The Late Prime Minister David Thompson (L), Leroy Parris (R), former Chairman CLICO Holdings (B'dos) Ltd

The CLICO fiasco continues to hog the news. It is a story which has tainted the government of Barbados for almost the duration of its tenure. BU remains sympathetic to the ‘sufferation’ of thousands of Executive Flexible Premium Annuity (EFPA) CLICO investors and the others. Many were lured by the greed of high interest rates, some appeared to be ignorant to the benefit of diversifying personal investment portfolios. What makes the CLICO fiasco one with a difference is the extent regional governments and regulators are to be held accountable for CLICO’s ‘failure’. In the case of Barbados a very close relationship between the late Prime Minister David Thompson and former Chairman of CLICO Holdings Leroy Parris added to the intrigue.

In his wrapup to the this year’s budget Minister Chris Sinckler promised CLICO policyholders that there is light at the end of the tunnel. Despite the snippets here and there CLICO investors continue to stumble in the dark. The word on the street is that the judicial managers have recommended an injection of capital into CLICO to fund the shortfall in assets of 152 million dollars that will see CLICO morphing to a new company. BU believes if this is true it is laced with uncertainty.

The insurance business requires confidence from the market to be successful. Is there a precedent in the region where an insurance company was restructured successfully? Given the controversy which has enveloped CLICO most if not all of CLICO policyholders want their money. Given the harsh economic times the desire to withdraw the maturing EFPA’s will be strong. Such a sentiment does not bode well for a rebranded company funded with CLICO assets plus tax dollars. What are the alternatives? To liquidate the assets of CLICO will take years.

The claim by Neal Bisnath during the Commission of Enquiry into the collapse of CL Financial and the Hindu Credit Union (HCU) – an attorney from CLICO – that “LAWRENCE DUPREY was paid $1.1 billion from the deposits of CLICO policyholders in the five years prior to CL Financial seeking a billion dollar bailout from the Government” has caused many to sit up. The revelation, if true, is not only an indictment on Duprey but also on current and former CLICO executives, Central Bank of Trinidad, Government of Trinidad and CLICO Auditors. In the CLICO debate we have tended to personalized the arguments and in the process many who should already be fired or incarcerated are operating as if nothing has transpired.

BU’s position regarding CLICO is known. Both political parties have contributed to where we find ourselves. Our regulators have been weak and fell asleep on the job. To be expected the Barbados Labour Party has sought to make political mileage from the fiasco although it must be stated that under Owen Arthur the noise has become muffled.

Some may not appreciate the remark but somewhere in the great beyond the late Prime Minister David Thompson is wearing a smile. When he died he took many secrets with him about CLICO. Let us not forget he was Leroy Parris’ lawyer and also represented CLICO at times. Time will tell if his wife who succeeded him in Parliament will be forced to defend his legacy.

On the sideline Al Barrack owed 65 million plus interest is observing how the CLICO fiasco plays out.


  1. @ balance
    The $10m bonus contract prepared, witnessed and signed by David Thompson & Associates law firm is proof that Parris did the same s Gakal and Duprey.


  2. It seems that the policy holders were led like lambs to the slaughter. Like the Trade Confirmers clients, Sharma’s clients and no one was made to pay for these criminal acts. It seems that when locals invest they are taken for all that they have by unscrupulous companies. The Government watch dogs seem to be totally incompetent and to pass legislation to protect themselves from negligence is scandalous to say the least.

    When the dust has settled, Barbadians will have no confidence in investing in these get rich schemes from these so called safe companies. This would be a very bitter pill to swallow and the lesson learnt is to TRUST NO ONE OR ANY GOVERNMENT IN POWER that is promoting such a scheme.

    As long as Government ministers and private company CEO’s are allowed get away with robbing their clients of their monies there will never be any Justice served. It is sad that every few years this disgusting serpent will raise its head again posing as a legitimate business waiting for its prey.


  3. I am also concerned about the Credit Unions where the peoples money can be seen as an opportunity to take them for all they have. Can we trust the legislation that is in place to protect the clients?


  4. Overlooked in all this mess is the role that the Supervisor of Insurance played in the collapse of CLICO.

    Unfortunately when unqualified individuals get patronage plums from Gov’t with oversight of important industries negative results should be expected.

    The Bajan phrase comes to mind “Monkey Handling Gun”


  5. The last few years have shown what happens when people are duped by clever sales and marketing strategies.

    Hopefully the BU family will be very careful how they invest their hard earned cash.

    The world is still full of con men hatching new get rich schemes.Some are in Barbados.


  6. Even the clerks working at CLICO knew that the Executive Flexible Premium Annuities were fraudulent pieces of paper and when the clerks refused to handle these pieces of paper CLICO fired them. Those who were happy to defraud the public were rewarded with big salaries, big bonuses and even bigger cars.

    Ah yes the sweet rewards that come from robbing widows and orphans.

    Then again CLICO long had a reputation for firing unmarried female employees who became pregnant and gave birth. Of course CLICO did not fire any men who impregnated anybody, and they did not fire women who had abortions. And all while this nastiness was going on pur dear PM Sweet Cakes was their lawyer.

    And now we are expected to bail out CLICO.

    Even while nobody has sought to recover any of the money paid in monster salaries to CLICO executives (and their lawyer Sweet Cakes)


  7. Since the last AGM of the credit union when all of those issues were raised, what happened? Is everything is back to normal?
    Well I am trying to build up my savings in the credit union but a little jittery because I have little confidence in the Registrar of Coops because he like he does let some foolishness happen with the poor people money with these credit cards and nuff overseas trips for these directors. If any of those people who run the credit union feel that they have free money to spend like Clico they could try it. Somebody may turn ignorant.
    It looks like you should save your money in a box.


  8. The information provided in the news stories this week suggests that the special forensic audit is merely to investigate the movement of funds that is missing between the various Clico companies only, ie. intra CIL group and inter CLICO related companies only. The Parrises and the Thompsons and the Arthurs, etc. are home scot free. There will be no investigation, no audit of monies paid from CLICO to these entities. The cover up has already been effected by the brief parameters of the forensic audit that have been released so far. Indeed, the fine print might well find that the remit for the audit may be even more limited than I’ve suggested above. I’d be most grateful if someone with the necessary knowledge would prove me wrong about the above.

    As far as I read it, there will be no scope in that audit to investigate any moneys paid to parties and individuals for political campaigning here and in the Eastern Caribbean islands; looking the other way in terms of regulating CLICO; the payment of exorbitant fees to prominent lawyers including David Thompson; the exorbitant bonuses paid to CLICO big-ups and their personal companies; etc. There is therefore no provision made for identifying what might have been a substantial portion in the hemorrhage of CLICO funds over the years and those of us who are asking for justice to be brought to the main culprits who engineered CLICO’s collapse by their greed and the use of property bought out of CLICO funds for defraying the pay out to policy holders and other debtors, will find out that this is definitely not on the cards.

    There will be a lot of talk but nothing will happen to the CLICO principals and their carefully and expensively bought political benefactors.

    The carefully chosen JM has done a good job.


  9. Perhaps hope is not lost.

    If monies were appropriated from CLICO Life and funnelled through CLICO Holdings the cloak of cover would have been via the EC businesses.

    Barbados has exchange control, not the EC.

    BU understands many of our elite citizens have been opening accounts in the EC.


  10. David not that not true the Barbados business could have sent out all they want. All they have to do to get around the exchange control is attribute funds to shareholders dividends/ Investment in parent company. The right paper work bypasses exchange controls. Every year with sagicor/bl&p/lime the overseas share holders are paid in us ( if legally allowed or their own local currency which is convert from the us dollar dividend payout). so C&W worldwide get a near 30-35 million us dividend payout each year. bl & p majority owner emera would have gotten a 40% stake in the bl&p total dividend last year. The right paper work with any transaction will bypass exchange control once the banks have enough us to send out.


  11. Anthony; Are you saying that private bajan citizens, even though elite, in contrast to large corporate entities, would not have the facility to bypass exchange control? In either case would’nt the initial transactions from Bdos to EC territory be recorded in a way that is transparent to the exchange control process and so be capable of being tracked in a forensic audit? Of course, further transactions out of or within the EC countries might not be amenable to tracking.

    Grateful for some guidance here.


  12. No i saying that corporation have easier access to paper work which will bypass exchange controls. elites also have access but it slight harder to move the money. The transaction are monitored and can used in forensic audit. The bank used to keep records for 10 years don’t remember if it is shorter now or not. Money transfer are easy to track once you have access to the bank record. but for that to happen you need to subpoena both end of the transaction to make sure it didn’t start/end somewhere else


  13. Clone said ….”It looks like you should save your money in a box”

    It is out with the ATM and in with the UTM*

    UTM…under the mattress


  14. @anthony

    The flaw in your thinking is that your are not filtering as a person would who is scamming. It would be a legit transaction for the Regional CLICO Office to fund projects at its satellite branches, construction as an example. Of course it would have to secure Central Bank approval but the rub would be in how the monies are utilized at the satellite branches.


  15. Nothing will come of this CLICO issue. The JM was hand picked for the job and while the first scam robbed the policy holders and the investors, the second and maybe even bigger scam is going to rob the people of Barbados by having the government either inject or guarantee the money needed to keep the ship afloat.

    It is sickening that this level of secrecy can prevail given the exposure of thoughs of ordinary Bajans to financial dissaster if the solutions are arm length transactions and the players are not conflicted or have other self interest.


  16. If the dots are followed diligently they will lead to Dodds.


  17. Random Thoughts wrote:
    Then again CLICO long had a reputation for firing unmarried female employees who became pregnant and gave birth. Of course CLICO did not fire any men who impregnated anybody, and they did not fire women who had abortions. And all while this nastiness was going on our dear PM Sweet Cakes was their lawyer.

    And now we are expected to bail out CLICO.

    And we are apparently expected to pay for a tomb to honour our late, dear leader Sweet Cakes’ memory, Rumour has it the “capstone” to this monument will be a raised fist with extended middle finger.


  18. The CLICO scam is unique in Barbados in that the Government of the day apparently openly undertook to actually REPAY those debtors fleeced in the scam very early on in the game as compared with the then government’s reactions to the persons losing their savings or equities in the Trade Confirmer’s and other earlier debacles.

    The CLICO scam is unique in that there is good anecdotal evidence that CLICO’s modus operandi was to make Governments political personages and Parties throughout the region beholden to it through the provision of huge amounts of largesse for personal and Party gratification. There is no indication that this was the modus operandi of the other big entities that fell earlier.

    The Supervisors of Insurance was probably not as culpable in the almost non regulation of CLICO’s apparent excesses as was the Ministers of Finance. The SOI is after all a creature of the MInister of Finance.

    Correlate the first two indications above and see that it is almost certain that the official reaction and exclusions from investigation will have more to do with the second paragraph than any concern for bilked investors.


  19. @Checkit-out

    We cannot ignore that the SOI has the legal bite to shutdown an insurance company which is non compliant. No political speak can refute.


  20. David

    I hope that you are aware that the Supervisor of Insurance is a public officer who is independent on paper only. Like many public officers the Supervisor of Insurance has an independent regulatory role but that independence is often overridden by ministerial edit with or without the necessary legal authority.

    Let me give you an example. People who breed mosquitos on their properties; create nuisances; or otherwise infringe the Health Services regulations are subject to criminal proceedings instituted by the Chief Environmental Health Officer for the particular district. In reality, the Chief Environmental Health Officer’s professional determination is overridden by the Minister of Health. Mind you many times the Inspector is bribed with a few pounds of pork from a stinking pig farm like that at Rock hHll, St. Thomas.

    If public officers ever venture to conscientiously carry out their professional duty without reference to a minister, who in most cases, have no role those officers would be transferred or worse yet they would never see another promotion.

    Have you ever wondered why the Director of Public Prosecutions, Charles Leacock, who is an extremely capable lawyer, has not been promoted to judge but has seen several lesser mortals bypass him. Well if you have ever wondered: I am wondering too.


  21. @Caswell

    Who will cut the Gordian Knot?


  22. David

    Everybody is looking to somebody else to be Alexander the Great to cut the gordian knot. You would be surprised how many people call me to expose corruption that they have personal knowledge of but are afraid to blow the whistle.

    Since December 31, 2007 the Public Service Act makes it an offence to know of wrongdoing, including criminal wrongdoing, and not report it. However, there is one drawback, you must report the wrongdoing in accordance with the guidelines but to date no guidelines have been published.

    We have an instance where the Chief Marshal admitted, to the Barbados Today, that they have not complied with the rules to call in the Police and the Director of Finance for Marshals who have misappropriated funds that they collected. The head of department is required by the Financial Rules to inform the Police and Director of Finance.

    Before we go off accusing the Chief Marshal of not reporting the misappropriations in accordance with the Rules: he is not the head of department. That honour goes to the Registrar of the Supreme Court who sometimes acts as a judge of the High Court.

    I also know of one instance where a marshal reported to the Registrar that his superior officer had returned a warrant to the court with an affidavit saying that a person could not be found. The marshals were able to find him to serve two summonses. It is obvious that the affidavit which was sworn and returned to the court constituted perjury. But so far the officer has not been made to account for the offence.

    It would that we like it so!


  23. @Caswell

    You point is well taken. We have a system undermined by inefficiency which does not hold people accountable.


  24. CLICO & SHEEP

    There is saying…… “You are a bunch of sheep”

    -you are afraid to speak up for yourselves, afraid to come forward and say what’s on their minds. You are shy, meekish, vulnerable and you simply act cowardly.
    -sheep (other than the animal itself) also means a person(s) lacking intelligence or common sense. Same as knucklehead, airhead, nitwit etc.

    It would appear that this quote is especially applicable in Barbados, particularly in reference to the islands know BLACK BELLY version.

    Once a thriving, organized, reputable and law-abiding country under the guidance of Britain, the country since independence and BLACK LEADERSHIP has wow-fully lapsed into a third world country, stagnant, corrupt and failing society. I hear the saying “we can see the light at the end of the tunnel”, it would appear to be a small nearly burnt out candle at the end of an extremely long and narrowing tunnel. Can anarchy be far away.


  25. Wily Coyote | September 26, 2011 at 11:35 AM |
    … or is it simply that Black is easier seen than White?

  26. millertheanunnaki Avatar

    “Once a thriving, organized, reputable and law-abiding country under the guidance of Britain, the country since independence and BLACK LEADERSHIP has wow-fully lapsed into a third world country, stagnant, corrupt and failing society”
    So very true, Wily Coyote!!
    This state of affairs does not augur well for future FDI or access to low cost foreign loans.


  27. Wily Coyote what are you smoking or snorting?


  28. A friend of mine who is very educated invested a lot of money in CLICO. I asked her how a sophisticated woman like her could have invested so much money in a company headed by LEROY PARRIS. Her response was that she was drawn to the high rate of return. People forgot their commonsense.

    I am in two minds rather my tax dollars should be used to repay CLICO investors when Leroy Parris is still not being held accountable and is still socialising with cream of this society. So he is no leper in DLP circles.

    I need to hear from Oliver Jordan if the friendship between him and Leroy is clouding his judgement. Deloitte has been paid 1.3 million already. I see Terrance Thornhill on DLPTV now as a chairman of the Enterprise Growth Fund.

    Heads need to roll for this before taxpayers dollars are doled out. Assets of Leroy Parris need to be seized, all the phony companies set up for him by the dead king like Brandlee which lists Faye Wharton Parris and Mara Thompson as directors need to be investigated as well as Families First. The DEMOCRATIC LABOUR PARTY needs also to be investigated as Wikileaks alleges that Peter Wickham told US officials that CLICO gave the DLP BDS34 MILLION DOLLARS for their last campaign.

  29. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar

    RANDOM THOUGHTS

    “in the upcoming election there is no way any DLP candidate can get my vote.

    NOT ONE ON THEM.”

    ………..and you claim that you don’t support B nor D.

    The more the monkey climb the more he show he tail.


  30. Prodigal Son; Where did you find a Wikileaks allegation about CLICO payments to the DLP?

    When was Terrance Thornhill made Chairman of EGFL?

  31. millertheanunnaki Avatar

    When policyholders find out the final bill for the JM fees, along with the forensic audit fees that must be paid in foreign currency, they will ‘hit the roof”. Millions of dollars will be siphoned off from their ongoing premium payments. LD+PL+TT+OJ = Fraud


  32. CCC; Your logic, or lack thereof, often astounds.


  33. @All…

    I’m just wondering… Would anyone like to help me write a book?

    The working title is “Machiavelli for Dummies”.

    I’m serious. I can be reached at mfd@chalsall.com.

    Look forward to hearing from you…

  34. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar

    I can’t believe what I am reading now.

    When I said a long, long time ago that the Supervisor of Insurance, the chicken man, and by extension his boss Arthur should be held responsible for the fiasco that is clico, I got ‘buse stink. Even the blog thought that I was crazy.

    The Audit firm which did CLICO’s yearly audit should also be held accountable. They too failed to do their jobs properly thus leading to misrepresentation of the company’s true financial position.

    If you are going to lock up Leroy Parris, then also lock up the former Supervisor of Insurance, the former Barbados Labour Party PM and the Seniors of the Audit firm which did CLICO’s audit every single year and reported that nothing was wrong. They all failed not only CLICO’s policy holders but all the citizens of Barbados as well

  35. millertheanunnaki Avatar

    CLICO Auditors ought be asked to explain their position by way of a class action lawsuit brought against them by policyholders. This scandal should also be brought to the attention of the Auditors’ parent company in the UK since it can have serious ramifications for the professional integrity of international audit firm.


  36. CCC. I can’t believe that at last you have written something that partially makes a modicum of sense. Bravo!


  37. millertheanunnaki | September 26, 2011 at 1:50 PM |

    An excellent point you have made. I feel that it is worthwhile to pursue from this angle. If the auditors were honest and professional they should have waved the red flag a long time ago.


  38. We should do this and we should do that we should a lot of things. What is required to DO is getting information which to date has been coming in drips and drabs from those in the know.


  39. Guess that where FOI legislation would come in handy. Is the final judiciary report for clico available for reading at the fsc as yet ?


  40. @All… With regards to “Machiavelli for Dummies”, I’m thinking the first chapter should focus on why those beside us so want us to fail.

    Hmmmmm…


  41. Didn’t the managing partner of CLICO’s auditors not become the chairman of the Barbados Tourism Investment Inc (Btii) after the Judical Manager resigned that position?


  42. checkit,

    Be careful downloading from the wikileaks site but I read it on line. I dont know when Terrence Thornhill was appointed but I saw him on DLP TV last week and the news item said that he was the chairman. You never know what this damn lying party is up to.


  43. @Chris

    It one word: GREED

    It is a universal problem.

    Do you think it is any coincidence that the CLICO issue is a regional one?


  44. @David: “It one word: GREED It is a universal problem

    @David: “Do you think it is any coincidence that the CLICO issue is a regional one?

    No.

    But I do find it interesting how few leaders will dare speak to this problem….


  45. It is interesting that the opposition isn’t really coming up against the government on the CLICO issue. The silence is deafening.

    Are they in a sinmilar glass house as the government, and therefore can’t throw any stones?


  46. @What is This? “Are they in a sinmilar[sic] glass house as the government, and therefore can’t throw any stones?

    Never be afraid of throwing stones.

    You can learn a lot from launching mass and observing the impacts….


  47. “GREED it is a universal problem”

    Could it be because mankind still has, in some ways, a primitive brain that is wired to help us survive in a primitive lifestyle like that of a hunter-gather but is not that well suited to assist us in adapting to life in a complex, modern, “civilized” society of relative abundance?

    One author thinks this the case (see below). Just throwing this out for your consideration. (For those who accept the theory of evolution at any rate.)

    Dangerously Addictive: Why We Are Biologically Ill-Suited to the Riches of Modern America
    By Peter C. Whybrow, MD

    The United States is the quintessential trading nation,and for the past quarter century we have worshiped the“free” market as an ideology rather than for what it is—a natural product of human social evolution and aset economic tools with which to construct a just and equitable society. Under the spell of this ideology and the false promise of instant riches, America’s immigrant values of thrift, prudence, and community concern— traditionally the foundation of the Dream—have been hijacked by an all-consuming self-interest. The astonishing appetite of the American consumer now determines some 70 percent of all economic activity in the United States. And yet, in this land of opportunity and material comfort—where we enjoy the 12-inch dinner plate, the 32-ounce soda, and the 64-inch TV screen— more and more citizens feel time starved, overworked, and burdened by debt. Epidemic rates of obesity, anxiety, depression, and family dysfunction are accepted as the norm.

    It is the paradox of modernity that as choice and material prosperity increase, health and personal satisfaction decline. This is now an accepted truth. And yet it is the rare American who manages to step back from the hedonic treadmill long enough to savor his or her
    good fortune. Indeed, for most of us, regardless of what we have, we want more and we want it now. The roots of this conundrum—of this addictive striving—are to be found in our evolutionary history. As creatures of the natural world, having evolved under conditions of
    danger and scarcity, we are by instinct reward-seeking animals that discount the future in favor of the immediate present. As a species we have no familiarity with the seductive prosperity and material riches that exist in America today. A novel experience, it is both compelling and confusing.

    Brain systems of immediate reward were a vital survival adaptation millennia ago when finding a fruit tree was a rare delight and dinner had a habit of running away or flying out of reach. But living now in relative
    abundance, when the whole world is a shopping mall and our appetites are no longer constrained by limited resources, our craving for reward — be that for money, the fat and sugar of fast food, or for the novel gadgetry of modern technology — has become a liability and a
    hunger that has no bounds. Our nature has no built-in braking system. More is never enough.
    (emphasis added /GM)

    Continued at:
    http://www.postcarbon.org/Reader/PCReader-Whybrow-Addictive.pdf


  48. Prodigal on wrote the following:

    The DEMOCRATIC LABOUR PARTY needs also to be investigated as Wikileaks alleges that Peter Wickham told US officials that CLICO gave the DLP BDS34 MILLION DOLLARS for their last campaign.
    ********
    When asked to provide a source he wrote the following
    “Be careful downloading from the wikileaks site but I read it on line.”

    Hey Prodigal, I heard that you were the biggest liar in Barbados.
    My source? I read it online


  49. @All… So correct if I am wrong…

    But we now have listen to the idiocy from Green Monkey and Sargeant…

    Sigh….


  50. Prodigal Son

    Could you point us to correct memo. There quite a few to search thru

Leave a Reply to anthonyCancel reply

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading