Sir Leroy Trotman who heads the Barbados Workers Union (BWU) has accused DIAMONDS International of firing 30 workers because they attended a union meeting on the weekend. Sir Roy has threatened to shut the country down if the foreign owned entity does not review it position. Caswell Franklyn who heads Unity Trade Union and veteran trade unionist has suggested Sir Roy should escalate the matter to the police – Barbados Underground

Caswell Franklyn, Head of Unity Workers Union

As long as there are workers whose rights are being infringed, or who work under substandard conditions, there will be a need for the trade union movement, or something very much like it.

This question only arises because people look on and judge the movement by the current crop of leaders. The unfavourable opinion of trade unions should really be an unfavourable opinion of its leadership. Most of them wear too many hats, sometimes openly but oftentimes clandestinely which result in the cause of the workers taking a back seat to the other agenda.

Another problem which can sometimes be regarded as a positive is that unions, for the most part, are democratic institutions. That being the case, as in parliamentary elections, the most popular, not necessarily the best equipped candidate, is elected to lead.

A good case in point to demonstrate the need to have a body to represent the interests of the workers is the Employment Rights Bill that is making its way through Parliament. The workers needed a strong voice but also an enlightened voice to secure and hold onto those rights that already exists. Instead, we saw the trade union movement being out-gunned by the employers’ lobby. This is not to say that the bill is not a step in the right direction, but the workers’ cause was not sufficiently represented in the final bill. Even though the workers’ representatives fell down with regard to the Employment Rights Bill that does not mean that there would not be future opportunities for a robust trade union movement to assert itself. But the workers need to come together to ensure that the right people emerge to represent their interests.

Just recently, a union with membership in excess of 10,000 members could not muster a quorum of 50 persons to conduct their annual general meeting. During their last elections, less than ten per cent of the membership participated. That same apathy has manifested itself in parliamentary elections, which has, in the recent past, resulted in extremely ill-equipped candidate being elected. People don’t only get the government they deserve; they also get the trade union leaders they deserve. However, we do not have people asking if governments are relevant.

The trade union movement is very relevant and needs to be protected for future generations from people who aspire to leadership whose main agenda is not the cause of the workers. If the movement ceases to exists, workers would be at the mercy of employers who want to make money without regard to the living and working conditions of the workforce.


  1. @Caswell

    Where do we go from here?

    How do the workers fight back or is it too late?

    You should be able to go to Settings on the ipad >system preference>Language – to change to English vs American etc.


  2. @Prodigal

    Yeah ! Yeah is dat truth or TRUT!in your propagandise comment on may 2 @ 10.05am

    Look of all the issues about the economy all wunna could talk about is CLICO which is heading for the court and under wunna 14year watch did nothing to stop the collaspe CHECK!
    Then there is Barrack that under wunna 14 year watch did nothing to pay de poor guy!CHECK1

    then AX that too under wunna 14 year watch played footsie wid the tyrannical JEFFREY BROOMES and wunna did nothing about! ChecK!
    Now allof a sudden wunna had a light bulb moment and decided it is HIGH TIME THE DLP solve 14years of the OSA adminstration in 2 years give or take how many months Stuart was PM
    But wait with all the high expectancy the BLP have of winning why should the DLP be in any hurry to help wunna out. Those problems handed back to wunna on a platter would be a nice gift.don’t you think so!


  3. The trade unions in Barbados needs to move to a higher level, gone are the days when members are called out on strike, the union should then be begging the very employers not to dock the strikers’ pay. Furthermore, the union should be at the stage where they control the recruitment of new staff to a company I E a person should be a member of the union representing the workers at the Company, before he/she could be employed by the company. Unions in Barbados are still in the 19th century, they MUST move to a much higher level, especially now that we are attracting foreign companies into this country.

  4. The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall Avatar
    The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall

    @The Scout: “Unions in Barbados are still in the 19th century, they MUST move to a much higher level, especially now that we are attracting foreign companies into this country.

    In your opinion, are stable Unions confrontational, or symbiotic, to their employers?


  5. Statement by the Barbados Chamber of Commerce & Industry on Diamonds International remarks
    by Barbados Chamber of Commerce & Industry (BCCI) on Wednesday, May 2, 2012 at 5:41pm ·

    The Barbados Chamber of Commerce and industry is appalled by the statements attributed to Sir Roy Trotman in relation to one of our member companies Diamonds International.

    Sir Roy is reported to have said that 20 workers at Diamonds International were terminated on Monday 30 April 2012 because they met on Saturday April 28 to discuss whether they should form a bargaining unit. He is also reported to have referred to the managing director of the company as an “Egyptian Jew” and called on all employers to “to tell these foreign people that this is not Syria, this is not Damascus, this is not Libya”.

    The BCCI fully supports the right of any employee to join a union of their choice and the principles laid out in the protocol of the social partnership. We also support the provision within the draft employment rights bill under section 30 which indicates that an employee should not be discriminated against on account of their race or religion and suggest that neither should an employer be discriminated against on a similar basis.

    The BCCI has consulted with Diamonds International to ascertain the facts and they have reported that 7 persons had their contracts terminated following an extended period of consultation as a result of the recommendations of their immediate supervisors. Their termination is in no way related to any intention that they might have had to form a bargaining unit. In fact, the company stressed that it has informed staff that they are free to join any organisation that they choose, including a union, without fear of repercussion.

    Over the last four years while the economy has been very difficult and many companies within Barbados have closed, Diamonds International has honoured the Protocol of the Social Partnership and has not laid anyone off as a result of the recession. In fact, Diamonds International has shown great commitment to the Barbadian economy by expanding during this difficult time, most notably by opening new stores at the Lime Grove Lifestyle Centre. The company currently employs 130 persons.

    The managing director, Mr. Jacob Hassid, has lived in Barbados for 17 years and he and his wife have three children all of whom were born in Barbados. When someone has shown this level of commitment to our country, we should not be referring to them by race or religion and seeking to make them feel personally uncomfortable.

    We would hope that Sir Roy would investigate the facts and, once he is satisfied that he has been mis-informed, would withdraw his uncalled for remarks.


  6. Trade Unionism is an old archaic practice in this country.

    It served the masses fairly well from the 1930s right up to the 1980s in Barbados.

    Trade Unionism was hijacked by some members of the then middle classes during the 40s and 50s, coming right after the Right Excellent Clement Payne and many others had agitated in the 1930s for greater workers rights and the right to form trade unions in this country – Agitate, Educate, But Dont Violate.

    This hijacking had to do with a more moderating evolutionary approach to the way forward for the development of the affairs of the masses in the country, than with persistence with a revolutionary approach to such
    affairs.

    For, it was the Black Revolutionary Pan Africanists who laid much of the basis for the earlier development of Trade Unionism in Barbados. A good reading of Dr. Rodney Worrell’s book: Pan Africanism in Barbados: An Analysis of the Activities of the Major 20th Century Pan African Formations in Barbados, will help many individuals to understand this fact.

    But the reality is that with Pan Africanism, Trade Unionism, BLP/DLP politics losing significant hold on the broad masses of people in Barbados, there is a very strong case for very viable progressive people centered ideologies to to be exploited by the relevant people and to be used in furtherance of the greater empowerment and enfranchisement of the masses and middle classes of people in this country.

    PDC


  7. and the beat goes on Diamonds International asks for retraction from Sir Roy Trotman !

  8. The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall Avatar
    The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall

    @PDC… A simple question:

    When you achieve your goal of becoming the leaders of Barbados, and do everything you say you promise you will do…

    How will you buy anything from away?

    It is an honest question.

    Please answer.

  9. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    David

    At 5:21 you asked, “How do workers fight back or is it too late?”

    The answer is quite simple – JOIN UNITY WORKERS UNION!

  10. old onion bags Avatar
    old onion bags

    LOL
    I see Caswell ready to CUT SOME ASS…………..but did Onions not warn all about 2 weeks ago (LIME)…that all this shit go float to the Top…as these slackers see the indecisiveness that prevails …and READY TO TEST IT..
    Well you see for yourselves….


  11. @David
    “We would hope that Sir Roy would investigate the facts and, once he is satisfied that he has been mis-informed, would withdraw his uncalled for remarks.”

    let’s see.


  12. Apology, not from the Knight of Harmony Hall or the Duke of York , or whatever name he goes by. Never!

  13. old onion bags Avatar
    old onion bags

    @ Prodigal
    Sir Roy apologies what……you mind these pack of cards….you believe that DI mangnt. man … given the state of this industrial climate ? I would bet my right hand is only because talk of police came in that ..he ran to the BCCI for shelter….When last you went in that store before ? I had a personal dealin g wid that man once….and I was not impressed. You see the tourists ain’t coming ..so heads gotta roll..simple..Do you think he would say otherwise…ask yourself why the workers decided to seek joining the Union AT THIS TIME….The man

  14. Adrian Hinds Avatar

    Sir Roy may not have been 100% accurate in this instance; but foreign born employers in Barbados have not treated to Bajans fairly at all. Were I Sir Roy my response would be specific to the numbers fired and the reason if the original position could not be substantiated.

    Not all trade unions are relevant. The sad thing is, those that need to be scale back if not done away with, are headed by Unionists who seem to still have the fight in them, and this energy is the very thing that should be brought to bear on some of these foreign born business people in Barbados.

    Wish that it were possible to switch public sector union leadership with that of the private sector trade union, and scale back the need for BSTU, BUT, NUPW, etc. They are all serving very little purpose and making a lot of money on the taxpayers back. Bajan workers are being treated unfairly in the private sector, while Bajan workers are over-paid, and are not productive in the public sector; the respective Unions carry a lot of responsibility for these occurrences in both sectors.

  15. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    In light of the responses and denials from BCCI and Diamonds International, Sir Roy cannot remain silent. This issue must not be allowed to blow away. If it can be shown that Sir Roy was not speaking the truth he would not only have brought the BWU into disrepute but he would have brought discredit to the entire trade union movement. Again if that were the case he should not wait to be pushed by his executive council: he should jump.

    Additionally, the reference to the national origin of the owner of Diamonds International is completely out of place, and as a senator, who is sworn to uphold the Constitution his actions are even more reprehensible. The Acting Governor-General should also take him out of his misery and declare his seat in the Senate vacant.

    National origin or race has nothing to do with how employers should behave. If any employer breaks the law he should suffer the consequences. I know of a black entrepreneur, whose business is supported by Government, who can only be described as the boss from hell. He has young people working under the most inhumane conditions and when they complain to him, he would say I did not send and call you: you came to me looking for a job and if you don’t like it you can go. His business use heavy machinery connected to long extension cords which run through pools of water when it rains. If the boys refuse to operate the machinery under those conditions, they are dismissed. Additionally, because of the nature of the business there is always the presence of rats. When he sets poison the rats would die and decay and the workers have to endure the stench or be fired. I know that BWU and the Labour Department are aware and yet there is no relief for those workers.

  16. old onion bags Avatar
    old onion bags

    ALL LIME outlets closed……hmmm..what’s up doc?…..Something in the air fa sure


  17. @onions
    just heard the news too… something’s rotten in Denmark. Let’s hear Lime’s statement first… Private Sector also criticised the Employees Rights Bill and requested amendments. Seems like private sector bosses smelling blood in the water and going for the proverbial kill.

  18. Prodigal Son Avatar

    old onions,
    How comes we have not heard a word of condemnation from the likes of Irene Sandiford Garner on women’s rights after the despicable way in which Donna Hunte Cox’s exit from NCF was handled?

    Mrs Sandiford Garner was all over the media saying she is a champion for women’s rights and how nasty the BLP was to move Mia Mottley as leader even though she knew it was done democratically. She had a role to talk. Now they have done it to Ms Hunte Cox, not a word and we have a DLP woman as the minister of Labour.Can you believe this? A woman also serves as minister of Foreign Affairs!

    It is wrong which ever government does it. Certainly a position like CEO of NCF in its contract, there would be a clause giving three months notice on either of a decision to renew or to terminate. The lady was treated with discourtesy to be handed a letter after four pm, what time did she had to clear her desk?

    The chairman would do well to remember that chairpersons dont last too long and what go around comes around. Ms Hunte Cox will have the last laugh.

  19. old onion bags Avatar
    old onion bags

    @ Prodi
    You forgetting Dr.Cox not from St.James South, St.Andrew or Sin John.
    Serious though they treat she too shabby….The good Dr. feeling really get hurt I hear…She did fighting tears…But I did always thought the lady politicians had each other backs. Irene said that the sisterhood did “TIGHT”
    Boy sign are wonders..signs are wonders…

    What ya make of this LIME thing? We now got AX, Di and LIME simmering..who next ?


  20. @Caswell

    Congrats on making it to the Business Authority!

    BTW have you heard the private sector is kicking up dust about how onerous the about to be enacted Employment Rights Bill will be on their businesses? Wasn’t the private sector part of the feedback process?

  21. The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall Avatar
    The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall

    @BU.David: “…about to be enacted Employment Rights Bill will be on their businesses?

    One might reasonably wonder why the promised Freedom of Information Act (FoIA) didn’t come first.

    Oh… Of course….


  22. On the subject of the LIME dispute which seems to have flared up, did PM Stuart eve made a public statement that he had resolved the issue? Seem to recall it was Sir Roy who delegated the announcement to Stuart. Willing to be proved wrong. It will be interesting to hear the BWU’s statement.


  23. @Chris

    The reason is probably Minister Suckoo needs something to hang her hat on with a campaign to be fought soon.

  24. The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall Avatar
    The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall

    @BU.David: “The reason is probably Minister Suckoo needs something to hang her hat on with a campaign to be fought soon.

    But how can they “hang their hat” on anything when they didn’t deliver on what they promised?

    FoIA. FoIA. FoIA. FoIA. FoIA. FoIA…

    It was promised.

    Why wasn’t it delivered?


  25. Chris Halsall,

    You wrote in your May 2, 2012, 7:10 pm blog: “When you achieve your goal of becoming the leaders of Barbados, and do everything you say you promise you will do…

    How will you buy anything from away?

    It is an honest question.

    Please answer.”

    Chris, the answer is simple: by doing and creating some of the things that many people in Barbados and others have been doing and creating for years better and far more effeciently at the lowest costs possible, and coming up with some newer very effecient more modernized processes to help produce world class items and services to help earn precious foreign exchange for the country.

    The will still be exports coming out of Tourism, Agriculture, Manufacturing, International Business, etc.

    By a future PDC Government removing Taxation, Interests Rates, Institutional Repayable Loans for Productive Purposes, by its Reducing Institutional Debt to the lowest levels possible, reducing the Cost of Use Of Money to the lowest levels possible, by making exports paid for in local currency/”prices”, by making imports into Barbados zero-“priced” at all points of entry, by Abolishing ALL exchange Rates Parities with the Barbados Dollar, et al, will impact most positively on the productive and distributive sectors in the country, and thus make sure that Barbados becomes more competitive and enterprising in the international political economy.

    PDC


  26. David; Yes, that’s my recollection also. The PM as usual said nothing, not even a disclaimer that the matter was solved. There was also no statement that I saw coming from the Lime side. Trotman looks as if he’s in deep doo doo with this matter also, following the Royal Shop, Sandy Lane and perhaps a few others. The agreement that Sir Roy hinted at always looked suspect.

    Once again, this matter suggests that the PM should think long and hard before stepping into any industrial situations, especially Private Sector ones over which his office have minimal direct leverage, without the foreknowledge that his minions had already solved the situation leaving him only to look good for the Cameras.

    Re. Sir Roy; Maybe its time for him to take up his well earned retirement, rather than leading the BWU into oblivion.


  27. @Chris

    But politicians promise all the time, it is what they do.

    In fact the origin of the word politician has its root in Latin which means…?

  28. The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall Avatar
    The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall

    @PDC: “…by making imports into Barbados zero-”priced” at all points of entry, by Abolishing ALL exchange Rates Parities with the Barbados Dollar, et al,

    Let’s run a thought experiment…

    Provide 1000 Bajans with a single tomato each for no cost.

    Prove that you can do this, and you might get some votes.

  29. Observing (and relaxing) Avatar
    Observing (and relaxing)

    @chris
    What freedom of information? we get promised that one recently??? all the talk is about integrity integrity integrity


  30. As far as the FOIA goes isn’t there the opportunity for Senator Orlando Marville to speak to the issue even it is to voice disappointment?

  31. The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall Avatar
    The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall

    @BU.David: “But politicians promise all the time, it is what they do.

    quod politici iusti cognoscitur mentiri non habere non dicit quod promittunt electorate

  32. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    David
    The less you speak of Senator Marville the better. Government compromised him : he is an independent senator for crying out loud. He should not have accepted any assignment from Government. His slip is showing.


  33. @Caswell

    Why would you suggest that Marville should withhold his service/expertise?

    He should come out as an Independent Senator and give us a position on it.

    He is a Senator and he should not renege on his role as an advocate for the people in the Upper Chamber.


  34. Chris,

    We are at this moment hoping that you are not trivializing that particular strategy.

    What we are saying here is that the Ports of entry will have substantial autonomy to charge importers – on the basis of prevailing market conditions generally – for services provided to them (importers) as a result of the general costs incurred (adminstration/transaction) by the Ports of Entry.

    PDC

  35. The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall Avatar
    The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall

    @PDC: “What we are saying here is that the Ports of entry will have substantial autonomy to charge importers

    But, if there is no cost of money, then the money is valueless.

    You have studied economics in school.

    Yes?


  36. @David and Caswell
    Independent, seriously??


  37. I hope people understand how the highest levels of our land botch up what appers to be the most mundane and straightforward things… “difference in interpretation?” After 10 + hours of negotiating?

    http://www.nationnews.com/articles/view/lime-still-committed/

    sigh


  38. @observing

    One id left to wonder after reading the Nation report why the BWU had to strike over a matter which required a simple clarification. Would it not make sense to strike after the clarification was given to confirm the difference in interpretation?

  39. old onion bags Avatar
    old onion bags

    Who is it in the press that calls on me?
    I hear a tongue shriller than all the music
    Cry “Caesar!” Speak, Caesar is turn’d to hear.
    Beware the ides of March.


  40. I am wondering and I hope that I am wrong but I keep thinking that Sir. Roy might be using the situation at LIME to wipe the egg off his face that he got from Diamonds International.

  41. The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall Avatar
    The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall

    @oob: “Beware the ides of March.

    Or, in the original, “Ἀπόδοτε οὖν τὰ Καίσαρος Καίσαρι καὶ τὰ τοῦ Θεοῦ τῷ Θεῷ

  42. old onion bags Avatar
    old onion bags

    @Chris Halsall (the Roman)
    Friends Romans countrymen…lend me thy ears

    I heard thee speak me a speech once, but it was never acted,
    or if it was, not above once; for the play, I remember, pleas’d not
    the million, ’twas caviare to the general. But it was, as I receiv’d it
    —and others, whose judgments in such matters cried in the top of
    mine—an excellent play, well digested in the scenes, set down
    with as much modesty as cunning.

    CHRIS YA OLE DOG……tief my thunda

  43. The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall Avatar
    The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall

    @oob: “tief my thunda

    Nos sunt rectam.


  44. @caswell
    Sir Roy got more egg to wipe

    @David
    one really is left to wonder. The entire company shut down over a “misinterpretation” in a letter written by the “PM” after “marathon negotiations”

    And wunna really feel AX gine be as straightforward as a Commission? sigh.


  45. And Observing; a misinterpretation on 2 clauses that were subject to further negotiations. Nobody has indicated that negotiations on these clauses were either started or completed but we do know that the PM has been very busy at meetings / functions outside of Barbados over the past few weeks.

    Why indeed would Sir Roy call a strike in these circumstances? or was it a wildcat strike? We need to hear both the Gen Sec and the PM’s sides of the story.


  46. quotation from above ‘Sir Roy has threatened to shut the country down if the foreign owned entity does not review it position. Caswell Franklyn who heads Unity Trade Union and veteran trade unionist has suggested Sir Roy should escalate the matter to the police – Barbados Underground’

    Stupid. It is the mouthings of the idiot Roy Trotman that should be reported and escalated to international rights organisation, the context of the ‘Egyptian Jew’ reference is a racial slur, pure and simple.

    He shoudl resign. Playing to the crowd, raising racial tenstions so that he SEEMS to remain relevant.

    No, he is an irrelevant jackass.


  47. Most of the writers above went on hearsay and not facts, inflammatory, excitable rubbish. We also do not need an Employment Rights Bill, after another year or two there will not be much employment.


  48. Chris

    I was saying that the matter that Sir. Roy complained about would amount to a criminal offence and suggesting that there would be no need to shut down the country if someone had indeed committed a criminal offence. As far as I am aware you still report crime to the police and that would have been all that he was required to do.

  49. The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall Avatar
    The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall

    @All…

    Just for the record, the person posting as “Chris” is not me.

    Not that I have an exclusive claim on the name of course. Just wishing to be clear.

  50. Not That Chris Avatar
    Not That Chris

    per thhe nation quting Little Man Trotman, “If I have said something that has offended anyone, show me where the offence is; when I see the offence, I am big enough to apologize for it,” he said.

    “I never set out to offend anyone, I never offended anyone, and therefore, there is nothing for me to be bothered about, but people take offence when none is given.”

    Is this jackass for real? He cannot see where he has offended? Tlell that to the many people worldiwde reading about this racial slur from the ‘Union Boss’ in Barbados.

    Bad enough the ratings agencies on our backs, not an idiot has to use racial slurs to make foreign investors run even further.

    One would think a bajan would know better. Bajans work everywhere including alongside Jewish people. Bajans should know that bigotry can attack them too and respect the moral that treating others with respect and dignity is a necessity, not just a moral right.

    But no, no he. Seriously, is he going senile, or just feeling irrelevant?

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading