289 depended on for cash.

    For her part, Sakal had told the commission she was approached by Duprey to initiate talks with Joseph Cassidy for the sale of CEL.

    he said: “CLICO Energy shares were the only asset of any real value that I knew of which CLF could sell almost immediately. Proman had a right of first refusal under the terms of the shareholders agreement.”

    http://www.trinidadexpress.com/news/CL_Financial__CLICO_try_to_recover-154630355.html


  8. Yes, Moneybrain, hit the nail of the Head; honest, objective, clear, critical thinking; not the ‘racially’ prejudiced, myopic view that David precieves it through!

    Again, as I’ve said before, the COLLECTIVE* wealth of Black Bajans, IS* vast, HALF A BILLION* $$$ in the Credit unions, plus BILLIONS $$$ more in the Commercial Banking sector, without doubt, plus all the equity IN the lovely homes they own all over B’dos.

    Now, WHY don’t the collective WEALTH of Blacks, sitting in Banks and CU, BILLIONS of $$$, be used in a sensible POOL of collective UNITY, to Buy B.S. & T, Brydens, Almond Beach, and any other number of Enterprises, like LIFE OF BARBADOS, et al that were ALL open in the ‘war’ that ensued, whoever came UP with the right ‘price’ won, why can’t BLACK Bajans not get off their tails, and DO something in this regard for THEMSELVES, instead of the RACIAL nonsense put forth here by David and others of his ilk; and STOP passing the buck on Whites, Trini’s et al, tinged with all kinds of hogwash ignorance!

    But, there isn’t any time left, the opportunity has PASSED, the End is already near, for ALL, all of the Signs that Jesus said would CONVERGE on the world stage, IN a particular ‘season’ are HERE, its just a matter of relatively short ‘time’, recession! We ain’t SEE nothing yet!

    The White man, Black man, Indian, and ALL other shades, who are NOT* IN* Christ, will suffer UNTOLD pain and misery, SOON!


  9. @ David

    Just for the record, I do not feel threatened by ‘race’ or anything else for that matter…..well except BAF’s sexual prowess….but then, he’s a friend and I’ve learned to live with it.

  10. old onion bags Avatar
    old onion bags

    CLICO……..look a muh crosses…..WOW !


  11. @Zoe

    Can you post the financials of the Credit Union to show the wealth of which you speak?


  12. Almond Beach Club, a company bought by T&T concern in the BS&T deal. If you try to book a room to Almond Beach Club here is the result – http://crusader.travimp.com/TIDirect/TIDirectFrontServlet?request_type=hotelavailability&source=waitSearch&TIConnectId=ABDIRECT&entrypagesource=search&travImp=null&airtype=C

    Now what does this mean?

  13. Carlos Bourne Avatar

    What is the issue now that owners of BS& T have delisted their stock on the T&T stock exchange and is now awaiting permission from the local FSC to do the same here. That company is lost forever to bajans. This is a whole plot now unfolding and our politicians(the only ones who have the power to control it)are preoccupied concocting lies while BIM sails away. What will our children think of us in 20 years time. The Barbados Stock Exchange is an excellent example of an institution that dis-enfranchised Barbadians.


  14. @ David
    Wait you serious?
    You dare to touch on this burning issue (which the bushman has been preaching in the wilderness for the last 40 years?) on your blog.

    WELL…Expect the usual reaction from the sleeping black sheep, and the inevitable tripe from John and moneybrain.

    The facts are there for all to see. Rather than empower the talented blacks within their organizations, the white money class would prefer to transfer their assets to outsiders…..and they have been doing EXACTLY that.
    Their ‘Allan Fields and others’ were clearly not up to the challenge of managing these entities successfully – but rather than empower the talents (WHICH EXISTED AND EXISTS but tends to reflect the racial character of the majority) within these organizations, they allow their organizations to fail under the mediocre ” must be white” leaders, or eventually sell to White outsiders where possible, and to rich outsiders (Trinis) when not.

    No doubt John and Moneybrain sees things differently.
    They probably actually believe that they are of superior intellect and that they deserve to controll the disproportionate percentage of Barbados’s assets that they have in the past.

    Our politicians are tragic jokers. They take bribes openly given to them by the whites (given to both sides, so It matters NOT who wins) and then they dare not even mention the word ‘white’ or ‘race’ or even ‘Egyptian Jew’…..
    ….Then they take up the little money we have in the NIS and give it to the same whites to build their empires….
    How much NIS funds have been provided to James Husbands in the face of the need to explore alternative energy?

    The real joke lies in the attitude of people like onions who live to receive handouts from people like John and Moneybrain and hopefully to win the LOTTO some day. Such persons will only recognize the danger we face when we find ourselves ‘owned’ by some international Mafia or such Drug Cartel type operation….

    We could be a serious country….?

    But Bushie knows that he who dig a pit will fall in it…..


  15. @Zoe
    Here is the most current country statistics for CU’s in Barbados. Where is the wealth of which you speak? Check out the highlighted numbers!
    Country Data: Consolidated Statistics
    Credit Unions:    33Members:    129,162Shares and Deposits($):    512,720,298Loans($):    516,157,039Total Reserves($):    45,129,635Total Assets($):    661,990,890


  16. @ Zoe
    Your simplistic nonsense is just as useless and wrong here as it is on the subject of religion.
    What Credit Unions have what Billions in what bank what?!?

    They have large ASSETS. They also have balancing liabilities. While they can leverage considerable influence (if they had visionary leadership,) they DO NOT have the cash to buy assets such as BS&T etc.

    In any case, even if they COULD, the white deciders WOULD NOT SELL THEM since they have black leaders. Did you see any serious attempt to follow up on the offer of Almond Staff to buy the operation? …it was laughted off….

    EVEN you must understand that.


  17. One thing can be said for BT, he is 100% predictable!! Sometimes he makes me laugh.

    There is a big difference between wealth and riches and when Bajans understand once again what that difference is we will progress.


  18. John
    Bushie was 100% predictable long ago. It is called honesty and consistency. You should try it sometime…

    Now what is this red herring about wealth and riches…?


  19. ‘been preaching for 40 years’

    I think if my views hadn’t changed over 40 years I’d consider myself brain dead.


  20. @ David

    $512,720, 298 equals ‘half a billion’ right?

    @ Zoe

    Isn’t that what you said?


  21. @robert

    Let us not quibble about the obvious. Read the numbers posted and the easy conclusion to makes is a CU industry is leveraged 100+%, i.e the loans total more than deposits.


  22. @ RR
    Clearly you are a lawyer…..We know that logic is not your forte..
    …how do you deduce ‘unchanging views’ from ‘preaching for 40 years’…?
    ..or did you just HAVE to post something…?


  23. Wait!!
    Zoe, John and Moneybrain gone fishing?

    LOL… Or they send their lawyer RR to deal with David?


  24. @ David

    Loans to whom? The investors? And who are the investors? I’m not an economist but isn’t that a way of making money? Is it any different in principle from a loan from bank or building society? Does a loan – which can usually be foreclosed upon and upon which interest is charged – cease to be an asset in real terms? Qua the Credit Union it can’t be a ‘liability’ surely?

    Or are you now going to say I’m “quibbling” or “pedantic”? But by all means tell me I’m wrong if I am. As an investor myself, I’d be interested to know.

  25. old onion bags Avatar
    old onion bags

    Ross on to something….hmmm


  26. @robert

    The indicator that the CU is highly leveraged means they don’t have the cash as Zoe has stated. They are already heavily lent to their members.


  27. ‘I have been preaching what you’re saying David for 40 years’ = ‘I have been preaching the same thing for 40 years’ = ‘My views haven’t changed for 40 years’ = brain death.

    Get it?

    But maybe they have gone fishing. Or maybe the same old stuff on here just bored them to death. The absence of any attempt (a) to articulate a vision rather than snipe; (b) to articulate meaningful policies in the light of that vision; and (c) to search for common ground where there is, ultimately, a common purpose – the national welfare – is really rather pitiful. But then my beliefs are rooted in the idea of ‘One Nation’ not ‘One Colour’.


  28. I keep saying that the idea about owning a home as a priority is madness. It does not provide liquidity, and inflexible asset and in MOST occasions comes with heavy indebtedness to the suffocating banks. We need to focus on investing in projects that are income generating and dynamic in nature.


  29. @robert

    It is a citizens right to snipe if he or she feels like it. As Barbadians we know what stinks, we know we have been shafted for years by the deep pockets and the politicians. We are sick of it and we are voicing our opinions about it. Let the iterations take effect, don’t rush the brush.


  30. @enuff

    You will have to continue arguing your that land should fetch its highest economic value’ because it is out of alignment with the masses.


  31. Well why would any body want to sell their birthright and from the responses given the buyers seem to think that it is a Godgiven right for them to purchase and eventually own other peoples inheritance shades of jacob and esau


  32. @ David
    I don’t recall that being my argument. My argument is that the West Coast was long developed and the majority of recent projects were redevelopments rather than new ones. I have further argued that leasing as opposed to selling would not change the situation and that access to housing and not land should be the focus.


  33. Robert
    You need serious help.
    if you want to be picky, Bushie is willing to oblige tonight…

    The fact that someone may preach or teach the same message for an extended period can logically suggest the following:
    1 – the message is correct, true and unchanging. It stands the test of time and experience.
    2 – the messenger is trying to get the message through to a slow learner who has some difficulty in comprehending simple issues, far less more complex matters such as those embedded in the message.
    3- the messenger is a patient person who does not give up easily.
    4- since our world environment has changed drastically over the past 40 years, it means that the message has remained relevant through changing times.

    How does one deduce ‘brain dead’ in such circumstances unless one suffers from a careless disregard for logic…?
    Indeed it must take a brilliant brain to have perceived this message back then and to have processed it through the changing times and adapted as relevancy dictated.

    PLEASE Robert!! … just don’t be on Bushie’s side in any serious legal issue….stick with Zoe, John and Moneybrain.


  34. Island Gal

    allan Fields was the CEO and he advised the shareholders to sell. Aint it?


  35. @ Blogger 2012
    Were there any cases in these sell-outs when the Chairman / CEO did not advise shareholders to sell? …and when they themselves did not sell their shares? ….and whatever else…?


  36. @Bush & David

    Let the discussion continues. Ah far away , but i am enjoying the discourse. John,Money Brain, Robert Ross et al, have not dealt with the issue in a coherent manner, and that is expected. Change dont come easy, and if the masses did not challenge dthe stau quo, where would we be today? On the plantations picking pond grass for John, Money and Robert Ross family, That is why they wouldnt want to see a change of the social and economic strutures, as our society was built on racail superiorty and they would want that to continue..

    John, Money Brai and Robert Ross forget that people like them could walk into a bank and almost get an unsecured loan, while the blacks have to sell their birt right to get a loan. Dont forget how they have controlled the distribution system throught their interlcking directorship. I want people to read Professor Hilary Beckles book on the Mutual. it should be in UWI’s bookshop. They would have an understading that BST had major black players in its infancy, but the company was whitened over time.

  37. old onion bags Avatar
    old onion bags

    I agree with all who says the selling over to T& T was for the sole and definite purpose plan to make sure that black Bajans would continue to be disenfranchised. Note I stress definite. It was a plan. But you know what so was segregation. Nothing devious will last forever…


  38. @ Onions
    Segregation is relatively easily reversed.

    When you sell your asse(t)s to strangers, what they do is rape you by sending their riff raff down to ride roughshod on our asse(t)s.
    They bring their own methods, culture, biases and when they are through, what is left is fit only to close down…. But they would have already repatriated the sweets to their homelands – leaving us with our damaged, sour asse(t)s.

    The ‘Johns’ and money brains of Barbados think that they will escape the consequences of these pirates that they have unleashed on sleeping Bajans, but they too are in for a rude and shocking surprise…


  39. I do not understand how anyone can refute the argument that Whites in Barbados had the clear advantage of owning the whole Island after slavery was abolished.

    In the 30s and 40s who owned and controlled the economic activity in Barbados?

    Give me a $million and Bushie $10,000 and see who will start a business employing 25 people and making a profit in a year even though “Bushie knows everything”

    Barbados has had the best functioning apartheid in the world and the majority are still afraid to say so publicly.


  40. @Bushie,
    Moneybrain already escape. He live in Canada.


  41. @ Hants
    Money brain escaped? One cannot escape from karma….

    Bushie has started a number of million-dollar-business with less than $10,000 Hants. You would need more than one Million $ to have a fair chance against The bushman…

    As to how anyone could refute the fact that whites had a massive advantage in Barbados….?
    ……people like John who cannot, even in his most charitable moments, appreciate that blacks can be anything more than plantation workers who should feel lucky to have been allowed to escape the whip…

    …and like Richard Goddard who, as you pointed out earlier today, is upset that blacks dared to riot (not march) against the white plantation system in 1937…. Led by a Trini who, according to Goddard, committed the gross sin of claiming to have been born in Barbados.
    Wuh he could only repeat what he mudda tell he bout where he born… 🙂


  42. it is ironic to hear bajans lamenting the sale of Bsand T to outside interests. i well remember that this company was a whipping boy in the election campaigns of the 60″s and 70’s where it was held up bt the DLp as a bastion of colonialism and a damocles sword on the backs of poor black barbadians.


  43. I fear for Banks”
    have no fear. remember the late pm thompson’s words. ” i f i am elected before the ink dries on the proposed sale of BSandT,i will stop the sale of this barbadian asset “


  44. For they have sown the wind, and they shall reap the whirlwind: it hath no stalk: the bud shall yield no meal: if so be it yield, the strangers shall swallow it up.


  45. “For too long Black people in Barbados have sat passively and allow our pride and industry to be beaten into submission. We have to fight back. A good place to begin is dismantling the Cattlewash club.”

    If Black people can’t see that they have been the white man’s source of wealth from the time they were brought here as slaves do you think they will see it now? How would you go about dismantling the Cattlewash club?

    ENUFF.. I keep saying that the idea about owning a home as a priority is madness.”
    You are talking nuff sense but it falling pon deaf ears. I totally agree with you!


  46. What are we saying that Blacks should not aspire to the land owning class in this country?


  47. islandgal246 | May 27, 2012 at 9:43 PM |
    How would you go about dismantling the Cattlewash club?
    ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

    Cattlewash is a biiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiig place.


  48. some years ago, if my memory serves me correctly, a resercher published an article of her findings that Barbados racism was suttle apartheid and was worst than South Africa’s becuse of it suttleness. It was around the time Cow Williams was fighting Hilary Beckles when he had sugested that the govt should rename farley hill, mandela park.

    Buahie u remember that article it was in the Nation.


  49. Owning Land is different from owning a home, for one it is less expensive.


  50. Wait balance,
    You eat something foolish or what? You normally make logical statements…

    What does the fact that one set of politicians criticised BS&T some time ago, have to do with current concerns about its sale to non Bajans?
    Two different and unconnected issues sir.

    You may have missed the assessment of the role played by politicians in this whole saga…
    BRIBE TAKERS!!

    Perhaps DT had discovered that O$A had gotten a larger ‘political donation’ than he did… or perhaps the Trinis also give political donations….except they likely do so in $ US…
    If you believed DT then, that says more about you -than it says about him…

Leave a Reply to robert rossCancel reply

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading